Fox didn't remove the wires for The Day the Earth Stood Still either.
ABaglivi said:Too bad the discussion of this film is concentrating on wires. I hope the people at Paramount are not reading this thread and become discouraged about releasing it on Blu-ray.
My first experience with WotW was in the 60s too Reed, on a drive-in double-bill with Psycho (if I recall correctly, Paramount officially re-released them together like that). Neither film made me choke, but that was undoubtably the most glutonous double feast I'd seen...then or since.Reed Grele said:When I saw WOTW at my local theater as a young lad (circa early 1960's), I can't honestly say whether or not I remember seeing the wires. But I DO remember the vivid COLORS!
Not to mention the fact that near the end of the film when the martians war machines were destroying the world with their heat, and disintegration rays, I was so scared that I accidentally swallowed a hard candy that I had in my mouth, and almost choked!
I'd be willing to bet that wire removal work on these particular titles was more of a budgetary consideration than an artistic one.JoHud said:I agree with that. It's not like Criterion removed the wires or updated the special effects in Godzilla, and I don't think any of the Toho monster movies on blu-ray bothered either.
I think it is just some wishful thinking on part of some.Bob Furmanek said:I'm not even sure how this rumor got started, but I seriously doubt that anybody is going to take time and spend money to remove the wires from this film.
I can't agree enough!ROclockCK said:So if they just stop trying to appease modern video tastes and go back to a look that is closer to the original IB Technicolor, most of these issues regarding wire visibility, will, if not totally vanish, then certainly be minimized by a more correctly timed colour/gamma balance.
Just to clarify - Houdini is paired with Those Daring Young Men In Their Jaunty Jalopies.Tony DeCosa said:BTW, there is ONE Pal film that has already released on Blu ray: Houdini, in a release paired with Those Magnificent Men in Their Flying Machines. Unfortunately, not much care was taken with it. Paramount's DVD is actually better.
One solution would be for the studio to offer both "with" and "without" the wires, which would be similar to what they did with the Blu releases of the STAR TREK OS episodes with original vs. new effects. You could even toggle back and forth between both versions for comparison.Lromero1396 said:Because of the significant cult following this film has, a lot of fans would get angry if the wires were completely removed and the release wouldn't have as big of a market. If any digital work is done on them, it should only be to lessen the prescence of the wires (this can be done without any alteration to the wires) Like I said, the release should be color-timed accurately with correct brightness and contrast in any case. End of story. Why not reach a happy medium and just color it correctly?