1. Guest,
    If you need help getting to know Xenforo, please see our guide here. If you have feedback or questions, please post those here.
    Dismiss Notice

Blu-ray Review Doctor Who: Spearhead from Space Blu-Ray Review

Discussion in 'Blu-ray and UHD' started by mattCR, Oct 9, 2013.

  1. mattCR

    mattCR Executive Producer
    HW Reviewer

    Joined:
    Oct 5, 2005
    Messages:
    10,472
    Likes Received:
    368
    Location:
    Overland Park, KS
    Real Name:
    Matt
    XenForo Template Doctor Who: Spearhead from Space

    Spearhead from Space occupies a special place for many life long Dr. Who fans. It’s the first series of Dr. Who done in color. It’s the first Dr. Who post the Time Lord wars conclusion. It’s the first Third Doctor adventure. Written by legend Robert Holmes. It is one of only two early Dr. Who to be shot on film, making it a candidate for Blu-Ray. It introduces Jon Pertwee's Third Doctor. Many of these factors have contributed to it being released repeatedly. By my count, Spearhead from Space has been released four times on DVD, two on VHS, and available on iTunes. I’m fortunate enough to have a copy of the 1994 VHS release, so there will be some comparisons here.

    Posted Image


    Studio: BBC

    Distributed By: N/A

    Video Resolution and Encode: 1080P/AVC

    Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1

    Audio: English 2.0 DTS-HDMA

    Subtitles: English

    Rating: Not Rated

    Run Time: 25 min per episode (roughly)

    Package Includes: Blu-ray

    Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer)

    Region:

    Release Date: 08/13/2013

    MSRP: $29.99




    The Production Rating: 4/5

    Robert Holmes, who wrote Spearhead from Space had previously written The Invasion in 1965, and many fans view this story as a recycled idea. While the idea itself is does seem recycled, the take on it remains new. Because this is a multi-episode arc, in the past the at least one VHS edition presented this in movie format, uniting the episodes into one feature length presentation. I’m very divided on the them choosing to have this only available in episodic format.Posted ImageWe find the Doctor bed bound and erratic throughout the first third of the finding himself lost on earth. There is a neat bit of film trivia here: the Doctor, finding himself in need of fitting in, steals clothes in a scene that would be mirrored years later by a little film called ‘The Terminator’. Posted ImageBecause this is the first introduction of the new Doctor, the opening is really anchored by Nicholas Courtney and Caroline John who establish the setup the tone and pace that follows the story arc from beginning to end. It has been a long time since I’ve watched Pertwee’s early portrayal of the Doctor, which is goofy and impish in comparison to the character he will eventually become. Pertwee’s later performances become tinted and darker, and this early set will see a bit more at home with those who came to Doctor Who through the 2005 series.


    Video Rating: 5/5 3D Rating: NA

    I have long been a proponent of bringing older series to Blu-Ray. Many of these titles have been released repeatedly, and if they could be cleaned up the presentation with less compression would be a serious benefit. There will be people who look at this release and find the flaws, but I had a chance to do an A/B with the 1994 VHS release, and right out of the gate I will tell you this is a restoration effort that rivals the best I have ever seen. In an extra on the disc “Restoration Comparison” they do a back and forth, but the back and forth simply doesn’t give you the entire feel for the unbelievable difference in quality between previous editions and this release. The BBC have accomplished an astounding accomplishment here; the title looks as though it must have coming straight out of the camera. Posted ImageIf you were to ask me for examples of a near perfect transfer of an early production, this would be one of the examples I would provide. Doctor Who fans will do no better for an early release then Spearhead from Space.



    Audio Rating: 5/5

    It is easy to complain about audio in an older release. They don’t make heavy use of the rear channel, and LFE isn’t deployed frequently. But what fans of this program will notice is the same thing I noticed: the dialog is astonishingly good with no drop outs or blurring. People forgetting what blurry audio is in the era of digital, but previous Doctor Who releases like this title had problems of a mix of small drop outs combined with slowing or speed ups of audio tracks which resulted in a choppy delivery and an uncomfortable presentation. The sound on this Doctor Who release is also cleaned up and polished. It is crisp, clear and clean in a way I haven’t heard any early Doctor Who release. Truly, this is as good as it is likely to get. Even in comparison to the special edition DVD, the audio on this disc is cleaner and a much improved listen.Posted Image


    Special Features Rating: 4/5

    One bad thing about this disc is that for Doctor Who completists, it won’t be enough. The disc is missing features from the DVD special edition, although it adds new features. A Dandy and a Clown (AVC, 29Mb/s AWBR, 44 minutes): A Blu-Ray exclusive release. We go in depth into Pertwee's time as the Doctor, and look into his career outside of Doctor Who. A really solid documentary extra that many Who fans will appreciate.Carry On: The Life of Caroline John (HD, AVC 28.9Mbps AWBR, 31 minutes): This is a new documentary that a lot of Doctor Who fans had been waiting for. Caroline John’s portrayal of Liz set the bar for many companions, but it was her off camera background and philosophies that have been discussed by many Whovians for years. Here, her daughter talks about her (lack of) religious ferver, and her career and appreciation for the role. Raw Title Sequence Material (HD, AVC 24 minutes): This is the original test footage creating the new Dr. Who opening.Restoration Comparison (HD, AVC 29.5Mbps AWBR, 2 minutes): I wish this had been longer. There are a lot of fans who are new to the series who have probably never seen earlier releases and have no point of reference to compare to. But the Restoration Comparison gives you a real look in short order of where the title came from and where it is today. I can tell you it barely scratches the surface in regards to significant upgrades that this title provides to early releases.Posted ImagePosted ImageThe Green Death DVD Promo (SD, 2 minutes)


    Overall Rating: 5/5

    Most serious Doctor Who fans will leap at this as a way to put into their collection some classic episodes that have never looked this good. But even casual Doctor Who fans may find this set of episodes a great way to look back at where Doctor Who has come from and enjoy early episodes. The presentation here is fantastic and the BBC should be commended for how good this title looks. I'm a bit let down that not all of the extras of prior releases are included, but what is included is fantastic material for anyone who is a fan of the Doctor.Posted Image


    Reviewed By: MattCR


    Support HTF when you buy this title:

     
  2. Tom St Jones

    Tom St Jones Stunt Coordinator

    Joined:
    Jul 14, 2013
    Messages:
    235
    Likes Received:
    121
    Real Name:
    Tom
    Question: Was the 1996 TV movie also made on film? It appears to have been a relatively high-budget production (for a TV-movie), so maybe it was finished on film, effects and all? If so, I can see this movie also looking very good in Blu/ HD.
     
  3. Adam Lenhardt

    Adam Lenhardt Executive Producer

    Joined:
    Feb 16, 2001
    Messages:
    16,226
    Likes Received:
    1,299
    Location:
    Albany, NY
    The 1996 TV movie was actually the only "Doctor Who" story to be shot entirely on film. However, I believe the visual effects were completed on video tape. Ahead of the original broadcast, separate masters were made for FOX (NTSC) and the BBC (PAL). All home video releases (and most re-broadcasts) have used the PAL master. In the US, this means that the 24fps 35mm production has been sped up to 25fps and then problematically converted to 60hHz for NTSC DVD.


    If there's an issue with the "Spearhead in Space" Blu-Ray, it's that they slowed it down from 25fps to 24fps to do a 1080p24 release instead of a 1080i60 release. They've done the same thing with the new "Who" US releases since "The Complete Seventh Series" set.


    Since this actually was shot in 24fps, I would LOVE for the BBC to go back to the original film elements and create a 1080p24 high definition master of the 1996 movie. Even if they have to recreate the effects, it wouldn't be anywhere near the undertaking that the "Star Trek: The Next Generation" sets were. And it would futureproof a key asset for one of their most recognizable brands.
     
    Josh Steinberg likes this.

Share This Page