David Von Pein
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Feb 4, 2002
- Messages
- 5,752
I recently watched the Season-Four TMTMS episode "The Dinner Party" on the VHS tape shown below, and was reminded of something that I hope like heck does not occur when that great ep. shows up on a S.4 DVD release. It's an "edit" of sorts, only in reverse. Something's been added to the soundtrack on that 1997 "New Video" VHS version.
What they've done (for some silly reason I cannot figure out at all) is to add in fake typewriter and telephone sounds during all of the WJM office scenes. And what it accomplishes is to destroy the "small, homey newsroom" atmosphere which has always permeated the WJM-TV newsroom and offices. And the phones are practically ringing non-stop too. It's just silly beyond belief IMO (esp. when viewers realize the type of small news station that WJM has always been up till then).
The last of the 2 eps. on that VHS tape ("Mary's Aunt"; Season 6) also has the silly fake newsroom noises of clanking typewriters, the constant whir of teletype machines, and incessant telephone-ringing.
Plus: Other ambient, totally-needless faux sound effects have been added to both of those shows on that videotape too -- such as added "clicks" to indicate a door has completely latched and closed, and a really-weird one which is the added-in accentuated sound effect of the automatic door-closer on the WJM double-doors, a "suction"-like noise to indicate the air being pushed through the door's door-closing device. And it's very loud too. Annoying as well, esp. since I know its not really supposed to be on the soundtrack.*
* = Or at least I don't THINK those silly sound effects are part of the "original" MTM soundtrack. Can anyone possibly confirm if they are or not? (I suppose it's possible that James Brooks, Allan Burns, et al, for some silly reason wanted to ruin the small-time newsroom flavor by throwing in all kinds of unnecessary phone rings and clattering noises....but I fail to see the logic of doing so.)
Anyhow, I only hope that those added sound effects are absent from the prints utilized by Fox for its S.4 (and beyond) DVD releases.
http://www2.foxhome.com/mtm/home.html
What they've done (for some silly reason I cannot figure out at all) is to add in fake typewriter and telephone sounds during all of the WJM office scenes. And what it accomplishes is to destroy the "small, homey newsroom" atmosphere which has always permeated the WJM-TV newsroom and offices. And the phones are practically ringing non-stop too. It's just silly beyond belief IMO (esp. when viewers realize the type of small news station that WJM has always been up till then).
The last of the 2 eps. on that VHS tape ("Mary's Aunt"; Season 6) also has the silly fake newsroom noises of clanking typewriters, the constant whir of teletype machines, and incessant telephone-ringing.
Plus: Other ambient, totally-needless faux sound effects have been added to both of those shows on that videotape too -- such as added "clicks" to indicate a door has completely latched and closed, and a really-weird one which is the added-in accentuated sound effect of the automatic door-closer on the WJM double-doors, a "suction"-like noise to indicate the air being pushed through the door's door-closing device. And it's very loud too. Annoying as well, esp. since I know its not really supposed to be on the soundtrack.*
* = Or at least I don't THINK those silly sound effects are part of the "original" MTM soundtrack. Can anyone possibly confirm if they are or not? (I suppose it's possible that James Brooks, Allan Burns, et al, for some silly reason wanted to ruin the small-time newsroom flavor by throwing in all kinds of unnecessary phone rings and clattering noises....but I fail to see the logic of doing so.)
Anyhow, I only hope that those added sound effects are absent from the prints utilized by Fox for its S.4 (and beyond) DVD releases.
http://www2.foxhome.com/mtm/home.html