First, if you are a fan of the book the film is not as good as the book, but still quite effective. One of the knocks on TFIOS is that that the book is accused often of being 'emotionally manipulative' taking hot button topics, throwing them together and seeing what works. There is no doubt about it, the film and book definitely do some of that. Still, what I always respected about the book and now the film is that the characters are not presented as ideal candidates to carry their message.. they are flawed and not always 'there' in a scene.
I recognize for some especially those who haven't read the book, this may be off putting. The character of Augustus Waters in the book goes from moments of true charm to fairly aloof and zoned out to simple 'on'. No matter how many movies show us perfect teen romance, I found Augustus in the book to be one of the more effective teen-romance leads in a pulpy piece of literature.. and the actor in this film really nails that feeling far better than I expected.
I also have to think this film may be review proof. I see it's getting good reviews, but let me say the 8PM, 10PM shows of TFIOS were completely sold out, leaving me to see the midnight which was near full. I have never, ever at any point been in a theater where there was that much open outright crying going on in a theater. Probably the next closest would be Schindler's List. That isn't a knock on Schindler's List, it is just that sometimes fiction or a good romance film can really pull an audience in a way that other things can't. There is a sequence
Where the audience in my theater lost it.. girls in the row above and below me in the theater were bawling, just outright parades of tears with heavy sobs and the like.. hell, at the sequence following that one of the few men in the theater (literally the show I went to was probably 200+ women and 6 guys.. I was the only guy in my row, and only guy in 3 rows of me which were all full) the one guy in the theater where I knew where he was also lost it.
I think for a certain audience this film is going to connect right off the bat and really hit home.
A-
I recognize for some especially those who haven't read the book, this may be off putting. The character of Augustus Waters in the book goes from moments of true charm to fairly aloof and zoned out to simple 'on'. No matter how many movies show us perfect teen romance, I found Augustus in the book to be one of the more effective teen-romance leads in a pulpy piece of literature.. and the actor in this film really nails that feeling far better than I expected.
I also have to think this film may be review proof. I see it's getting good reviews, but let me say the 8PM, 10PM shows of TFIOS were completely sold out, leaving me to see the midnight which was near full. I have never, ever at any point been in a theater where there was that much open outright crying going on in a theater. Probably the next closest would be Schindler's List. That isn't a knock on Schindler's List, it is just that sometimes fiction or a good romance film can really pull an audience in a way that other things can't. There is a sequence
The pre-funeral for Augustus where he hears his eulogies
I think for a certain audience this film is going to connect right off the bat and really hit home.
A-