Jason Bovberg
Stunt Coordinator
- Joined
- May 17, 2001
- Messages
- 75
A HUGE one for me is "After Hours" by Martin Scorsese.
So those of you with long lists of 30s films I wouldn't bet on them all reaching DVD. Technology moves so fast these days and I'm concerned a few won't make it before the next new video format comes along.
I tend to agree on this.
There was sooo much time for the studios to
throw just about everything they had onto VHS.
The current DVD format may be too short-lived
to see everything everyone wants released. Then
again, who knows how long it will take HD-DVD to
become mainstream.
The current DVD format may be too short-lived
to see everything everyone wants released. Then
again, who knows how long it will take HD-DVD to
become mainstream.
i think that backward compatability is going to be a must have for any HD dvd devices...for at least quite a while.
also, while i won't dispute the merits and benefits of HD, it really becomes evident with shot on HD video.
yes, there is improvement with most movies, especially 2.35 wide recent (last 30 yrs or so) epics, but i really don't see a substantial amount of benefit to be derived from an HD resolution copy of an academy ratio film from the thirties that has only had the most minimal of restoration...if any.
unless we are going to start getting into some inverse kind of anamorphic where the 1.37 film is horizontally stretched on disc to accomodate all available screen space and then pillar boxed at the display for improved resolution.
but that seems highly unlikely.
i think that 20's-50's films on dvd can happily co-exist with modern blockbusters on HD-dvd.
the buffs and fans seeking out the former are a little more forgiving of the circumstances and as long as the film looks properly transferd in its respective format, there shouldn't be a reason to bemoan the lack of a few pixels.
but i really don't see a substantial amount of benefit to be derived from an HD resolution copy of an academy ratio film from the thirties that has only had the most minimal of restoration...if any.Interesting point. I wonder just how much resolution you can go with before you get to the point where there is no need for more resolution.
Can an old movie benefit from HD-DVD? I assume so, but how much so? You can probably get a better picture on HD-DVD than with the standard DVD format, but is it as noticable a difference as the new movies that go from standard to HD?
It would seem that most of the 'detail' you'd get with an HD-DVD would be through image enhancements. And is this what historians really want? Don't you want what the original print was like and not added resolution?
I guess the best argument is in the compression. Since HD-DVD will have less compression, it's safe to assume that anything transfered to HD-DVD will look better than standard DVD because of the bit rates.
I guess the best argument is in the compression. Since HD-DVD will have less compression, it's safe to assume that anything transfered to HD-DVD will look better than standard DVD because of the bit rates.
Ah, but compression is a relative factor. It takes higher bit rates to encode HD material because of the higher resolution of the image, but that does not necessarily mean that the percentage of compression applied to the image is any less than an average SD DVD release.
I'm just a little worried that when HD-DVD hits, there will be alot more mpeg artifacting than people are used to seeing on standard DVDs.
but that does not necessarily mean that the percentage of compression applied to the image is any less than an average SD DVD release....but I'm assuming the bit rate will be high enough to allow for even less artifact than standard DVD. i.e. I thought the HD compression to resolution ratio was better than standard DVD, but I could be wrong.
Eating RaoulYES! Where the heck IS that one?! Should've been on DVD by now, I feel. A gem of a movie.
Gordy
Then again, who knows how long it will take HD-DVD to become mainstream.That's the Big Question, as far as I'm concerned. That's going to be a marketing nightmare: How do you entice and convince Joe Sixpack to buy a new DVD player? As far as Joe is concerned, there was the standard DVD player, DVD recorders and now HD-DVD - "But I have already got a DVD player!", he will say, and when you try to explain that HD-DVD is better, he will say "Prove it!" and so you present a demonstration... on a HD-TV! "But I already bought a new $1000 TV!!!", he'll say. If you ask me it's going to take a long time for HD-DVD to become mainstream and the norm. It may end up like DVD-Audio and SACD - badly marketed and reserved for hardcore HT consumers. At this point, it is all speculation and everyone is still looking forward to buying many, many films on standard DVD, so the Big Studios won't be in any hurry to leave the cow's udders half empty!
Gordy
Agreed...Eating Raoul should have been on my list as well. Fantastic flick, very funny.It was available a couple of years ago in an R4, PAL DVD. Don’t know if it is OOP or not.