New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Star Trek: The Next Generation - Next Level Blu-ray Review

post #1 of 97
Thread Starter 

Paramount Pictures and CBS Home Entertainment undertook a restoration and clean-up of arguably one of the most influential television series of all time with Star Trek: The Original Series. Cleaning up the film and recreating the many visual effects, it sought to present that groundbreaking series to a faithful fan base and many more who would discover – or rediscover – the wonder that gave birth to the Star Trek phenomenon in high definition. It was a marvelous success. The faithful preservation of the three season and presentment of both the newly realized visual effects (and stunning 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio) and the original versions earned my deserved praise and would eventually beg the question: Would Star Trek: The Next Generation be next? Rumors murmured for years until work leaked that tests were being performed to see what it would take to preserve the second crew to take the U.S.S. Enterprise into the wide unknown of the universe.

 

LS

 

Star Trek: The Next Generation

The Next Level

 

Studio: Paramount Pictures
Year: 1987-
US Rating: Not Rated
Film Length: 3hours and 2 minutes
Video: MPEG-4 AVC 1080P High Definition

Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1 (4:3)
Audio: English 7.1 DTS-HD Master Audio, DTS-HD Master Stereo 2.0,French/Spanish/German/Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0

Subtitles: English SDH, French, Spanish, Japanese, German, Danish, Dutch, Finnish, Norwegian, Swedish

 

Release Date: January 31, 2012

Review Date: January 18, 2012

 

“Space – The final frontier. These are the voyages of the Starship Enterprise. Its continuing mission to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly go where no-one has gone before.”

 

 

The Film

4/ 5

 

In 1988, the world changed for me. In England, I was hanging around the video store just about every day and one day, in the new release section, was something called Star Trek: The Next Generation: Encounter at Farpoint. I was already a life-long (at 13 years old) fan of Star Trek: The Original Series (as it is now often referred to), but this video case had a fancy looking Starship Enterprise on the cover with a cast of new characters that was as diverse and interesting as I remember the original crew looking. Needless to say, I was excited. I rented the video and was floored by the excitement and the high quality special effects (good for its day and markedly better than what the original series had been able to produce). I was hooked. The series had premiered on US television the year before and was only available to me (and our 4 television channel household) on VHS. Episodes were released infrequently and a few at a time – but I patiently followed the show.

 

Star Trek: The Next Generation is the most successful of the now five Star Trek series, and for good reason. It was serious minded, exciting, and bolstered by wonderful visual effects for a Television show (thanks to ILM’s terrific stock effects and other talented folk) and an earnest dedication to the evolved sensibilities of our possible future created by Star Trek creator, Gene Roddenberry. It featured a rich cast of characters which included a strong first officer, a Klingon security officer, an android commander, an empathic counselor and a gifted ship’s doctor with her even more gifted son. The cast ranged from superb actors to moderately skilled, but each added a flavor and distinctness that are every bit an integral element in the fabric of the show. Patrick Stewart stars as the English accented, French born Jean-Luc Picard, Jonathan Frakes as the handsome first officer, William T Riker, Brent Spiner is unique and beloved as the android Commander Data, LeVar Burton, with his special visor is solid as Chief Engineer Geordi La Forge, Marina Sirtis mostly good as the half-betazoid, half human ships counselor Deanna Troi, Michael Dorn interesting and impressive as Worf, the lone Klingon aboard, Gates McFadden limited and under-written as the ship’s doctor Beverly Crusher and Wil Wheaton as the often ill-placed Wesley.

 

The crew, captained by Jean-Luc Picard, explores space in the Enterprise D, a Galaxy Class starship, housing over 1000 crew and their families. They encounter evolved beings, mysterious anomalies, aggressive and amenable species and other assorted magnificent wonders out the great unknown. The stories from the seven seasons for which this show ran feature impressive, intelligent and exciting tales that deliver allegorical thought-provokers and good old fashion science fiction fun. It is a show that has grown and prospered from the success of what the original series (in syndication and in feature films) provided. The Next Generation was different from the days of Kirk, Spock and McCoy in tone, technology and tenor – but fundamentally born of the same spirit of exploration, tolerance, social stories and intellect. This collection of four episodes represents a nice variety of what the show delivered during its tenure. This isn’t a collection of the very best episodes (though such collections are highly subjective), but rather a real taste of how this show varies its storytelling and mixes amounts large and small of visual effects, set work, Matte paintings, and solid stories.

 

The Episodes:

 

Encounter at Farpoint: Parts 1 & 2: In this impressive pilot we are introduced to the new crew of the Starship Enterprise. Dispatched to investigate Farpoint Station (on Denib IV), the new Captain Picard is accosted by a powerful and omniscient being known as Q who seeks to try, judge and administer punishment upon his crew as representatives of the entire human race. The savvy Picard petitions the court of Q’s construction that humanity has evolved beyond its brutal infancy and that he and his crew should be allowed to demonstrate how much humans have grown. Relenting, the U.S.S. Enterprise continues its mission to uncover the mission of Farpoint station and demonstrate that the human race is far more than the sum of its history.

 

Though without the polish of later seasons, Encounter at Farpoint accomplishes a great many things. It successfully introduced a diverse new crew helming the grand, impressive new Galaxy Class vessel, with all her improved capabilities (a separating saucer, family-friendly quarters, holodecks, and food replicators). This two-episode series starter, once the stiffness of the actors stretching into their characters is overlooked, remains solid entertainment, with a little wit, solid visual effects (even more impressive now), and Rodenberry’s optimistic vision of our possible future firmly on display

 

 

Sins of the Father: Of the series many superb episodes that explored the Klingon race – a species that holds an uneasy alliance with the federation – sins of the father proved to be an excellent showcase for Michael Dorn (Worf) and the increasing nuances of the warrior race. First Officer Commander Riker steps aside as part in an exchange program allowing Kurn, first officer aboard a Klingon Bird of Prey, to act as First Officer of the Federation’s flagship. Once aboard the Enterprise, Kurn reveals himself to be Lieutenant Worf’s half-brother and persuades Worf to defend their father’s honor. Their father, now deceased, is accused of having betrayed the Klingons at the massacre at Khitomer. The accuser is Duras, a dishonorable Klingon with considerable power and reach within the Klingon Empire.

 

The political machinations that unveil themselves throughout this episode are deeply intriguing and would have ramifications later in the series. The Klingons in The Next Generation were developed as a complicate ally for the federation – far more than the single-minded aggressors from the original series – and were a staple of every season. Worf’s character was not intended to be as prominent, but Dorn’s portrayal so unique (and Denise Crosby’s departure after just 13 episodes so abrupt) that the stars aligned just so, and the legendary sole Klingon member of Starfleet was given ground to grow

 

 

The Inner Light: Perhaps the most beloved of the 178 episodes, The Inner Light is the intimate story of Captain Picard, struck by an alien probe and debilitated, who wakes up having lived a different life, with a wife, in his home, in a drought-impacted village, on a strange world. Back on the Enterprise, Dr. Crusher attends to the fallen Captain on the floor of the bridge as he is connected to the alien artifact. Unable to disconnect the beam affected him, Picard lives out the golden years of this other life.

 

There is a haunting quality to this episode which has resonated with audiences for years. A simple story lovingly shot and very well acted by the guest actors, and complimented with composer Jay Chattaway’s sweet and dramatic score, including the memorable theme played by Picard on the flute, The Inner Light is a triumph of superb science-fiction storytelling. The Next Generation achieved a great balance of drama, action and science (not always convincingly, but…) and this episode, aired between the concept-heavy The Next Phase and the first part of the time travel adventure Times Arrow, The Inner Light is a silent gem emanating a bitter-sweet science fiction conceit nestled amidst character-centric storytelling. A real favorite!

 

 

The Video

4.5/5

Transferring this series to high-definition is a mammoth undertaking. The show’s visual effects were shot on film requiring every sing visual effects element to be re-compositioned (rather than suffer an unconversion from videotape). This requires re-cutting over 25,000 film reels, meticulously rebuilding the episodes and preserving the original episodes in lush detail transferred to high-definition detail. This effort will show off details from the episodes that none of us have seen before (from the original broadcast, the mediocre and soft DVD release or in reruns over the last 20 plus years).

 

So how does it look?

 

Wow!

 

This is an exquisite experience. After watching this series for years in a soft, even blurred presentation, revisiting this collection of quite different episodes is like seeing this show for the first time. Details are beyond words, colors are bold and fresh, flesh tones incredibly natural and visual effects shots revealing of the painstaking artistry (by ILM and others) that went into this bold television series. Encounter at Farpoint is perhaps the most impressive. This Pilot, consisting of two episodes, holds up better than I could have hoped. Set details do not reveal cardboard hallways and dubious uniforms but rather reveal impressive craftsmanship, expense and details.

 

The Sound

4/5

 

The 7.1 DTS-HD track is a winner. The whoosh of the enterprise in the opening credits (whooshing towards and past the camera) fills the surrounds completely and Jerry Goldsmiths reconfigured theme from Star Trek: The Motion Picture fanfares gloriously. The hum of the ship (and the beeps and other electronic noises that abound on the bridge) is clear and present and other sounds such as phaser fire, the echo of the Klingon halls and the roaring crowd of a faux-court (courtesy of Q) are all superbly presented on this Blu-ray disc.

 

Also included is a DTS-HD 2.0 track that more closely resembles the stereo presentation of its original airing.

 

 

The Extras

2 / 5

 

Included on this disc are three trailers, a full-HD version of the teaser and comparison trailer, and Star Trek Padd – iPad App promo spot.

 

 

Final Thoughts

 

Star Trek: The Next Generation is all brand new! This teaser disc is a real treat to begin the year and holds great promise for what the full-first season set – due to be released later in 2012 – will bring. How will episodes like Best of Both Worlds parts I & II look, how will Yesterday’s Enterprise fare, how will The Measure of a Man hold up, how will Spock look in Unification parts I & II, how about Cause and Effect, All Good Things, Galaxy’s Child, Parallels, Darmok, and scores of other classic episodes that I am sure are dear to more fans out there than just me.

 

If this collection is representative of what we have in store, 2012 is going to be a fantastic year for Trek fans. I recommend this collection if you can’t wait to see what TNG in HD looks like, if $14.99 is a sweet enough price to see what Paramount and CBS have been able to do with this show, or if you are like me and both those reasons made this release of TNG in HD a must own!

 

Overall (Not an average)

4/5

 

Neil Middlemiss

Kernersville, NC

post #2 of 97

WOW!  WOW! and WOW!

 

Talk about getting excited just from reading a review.

 

You know, I know this is a teaser for what is to come.

The $15 Amazon price is tempting.  As much as I would

love to own this teaser, I sort of feel like I am just going

to be buying it all over again once the season sets are

released throughout the year.

 

Your review completely assures that Paramount has

done a most remarkable job with restoring this series

and that fans have something quite incredible in store

for them.

 

I will be purchasing these seasons as they are released

though I am somewhat concerned what the price of these

full sets are going to be on Blu-ray considering there are 

7 seasons to purchase.

post #3 of 97

I've already pre-ordered.   High on my list.   I'm hoping for big sale through numbers that help convince many studios to consider this kind of effort for big properties.

post #4 of 97
Deep space Nine is also very Murky on DVD, hopefully it will also get the treatment
post #5 of 97

Thanks a ton, Neil.  I was not on board with this until I saw the most recent trailer for the remaster and now two different reviews which find the effort superb.  Now I can't wait for the disc to hit at the end of the month. 

post #6 of 97
I'm in for the whole series. Thanks for the very thorough and informative review. It's going to be tough to hold off on buying this in anticipation of the complete season sets. If the street price isn't too high for this I might not mind the double dip just to get my temporary TNG fix.
post #7 of 97
Thanks for the great review Neil!

Did you happen to notice the 13 seconds of upconverted material they had to use for the lost footage in Sins of the Father? I'm sure by the time this episode is released, they will have found the footage, so it's not too worrying.

I don't mind getting this teaser. Sure, I'll be rebuying each episode in time, but it will be fun to watch them now.
post #8 of 97
I won't buy a teaser, but just let it be known a full series (or individual seasons) are very high on my list. ...Deep Space 9 too. Bring them on.

OT: Noticed the original Battlestar Galactica Epic series set dropped in retail price. Selling for about 30 bucks on amazon. Blu ray set coming? That's the only reason I didn't order one... if they do blu ray...that would be excellent...
post #9 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson Au View Post

Thanks for the great review Neil!
Did you happen to notice the 13 seconds of upconverted material they had to use for the lost footage in Sins of the Father? I'm sure by the time this episode is released, they will have found the footage, so it's not too worrying.
 


Bill Hunt noted this in his review on the Digital Bits: http://www.thedigitalbits.com/reviewshd/bdreviews011812.html He says it's not troubling and very quick.

 

I think 15 bucks is fine for a release like this, which both gives a taste to the fans of what they're doing, and lets the studio gauge support for this project. Personally, I want to see this project succeed so they'll get on to do DS9 (and because TNG deserves it). I still maintain that as cumbersome and costly as this is, it is essential to the longevity of these series playing on the now-standard HDTVs around the world. In another five years, no one is going to want to look at shows compiled on videotape on their flat screens.

 

 

 

 

 

post #10 of 97
Thanks Sam. As Bill suggested, it would be nice of CBS to offer some kind of incentive if you bought the teaser as credit towards the first season set when it's released. But given the relatively low cost of the teaser, it's not too much to pay to show support for this effort.
post #11 of 97

Even better, how about an incentive for people who bought seven seasons on DVD?  While I am excited about the releases coming soon, I also dread the idea of dropping bucks on these seasons all over again.  Oh well... sometimes it sucks to be a Star Trek fan.

post #12 of 97
I'm also really pleased to see that they are maintaining the original aspect ratio of this series rather than cropping it for wide screen. After all the years we spent moaning about panned and scanned wide screen features I wish people would be as sensitive about maintaining all movies and tv shows in their original forms even if it does mean blank bars on the sides of their wide screens. Too many older shows, like Law&Order and Seinfeld, that were originally made in 4:3 are now only broadcast in wide screen.
post #13 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by adklz View Post

I'm also really pleased to see that they are maintaining the original aspect ratio of this series rather than cropping it for wide screen. After all the years we spent moaning about panned and scanned wide screen features I wish people would be as sensitive about maintaining all movies and tv shows in their original forms even if it does mean blank bars on the sides of their wide screens. Too many older shows, like Law&Order and Seinfeld, that were originally made in 4:3 are now only broadcast in wide screen.

True, but shows like L&O were shot on 3-perf 35mm from the start (something that began to be typical for filmed TV shows starting in the early 90s), which gave you a wider image on the negative, so there actually was more side information than what was originally broadcast. Now it's just opened up (Friends is another similarly shot show). But TNG was not shot that way in '87. It was all still a 4-perf image on the negative. Sure, the final extracted image was usually copped in a bit, and we've all heard the arguments (and seen the image comparisons) that a 16x9 image could be extracted from the full negative image. But, I agree with you. Leave it as it was intended in this case. Besides, they could probably get a balanced 16x9 image out of only some of the original negative images, but we just don't know how often that could be the case.
post #14 of 97
The amount of work to do the entire series seems staggering to me. It will be a true achievement if all seven seasons are reworked for HD. Too bad they can't do seasons one and two last and start with season three.
Edited by Carabimero - 1/20/12 at 3:20am
post #15 of 97
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carabimero View Post

The amount of work to do the entire series seems staggering to me. It will be a true achievement if all seven seasons are reworked for HD. Too bad they can't do seasons one and two last and start with season three.

Though that might be the fan-preferred release order, I'm sure there's the perception in the general public (or at least, about the general public) where people might not be as inclined to collect if you don't start from the beginning (people saying, "Where are seasons 1 and 2? DId I miss them?, etc").

I personally have no problem starting with season 1. It may be a bit uneven, but I have a certain nostalgia for that first season. Apart from a few select episodes (Measure of a Man, etc) I much prefer it to the affected-by-writers-strike second season (and also detested Dr. Pulaski as a character).
post #16 of 97

I think one of the things we're going to find with the episodes in HD is a ton of small details none of us ever saw before.  That, at least for one or two viewings, will make episodes like Code of Honor or Shades of Gray watchable.  Besides, I can name a good handful episodes from season one I genuinely like: Encounter at Farpoint, Where No One Has Gone Before, Lonely Among Us, 11001001, The Arsenal of Freedom, Hide and Q, The Big Goodbye, Datalore, Coming of Age, Heart of Glory.  I'm very much interested in seeing them again rather than a lot of seasons 5-7, which are hoighty toity to me.

post #17 of 97

I've ordered this for myself and 6 other Trek fans in my church group...can't wait til the end of the month for this 3-episode sampler to reach my player and screen!!!dance.gif

post #18 of 97

For me, TNG started slow but had glimmers during the first year and then really picked up in the last few eps of the first year.   The pilot was okay and had a few very interesting moments (one of which was a classic David Gerrold scene between Riker and Picard about away team protocol, and another of which was a great moment for Geordi and Dr. Crusher) but there were also plenty of moments of the stiffness noted by Neil.  The first ep that really indicated something interesting was happening was "Where No One Has Gone Before" which played to all of the strengths of the then-new series. 

 

There were a bunch of ups and downs after that, but things really coalesced around the time of an episode called, appropriately, "Coming of Age", which summarized multiple eps from the point of view of the characters and had some great dialogue scenes including a great one with Worf and another good one with Riker and Picard.  This was followed by a string of eps that were arguably as strong as what had been seen on the original series in its heyday, including "Heart of Glory", "Arsenal of Freedom", "Skin of Evil", "Symbiosis", "Conspiracy" and even "We'll Always Have Paris".   "Skin of Evil" had the typical evil alien, but it had a real punch to it given the consequences of the episode, and given the seriousness of its situation.  "Symbiosis" and "We'll Always Have Paris" were both marked by a real creativity in the writing - they look simple on the surface but have some really clever moves built into them.  I've never forgotten the idea of the locked room in "We'll Always Have Paris" where the transporter doesn't work, nor have I forgotten the multiple spins on the Prime Directive played in "Symbiosis".  And even the last episode, "The Neutral Zone" re-introduced the Romulans and showed us a really interesting new warbird.  And by the way, also introduced the first signs of the Borg.  Those last episodes were the evidence of the new writing group starting to put their own stamp on the Star Trek idea.  If the first batch of episodes was Gene Roddenberry clarifying his vision, and the next batch showed some growing pains, the final 8 eps of the season showed what could happen once everyone was on the same page.

 

Season 2 was hampered by the WGA Strike of 1988, and was thus shortened by several eps and denied of the momentum it otherwise could have had coming out of those last 8 eps of the first season.  As a result, the year limped along until about 8 eps in, when it started to figure itself out.  And then they had to inflict the clip show, "Shades of Gray" at the end, which was a real shame.  Seasons 3 and 4 were probably the best of the series in their overall variety and quality.  Season 5 had some great eps, like "The Inner Light" but was also stuck with the situation where they tended to focus on the "Child of the Week" with a B-story about the ship being in some kind of jeopardy.  Season 6 started out with some concept eps but not much substance until they got to what may be the best ep of the whole series, the two parter "Chain of Command", followed immediately by "Ship in a Bottle" and by some great eps a few shows down.

 

I look forward to seeing what these eps look like in HD.  I was very happy to collect the first 6 seasons on DVD but never picked up the last year as the show felt quite tired to me by that point.  I counted two good eps that whole last year - the series finale "All Good Things" and one interesting sidenote, "Lower Decks".  Beyond that, Season 7 felt like a year too long to me. 

 

I'll pick up the sampler disc, just to see how things are doing on the Blu-ray end of things.  I have a feeling it will be several months before a full season set is ready, and I'm happy to wait for it.

post #19 of 97
Thread Starter 

I found this at Darkhorizons.com - someone appears to have collected comparison stills from the four episodes in this collection - this gives a great taste for what this HD version of TNG looks like!

 

post #20 of 97
Thread Starter 

I found this on Trekcore, appears to be the cover art for the full first season:

 

tng_s1.jpg

post #21 of 97
I can't wait to check this out and later to buy the seasons, I haven't seen the originals for awhile so it'll be great to watch them again restored.
Deep Space Nine my personal favorite, hope that gets the same love, love to have the original Battlestar Galactica on Blu but for me the most important Blu would be Space Above And Beyond.
post #22 of 97
The Trekmovie website has some coverage on the remaster.

Here's a link to part 1 of an interview the Okudas on their involvement with the remaster and what was done.

http://trekmovie.com/2012/01/24/interview-mike-denise-okuda-talk-star-trek-tng-the-next-level-part-1/

You can find part 2 on the site and a new video clip from Encounter at Farpoint. The interview is very informative.

The aspect ratio question is addressed in part 2.
Edited by Nelson Au - 1/28/12 at 8:51am
post #23 of 97
Thread Starter 

I'll be interested to hear the reactions of fans who picked up (or were delivered) their copies today?!

post #24 of 97

Mine came today.   Comments and stills later!

post #25 of 97
Wow--simply stunning! I was concerned that when the original series was transferred to HD, it suddently looked more 'contemporary' and sleeker than the Next Generation series. Not anymore--the TLC that the wizards at CBS have put into this is evident in every frame, as I viewed this on a 46-inch plasma. Now, the series has a film-like quality to it, rather than a murky videotape look. The blacks are deep and rich, the detailing on the ships and the planets and the starfields looks amazing, and the scenes on the ships and the planets don't have that fuzzy look to them anymore, but rather a sleek, sharp and immensely detailed and colorful look, without the colors looking too blown out as I've seen with some HD remastering efforts on other series. Even the credits at the beginning and end of the episodes now have a crisp film-like quality, as opposed to a video-generated appearance previously.

The other big part of this remastering effort is the 7.1 audio--the bass in particular during the ship fly-bys are even richer than some of the motion pictures, and it has a movie theater-like quality to it. Gives the sub-woofer a nice workout in many scenes, even the intro as the Enterprise does its flybys.

Scenes that impressed me included the Klingon city shots in "Sins of the Father", the Q 'net' and the sphere as it chases and envelops the Enterprise (it had a very video-y look previously, now it looks like a feature film-caliber effect), the Enterprise dropping out of warp at the beginning of "Inner Light", and numerous other moments from the pilot episode, which in my opinion is the episode that benefits the most from the remastering of the 3 that are presented here.

I am oddly thrilled that this sampler has now rendered my 7 SD season sets obsolete. It will definitely be worth it to spend $80 twice a year for several years, as this remastering effort has completely transformed the series and given it a new lease on life, not only for the old fans, but for new fans discovering it for the first time.

-Jeff
Edited by Jeff*H - 1/31/12 at 11:40pm
post #26 of 97

I will admit, I was pretty blown away by how good this looks.   I mean, it is a monumental improvement over the DVD release.

post #27 of 97
I took a look at the sampler today and the new cover design is on the slipcover, the actual case is a slim keep case. So, hopefully this is the way season one will be also.
post #28 of 97

TNG-NL-0.bmp

 

Opening credits get some love.  

TNG-NL-1.bmp

 

Scene that they will show you - the bright colors.. I found Far Point to be the one that shows age the worst, which is fitting, but it still looks so much better then the DVD it's not funny.

 

TNG-NL-3.bmp


One of the special effects in Encounter at Far Point that you don't see in their previews, but definitely improves, as the alien reaches out, the way this effect comes off is very good.

 

TNG-NL-4.bmp

 

The Inner Light is one of my favorite episodes of TNG.   Very well done; the color here is very good, significantly improved.. and this brings me to the way some of the makeup really shows off here

 

TNG-NL-5.bmp

 

Sins of the Father is a good chance to see how the Klingons of later season will look:

 

TNG-NL-9.bmp

 

TNG-NL-10.bmp

 

TNG-NL-11.bmp

 

Maybe this is a walking ad for the future season sets, but let me tell you: SOLD.   Convincingly sold.   It's such a remarkable improvement over the DVDs, it's a stunning amount of work that had to go into this.    Great stuff!

post #29 of 97
Wow. Thanks for posting those screen shots. Of all the examples I have seen of the remastering on the Internet, your still grabs give me the best impression, I think, of how terrific the work is. Thank you.
post #30 of 97
Yes, thanks for the great screen caps.

I'm not all that surprised by the reactions here. I haven't had time to go get my copy yet, but I knew it would look great! The TOS blu rays was such an improvement, TNG had to be on par! I hope to get a copy later this week.

When Sarek and Unification part 1 and 2 come out, it will be interesting to see if the ears on Spock and Sarek will have the same visible join lines you see on TOS. smile.gif
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home