- Joined
- May 9, 2002
- Messages
- 13,058
- Real Name
- Cameron Yee
I was shopping in Target and saw these, made by Atlantic:
Which I thought looked somewhat similar in concept to these, made by MMdesigns:
But at almost a third of the price once shipping is factored in!
When I got them home I was disappointed to find the sleeves are only meant to hold inner materials (and what DVDs include those these days?), not cover art, coming in about a quarter-inch too narrow. But it occurred to me it would probably be just fine for Blu-ray's slightly smaller case size. And here's the result:
Although I'd like to find something similar for DVDs at a comparable price, if you're like me your DVD collection is relatively static or slowly shrinking compared to Blu-rays, so in one way it makes more sense to shift to sleeves for them.
That said, there are the occasional inconsistencies with the disc holders (which are a separate sleeve which goes into the larger envelope that holds the cover art), being a pretty tight fit on some and just fine with others. But the material will give and stretch, you just have to finesse the disc into the holder initially.
Of course they don't really address releases in special packaging or with slipcovers, but you'd face those issues with any compact storage solution.
Which I thought looked somewhat similar in concept to these, made by MMdesigns:
But at almost a third of the price once shipping is factored in!
When I got them home I was disappointed to find the sleeves are only meant to hold inner materials (and what DVDs include those these days?), not cover art, coming in about a quarter-inch too narrow. But it occurred to me it would probably be just fine for Blu-ray's slightly smaller case size. And here's the result:
Although I'd like to find something similar for DVDs at a comparable price, if you're like me your DVD collection is relatively static or slowly shrinking compared to Blu-rays, so in one way it makes more sense to shift to sleeves for them.
That said, there are the occasional inconsistencies with the disc holders (which are a separate sleeve which goes into the larger envelope that holds the cover art), being a pretty tight fit on some and just fine with others. But the material will give and stretch, you just have to finesse the disc into the holder initially.
Of course they don't really address releases in special packaging or with slipcovers, but you'd face those issues with any compact storage solution.