I have a box of snappers and digi-pak cases stored away in my closet for that very reason. They have all been replaced with more traditional (and often slimmer) DVD and BD cases.
I'm not sure how much I buy into the environmental aspects of this case either. As soon as I saw it, I assumed it must be cheaper to manufacture and therefore cheaper for the studios to purchase because it uses less plastic. In my mind that's the real motivation.
BTW, the new James Bond discs (Goldfinger, Moonraker, and The World is Not Enough) all use these cases too. I'm not a big fan, but I won't get too worked up until the first time one of those damn flat, black, square security stickers Fox/MGM/Disney uses gets stuck to the inside of the slip cover.
As someone that works in home video/DVD/Blu-ray, packaging is something that I'm involved in. I can promise you that these "environmentally friendly" designs cost us more, not less. Not significantly more, in the grand scheme of things, but we're not getting offers like, "We'll sell them to you cheaper if we can give you ones that have giant holes and less plastic."
I think these cases with the cutouts aren't as bad (pricewise) as some of the other environmentally friendly options, because they can still be packaged by machine. Thinpaks, digipaks and different kinds of environmentaly friendly packaging all have to be packed by hand, which costs more.
I can't tell you for sure what goes on in the heads of execs at other studios, but I think this is one instance where they really are trying to do the right thing by trying to be more conscious of the environment.
by the way I decided to open the wallet at that price I started having second thoughts given the mixed reviews so I ran to put in the Criterion dvd which I haven't watched in a good while and couldn't believe that it was non anamorphic and the amount of print damage that existed on that release. My decision quickly went from hesitation to a no brainer.
Thanks - I was just going to post that. It didn't take long...I'll probably try and grab it at my local WM tonight. This is a more reasonable price indeed especially for an MGM title....hopefully a price trend of more catalog titles to come.
from what I understand the WM price is only good online you could do site to store shipping but that would take some time and you have to factor in sales tax as well for WM