george kaplan
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2001
- Messages
- 13,063
We have these tourneys and there's always lots of disagreements, at least in part because of the different criteria we bring to bear. So, I thought it would be good to have a tourney where the criteria was explicit and see what happens.
For each matchup you will cast 4 votes.
1 - film you'd rather see (let's say you're on a flight and you get to pick which of the two films they play (uncensored )
2 - the more serious film
3 - the film that is better art
4 - which film you think is better overall (however you define that)
Now, for all of us, some of these categories are going to be redundant. But, I think which categories are redundant are going to vary from person to person. For example, some (like me) will see no difference between 1 or 3, whereas I know some will not think 1 and 3 are the same at all.
As far as the films, I'm stealing the top 64 from the HTF 100 revote thread and just using those.
Please cast 4 votes even if they are all the same. For example: Film X vs. Film Y
rather watch: X
more serious: X
better art: Y
better film: X
Bracket 1:
Taxi Driver vs. Sunset Blvd
For each matchup you will cast 4 votes.
1 - film you'd rather see (let's say you're on a flight and you get to pick which of the two films they play (uncensored )
2 - the more serious film
3 - the film that is better art
4 - which film you think is better overall (however you define that)
Now, for all of us, some of these categories are going to be redundant. But, I think which categories are redundant are going to vary from person to person. For example, some (like me) will see no difference between 1 or 3, whereas I know some will not think 1 and 3 are the same at all.
As far as the films, I'm stealing the top 64 from the HTF 100 revote thread and just using those.
Please cast 4 votes even if they are all the same. For example: Film X vs. Film Y
rather watch: X
more serious: X
better art: Y
better film: X
Bracket 1:
Taxi Driver vs. Sunset Blvd