Jesse Skeen
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Apr 24, 1999
- Messages
- 5,038
A better analogy is that these are the 8-track tape of video formats. But that's why I love 'em, all 1200 or so in my collection (I've got almost every title and won't quit til I get 'em all!)
If everything had gone as planned though, these would have been the dominant video format, at least up til the 1990s. They intended to get them on the market in the mid 70's, but didn't come out til 1981, when VCRs were already becoming commonplace and laserdisc was just trying to find its place in the market.
The biggest problem with CEDs is that they skip- all of a sudden it'll jump forward a few seconds, usually during important dialogue. While the later players handle skipping better than the earlier ones, it was really stupid of them to let them on the market until they had gotten rid of the skipping problem entirely. The quality isn't anything to write home about either- on a modern TV the picture looks rather jaggedy, so it's a toss-up between that and VHS- doesn't even compare to laserdisc! The sound on some of them is pretty good though. They made both mono and stereo players though, so the mono ones are only good for spare parts to fix a broken stereo one.
If everything had gone as planned though, these would have been the dominant video format, at least up til the 1990s. They intended to get them on the market in the mid 70's, but didn't come out til 1981, when VCRs were already becoming commonplace and laserdisc was just trying to find its place in the market.
The biggest problem with CEDs is that they skip- all of a sudden it'll jump forward a few seconds, usually during important dialogue. While the later players handle skipping better than the earlier ones, it was really stupid of them to let them on the market until they had gotten rid of the skipping problem entirely. The quality isn't anything to write home about either- on a modern TV the picture looks rather jaggedy, so it's a toss-up between that and VHS- doesn't even compare to laserdisc! The sound on some of them is pretty good though. They made both mono and stereo players though, so the mono ones are only good for spare parts to fix a broken stereo one.