I'm just barely old enough to remember the phenomena of Zefferelli's Romeo & Juliet (1968). That film reduced audiences to tears every time and everywhere it played in every language. You could feel an entire theater of 1,000 people sobbing before you opened the auditorium doors. It happened several times a day everywhere the film played for months. It is easily and by far the most romantic tragedy ever made, Shakespeare or otherwise.
Some romantic dramas that I find affecting:
1931 City Lights
1931 Tabu: A Story of the South Seas
1932 Blonde Venus
1932 Shanghai Express
1936 Dodsworth
1936 Modern Times
1937 Hurricane
1941 How Green Was My Valley
1943 For Whom the Bell Tolls
1946 Brief Encounter
1946 Notorious
1946 Enamorada (directed by Emilio Fernandez)
1947 La Perla (The Pearl, directed by Emilio Fernandez)
1948 They Live By Night
1949 The Passionate Friends
1949 The Small Back Room
1951 The Asphalt Jungle
1953 Shane
1954 Magnificent Obsession
1955 All That Heaven Allows
1955 Ordet
1955 Summertime
1956 Written On the Wind
1959 La Cucaracha (directed by Ismael Rodriguez)
1963 Hud
1963 Winter Light
1963 Love With the Proper Stranger
1965 Baby the Rain Must Fall
1968 Petulia
1969 John and Mary
1970 Jane Eyre (with Susannah York and George C. Scott)
1970 Love Story
1971 The Last Picture Show
1971 The Panic in Needle Park
1971 They Might Be Giants
1972 The Public Eye (aka Follow Me)
1973 Cinderella Liberty
1975 Robin and Marian
1976 Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore
1978 Julia
1979 Manhattan
1979 Starting Over
1979 Tess (directed by Roman Polanski)
1983 Tender Mercies
1984 Places In the Heart
1984 Paris, Texas
1985 Murphy's Romance
1985 Out of Africa
1986 The Morning After
1989 Lonesome Dove
1992 Conagher
1992 Howard's End
1992 The Double Life of Veronique
1993 The Age of Innocence
1993 Remains of the Day
1993 Un Couer En Hiver
2000 Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
2000 In the Mood For Love
Edited by Richard--W - 4/29/11 at 7:58am