Quote:
Originally Posted by
smithb 
So don't just break out an HD of Avatar when determining the appropriate distance. Select several examples of content with varying video quality that you prefer to watch on a regular basis.
Exactly. When I was doing my research on TVs (though I was researching for PAL and 1080i/50 compatibility as well as general things like viewing distance), I decided that I had to do some in-store testing with my equipment. You shouldn't have trouble finding a store that will let you hook up your DVD or BluRay player to it (Sears and HHGregg both let me do this). With my player I also took an assortment of "test" discs from various sources. For my needs, I took a couple pre-recorded PAL DVDs (one of film-based material, one of shot-on-video) to see if the TV could natively display PAL without any standards conversion (thankfully, my players can output an unconverted picture).
I also took some PAL off-air burnt discs (from a friend who records shows for me) and I took a 50i-encoded BluRay disc.
For my 'American-standard' tests (which are probably of more interest to you), in addition to seeing how it would handle prerecorded stuff (and how it handled upscaled DVDs), I also burnt a disc with some Match Game that I recorded off of GSN over Dish Network, to see how it was likely to cope with the overly-compressed SD satellite channels. If you get any SD television programming, I'd suggest burning a disc recorded from your cable/satellite provider (if you have the equipment to do so) and at least take that to the store with you, just to see how far back you'd need to stand/sit for the picture to look good enough).