Kerry R
Grip
- Joined
- Jan 7, 2002
- Messages
- 20
I've been thinking of purchasing a 5200 but am concerned with the audio drop out, the "popping", and the S-video sync issues. Has Marantz developed a fix for these problems?
I know that's not what you wanted to hear, but it's really not worth it. Trust me.
This is just simply not true.
As a dealer for Marantz I will once again step up to the plate and defend them.
We have been selling the x200 line very well since its introduction. We've been pleased with the feature set as well as build and sound quality coming out of these machines.
They have been very popular and all models have been selling briskly. Probably the best seller is the 5200, with the 6200 and 7200 tied for second place.
With the exception of one unit, we have had no problems with the line, and we've probably sold around 75 of the units all told. We have had no returns and no complaints.
I have only read of two accounts of 5200 units catching fire - if you take the time to compare those 2 to the (probably) thousands of units out there that have been sold and have NOT caught fire, the problem seems irrelevant. Also, just because a unit catches fire doesn't mean we should instantly blame the unit. We have no idea the situation or the load it was presented with. This could very much be due to user misuse (even if it was unwittingly). Our store specializes in speaker repairs and we have seen some nasty things happen with speakers - if they are damaged they can present some dangerous loads to an amplifier.
Second, I am going to call your attention to another fact: yes, it appears Marantz had some problems with this line (though we did not experience them). The simple fact is: EVERY manufacturer has had problems at one time or another with their line. Doesn't matter whether its a Sony, a Denon, a Yamaha, or a Pioneer or anything - you'll always find QC issues at some point in their history. Doesn't mean the name should be trashed and avoided at all costs.
To sum up: the x200 line from Marantz carries on a tradition of providing excellent sound quality in an affordable and well-featured package. Audition the unit and try them out. If you have problems, then take it back. But more than likely you will not and you will not regret your purchase.
/Jeff
Second, I am going to call your attention to another fact: yes, it appears Marantz had some problems with this line (though we did not experience them). The simple fact is: EVERY manufacturer has had problems at one time or another with their line. Doesn't matter whether its a Sony, a Denon, a Yamaha, or a Pioneer or anything - you'll always find QC issues at some point in their history. Doesn't mean the name should be trashed and avoided at all costs.
Jeff,
Yes I agree that every brand has had problems at one point or another with harware... BUT I can't recall a brand that
A) has problems across THEIR ENTIRE LINE (noise, dropouts, etc)
B) REFUSES to look into the problem much less give us a solution!
C) Releases a NEW LINE (8200, 9200)that has the some of the same problems as the old line!
I've had lots of respect for this brand, and I can say that their older equipment was fantastic in quality and performance, but I just can't recommend this current line of receivers. Maybe if enough people don't buy these receivers, Marantz will take notice and correct the problems in their next line.. otherwise what incentive will they have to do so?
I'm probably being too picky.. maybe these problems which are totally unacceptable to me are fine to less discriminating folk. Whatever suits you. But when I pay good money for a piece of equipment, it's not unreasonable to expect it to work the way it should.
C) Releases a NEW LINE (8200, 9200)that has the some of the same problems as the old line!
My extensive testing of the new line showed none of the traits of the lower series. Sound quality was in a different league and I noted no problems.
Look guys, the problem is this. Everyone blabs on and on about what a great resource forums like HTF are - but they are becoming less and less so with people who are hot-headed about their opinions and post inaccurate information. 20 people have a niggly complaint about a receiver and they trash the line. Doesn't mean the product is trash. The Marantz receivers sound a hell of a lot better than their competing product. Our customers have recognized that. No, maybe the noise floor is not as low as it could be, but who cares? The sound is damn good. It's a compromise that is made.
Whatever the problems, the Marantz line is still respectable and should be considered. Let's be fair here. "Stay away at all costs" comments are ignorant of the truth. Test them out for yourself. If you have problems with your unit, then maybe you need to look elsewhere. Or maybe you'll get a good unit and get some kick-ass Marantz sound at a good price.
Just be rational and not so hot-headed.
/Jeff