Well, my expectations aren't exactly sky-high for Olive Films blus. They are a bit like VCI in which they are licensed transfers of variable quality. That's why some of their releases or only released on DVD. So I would recommend (if it isn't obvious now) to not expect the image quality of these to rival top-drawer studio HD transfers and some may look pretty weak compared to others.
I'm a bit more forgiving to Olive an its ilk, since they are not really responsible for making transfers, more Paramount for not having something better. However, I think they should use a bit more discretion as to which transfer would truely benefit from a blu-ray release, and I think they are tempted to release borderline acceptable transfers on blu if the film is in color and widescreen since it seems that the DVD-only titles are almost exclusively B&W, pre-widescreen titles.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
haineshisway 
I watched a little of this today - for all those complaining about the quality of Demetrius and the Gladiators, you now have something truly terrible to compare it to - and once you've seen this, you know that Demetrius is more than acceptable. Simply put, this is an ancient transfer off a faded element (and certainly not the camera negative) - it's not just the completely brown washed out color, it's the softness of it all - truly terrible.
I would like to add some good news on this title in that it improves quite a bit as the film goes on--the worst of the image quality is in the first part of the film during the opening credits and some minutes afterward.
While not as good as
It's Only Money, which looked good enough to have been groomed for a "Jerry Lewis vol. 2", I certainly didn't find it to be some sort of travesty. Overall a middling, if occasionally lacking, transfer.
Edited by JoHud - 5/3/12 at 10:51am