Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › DVD › HTF Review: The Real National Treasure -- Modern Marvels looks at the Library of Congress
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF Review: The Real National Treasure -- Modern Marvels looks at the Library of Congress

post #1 of 3
Thread Starter 

Cover art: The Real National Treasure

 

The Real National Treasure
An Inside Look at the Library of Congress

 

A History Channel production, part of their Modern Marvels series.


A standard definition program, 16x9 aspect ratio, letterboxed in a 4x3 frame, with Dolby Digital stereo sound.  The run time is about 47 minutes, and the main menu comes up fairly promptly after a brief FBI warning, and a History Channel splash.  The disc is Line-21 Closed Captioned.  The packaging is a standard DVD case.  Retail price for this title is $24.95, and has a USA street date of September 28, 2010.  


The program originally aired on June 10, 2010.

The Feature — ½
In the spirit of full disclosure, I work about a 2.25 kilometers (straight line,) heading 280°, from the Library of Congress’s Jefferson Building, in a building with the recently adopted tag line of “Real National Treasures.”  When this title, with this title, came available for review, I had to admit... curiosity.  That said:


This program, a 47 minute run-time episode of Modern Marvels, is a bit of a biography and an introduction to — a building.  A collection.  A governmental... body, in support of the US Congress.  In support of the arts, culture, and history, not just of the United States, but of the world.  But it is just an introduction.  After all, in 47 minutes, this program is tasked with revealing a fairly poorly understood facility — one where millions of tourists visit per year, with no idea of what they are seeing.  Most, like me, arrive as students on school trips, boy scouts, or international bus tours.  Arrive.  Walk in.  Take a picture of the magnificent Reading Room, and maybe of one of the three remaining pristine condition vellum ~1450CE Gutenberg Bibles.  And leave.


Not realizing that while the Library itself is not a lending library, it is truly one of the marvels of the cultural and scientific world.  And it is also open for the public.  Anyone sixteen or older can gain physical access to its collections.


And the collections, of course, are vast.  One hundred forty five million items, occupying about 745 miles of shelves.  Books, sheet music, maps, flutes, sculpture, scrolls, manuscripts, countless forms of audio and image recordings, and one of the largest collections of machinery for playing back obsolete recordings.  And films, films, films, and more films, spread out over five impressive buildings in and around the Washington, DC area (to include Fort Meade, Maryland, and Culpeper, Virginia.)


And the Missions of the Library are almost as varied as its collections; the biggest being Collection, Preservation, Restoration, and, of course, making it available to its users, be they visitors to the Library in person, or via the Internet.  


Which means that a 47 minute video, with bumpers and recapitulations around ad-breaks, is going to have to be just a very, very fast and brief overview.  Particularly since this program also touches on the history, from the first Library that burned during the War of 1812.  Fortunately, while it lingers here and there on some ‘key’ subjects — all of the ways that they preserve the information that they can obtain on their Stradivarius instruments, for example — they also talk about some of the more challenging aspects of their collection.  Particularly related to the Home Theater Forum — nitrate films.  [Nitrate films are film-stocks made on a plasticized mix of nitrocellulose and camphor.  Nitrocellulose is also known as guncotton or even smokeless powder.]  


The program touches on all of this and more, moving fairly briskly during its allotted time.

The Picture
The picture is 16x9 standard definition video, letterboxed into a 4x3 frame.  Much of the basic video is fairly clean, if a little soft.  There was no significant edge enhancement or noise reduction to the picture, but it is still, fundamentally, a standard definition television production, produced, edited, and delivered in standard definition.  Some scenes are a little noisy, courtesy of having to sometimes work in some fairly low-light situations.

The Sound
The sound is mostly unexceptional.  Clean and clear voice-over and background music here and there.  Interviews vary in quality, depending on the amount of noise in the room where it was conducted.  Unfortunately, there is a tendency to do very strong noise-reduction to those interviews, yielding a sort of fishy, underwater-sounding distortion to those interviews.  A few of the interviews were conducted in grand galleries, and they were allowed to have some of the ‘space’ or ‘air’ of the room.  On the whole, clean, intelligible, and suited toward a documentary.

The Extra
There is an approximately five minute ‘trailer’ for the Library of Congress, heavily cut together from numerous interviews, to have multiple divisions all working toward completing the same sentences, called The Library of Congress Experience.  

In The End
The biggest difficulty I have with this disc is not a technical issue.  Technically, I have no significant complaints.  Instead, it is the question of, where does this fit?  I think this disc would find itself most at home in a school’s film library, where it might be shown to groups of students before they took a field trip to the District of Columbia.  Or in a public library, for anyone thinking about vacationing in Washington, and looking for ‘things to do.’  Or perhaps, in either case, as a refresher: did you have any idea what was going on behind the walls?  And while I am somewhat disappointed by the lack of depth to the program, I suspect one produced about my place of work would be similarly disappointing to me, for many the same reasons.

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 3

Leo, as someone who has never been to the Library of Congress and doesn't know much about it (outside of the other "National Treasure" movies) it sounds like watching this would only scratch the surface and make me want to know more.  Interesting take on it.  I would like to visit it and the Smithsonian someday.

post #3 of 3
Thread Starter 

A problem that I see, working in DC in a "major cultural and historical center" is that tourists rarely seem to know what they're getting into.  All too often, we see a school bus drive up, dump the kids, giving them the direction: "see the Smithsonian.  We'll pick you up at 3pm outside of the Air & Space museum" (diagonally across the Mall from us.  Or the other way around.  Either way..)  And sometimes, they'll have a "scavenger hunt" sort of thing, with items from NMAH, NMNH, and NASM (the big three SI buildings on the Mall.)

 

5 hours.  3 buildings, each with in excess of 200,000ft² of exhibition space.  Plus lunch, and, of course, gift shops.

 

To quite Bill Cosby, "Ri-i-i-ight."

 

From much personal experience, I know it takes me an absolute minimum of 25 minutes to do a gallery-check in my building.  That's a high-speed search for (a) major power issues, (b) major dark spots (lighting,) (c) major damage and/or safety issues, and (d) AV/Interactive functionality.  That's not "looking at" anything, reading anything, or listening to anything.

 

Of course, I used to go on these sorts of school trips, way back when.  Although they generally didn't try to send us to all three major buildings on a single trip.  And this, of course, doesn't count any of the "smaller," but no-less-important buildings, such as the Freer and Sackler galleries, the National Gallery buildings, the National Archives, American Indian, or the Botanical Gardens -- all of which are also free admission and on the Mall.  Oh, and don't forget the new Capital Visitor's Center, the Washington Monument, and all of the various and sundry monuments, memorials, and landmarks that have featured prominently in -- particularly our recent -- history.

 

So, perhaps, maybe this program shouldn't belong in the Modern Marvels series, but rather should be a, say, "founding episode" of a detailed series of "what to see in DC" or something like that, where it might cover some of the major highlights, (such as Archives, or Natural History,) but also the smaller ones (Freer and Sackler Galleries,) as well as monuments and memorials (Washington, Vietnam, WWII, Lincoln, Jefferson, and at least 10,000 more!) or even biological (not just Botanical Gardens, but also the extensive forestry along the streets of DC, as well as the whole Cherry Blossom festival and related..).

 

Obviously, I can get distracted.  Anyway, if you know you're going to be in the DC area any time, let me know..

 

Leo

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: DVD

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › DVD › HTF Review: The Real National Treasure -- Modern Marvels looks at the Library of Congress