Thank you Gary, Brad, and Jack!
Like “Harry”, you all are also names I trust to steer me right.
To recap: I SHOULD get the two First Season Volumes without question. As with many such shows of the era, the First Season will contain many of the better episodes – and little or no music replacement. I can certainly live with a juke box tune being replaced, if that’s mostly the extent of it.
In S2 and S3, Pete Rugolo did original scores that were supplemented by Capital music – and it was replaced by new Mark Heyes scores without regard to what was what.
This was mitigated with reissue discs, but… the danger is that, if I were to order from Amazon, I stand an excellent chance of getting the Heyes music replacement discs and not the reissue.
NOW… Is there anywhere I am assured of getting the proper reissue? Or do I take my chances… knowing my chances aren’t good?
Further question, regarding Heyes: I know everyone will have different views on this but – not having an ear for what the cues are supposed to be – will I really be irritated by the Heyes cues? Or are they somehow “acceptable” for a sixties show, even if they aren’t “right”?
By this I mean… If STAR TREK TOS were to have its music replaced, certain scores from VOYAGE TO THE BOTTOM OF THE SEA (particularly from Season Two) might be “acceptable” to those who had not developed an ear for what TOS should sound like. It would still sound like a sixties sci-fi adventure show.
However, if the cues from STAR TREK THE NEXT GENERATION were used for TOS, it wouldn’t be “acceptable” for TOS, because it is not “sixties-sounding”.
Does that help frame my question regarding Heyes? Is his work “acceptable”, even if it is not “right”? Or is it totally inappropriate for this show? I’m really interested in your answers.
Thanks in advance.