- Joined
- Feb 8, 1999
- Messages
- 18,397
- Real Name
- Robert Harris
Stanley Donen's 1958 Indiscreet is one of my favorite films, and may possibly hold the top spot for a romantic comedy. The story and dialogue are just that good. "599 people in a room does look untidy." What a great idea to bring together Alicia Huberman and Devlin a dozen years later, and make them the centerpiece of the brilliant Kind Sir, as written by Norman Krasna. The original roles on Broadway were handled by Charles Boyer and Mary Martin. But Cary Grant and Ingrid Bergman, are perfect. More than perfect, actually. The photography by Freddie Young has been gorgeous. It's now very nice. It used to be smooth, glossy and colorful, with perfect shadow detail, and rich blacks with differentiation of fabrics. The color is still basically with us, except that flesh tones are occasionally just a bit off. Blacks are pure black, with no hint of the fabric that makes up the color, and with little detail to those fabrics. I'm presuming that sep masters were used to create the image, and it looks generally nice, but never quite correct. My initial annoyance was the removal of the original Warner Bros. logo. Why not give credit where credit is due. This was not a Paramount production. Just wrong. In the end, I still love the film, warts and all, including the heavier than normal grain structure. Indiscreet is one of those films that needs to be seen by modern audiences, to allow them to understand how great a classic entertainment with quality actors can be. Image - 3.75 Audio - 3.5 Recommended. RAH