David Susilo
Screenwriter
- Joined
- May 8, 1999
- Messages
- 1,197
Let's make a list of unrealistic things on CSI
I don't know about many unrealistic things on CSI but the show always irk me when they try to show how they are isolating sound elements from a recording.
For example, CSI season 2, disc 2, 911 recording.
The original recording is one-track phone conversation. So how can they suddenly have multiple discrete track (operator's voice, victim's voice, engine noise)?
Worse, they tried to make it look more realistic by showing the forensic dude changing a knob or two on his mixing board to isolate sound even further.
Nothing is realistic in their ways of showing sound analysis.
The big question is, anybody else in the field (or similar) can point out other stupidities in this series?
PS: I love the show, btw
I don't know about many unrealistic things on CSI but the show always irk me when they try to show how they are isolating sound elements from a recording.
For example, CSI season 2, disc 2, 911 recording.
The original recording is one-track phone conversation. So how can they suddenly have multiple discrete track (operator's voice, victim's voice, engine noise)?
Worse, they tried to make it look more realistic by showing the forensic dude changing a knob or two on his mixing board to isolate sound even further.
Nothing is realistic in their ways of showing sound analysis.
The big question is, anybody else in the field (or similar) can point out other stupidities in this series?
PS: I love the show, btw