Patrick Sun
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Jun 30, 1999
- Messages
- 39,669
I thought it was just okay.
I'm kind of leaning toward that thinking, but my only real problem with it was I don't really care about any of the 4 characters this episode focused on. Other than that it was very well done. Although I don't understand why they didn't just get up and leave in the middle of the night without Lizzie instead of shooting her in the back of the head. I know they had hoped to stay there but they knew that wasn't happening at that point.Patrick Sun said:I thought it was just okay.
This was explained on Talking Dead. She said her character, Carol, did bring this up with what to do and they had an unspoken understanding between them when they shared that look. They could've left her on her own to be Zombie food, but that's what Lizzie wanted and it was a fate worse than death which she did not understand being a psycho.Scott Hanson said:I'm kind of leaning toward that thinking, but my only real problem with it was I don't really care about any of the 4 characters this episode focused on. Other than that it was very well done. Although I don't understand why they didn't just get up and leave in the middle of the night without Lizzie instead of shooting her in the back of the head. I know they had hoped to stay there but they knew that wasn't happening at that point.
I don't know...I think Lizzie would have enjoyed living among the zombies for a while. Probably would have even had them playing cards and stuff.Jeffery_H said:They could've left her on her own to be Zombie food, but that's what Lizzie wanted and it was a fate worse than death which she did not understand being a psycho.
Agreed. Judith is not a perpetrator the way Lizzie was. Even while Carol criticized Mika for being weak, she never would have done to her what she did to Lizzie.RobertR said:That's not a comparable situation.
Sam, you stole my line!Sam Posten said:BestEpisodeEver
I think we've seen comparable dilemmas in many a western as the baby cries and the Indians get closer. But, it is not comparable to the Lizzie situation.Patrick Sun said:I'm not talking about comparable situation, just talking about survival in the zombie apocalypse. It came to me when I was at the post office, and a mother with her baby child were in line, and the baby would not stop crying. So if it was Judith doing the crying, and if Carol and Tyrese are out there trying to get to Terminus, do they run until they can't anymore, or deal with the noise coming from the baby?
Ha! I just watched Quigley Down Under the other day...I won't give it away, but that situation is in that movie too. That is a surprisingly strong western and well worth a view.Patrick Sun said:I have not been watching the right westerns... LOL!
That's EXACTLY correct in your summary of what happened.Quentin said:I think we've seen comparable dilemmas in many a western as the baby cries and the Indians get closer. But, it is not comparable to the Lizzie situation.
What do you do? Watch any western where the question is asked. You try to quiet the baby and/or defend yourselves or run. You don't kill an innocent baby. Not if you're human.
What do you do with a mentally ill individual who has no understanding of life or good/evil or right/wrong in the middle of an apocalypse? Someone who poses a threat to herself as well as any other human in her vicinity at any possible time? That is what Carol and Tyrese faced. They could have split and died, they could have abandoned her to death by zombie, they could have tied her up or caged her...forever? They did what they had to do.
Seen it myself many times, I'm a big Tom Selleck fan. He's what I call a man's man and not these glorified sissy guys in Hollywood now days.Quentin said:Ha! I just watched Quigley Down Under the other day...I won't give it away, but that situation is in that movie too. That is a surprisingly strong western and well worth a view.