The Arbuckle case has always fascinated me for several reasons.
I've never been able to find any "proof" of this but when I was little I remember watching a show on VH1 about various haunted things in Hollywood. I remember there was an apparent screenplay about an overweight silent star that many people in Hollywood thought about playing but all of them ended up dying. Belushi and Farley were just two of the people wanting to do the film. This "haunted screenplay" apparently killed a couple others who tried doing it. I'm fairly certain this was a screenplay about Arbuckle but I'll be damned if I can't remember this show and I've asked countless others about it and they don't seem to remember it either.
I've gone through quite a few of Arbuckle's films and I've never been totally impressed by them. There are many gems among them (CONEY ISLAND the best) but I still think he was a few steps behind Chaplin even in the Keystone days. As for the murder, it's really hard to tell what really happened. It does seem that he was innocent but William Randolph Hearst and his papers apparently ripped him to pieces (funny considering what Hearst was actually doing at this time and in the future). The sad thing is that Arbuckle probably would have gotten his career back on track had Hearst done the right thing and admitted that what he printed was false. Instead, Hearst just fired Fatty to direct movies but under a different name.
With all the NCAA games, I've been sticking to the shorts and just watching these in between everything. I'm actually trying to get all of these watched so I can move on to countless other sets I've had for ages yet are still unopened. This time out:
Georges Melies: The First Wizard of Cinema Disc 3:
Impossible Voyage, The (1904) 


aka Voyage à travers l'impossible
Melies attempt to pass his landmark A TRIP TO THE MOON doesn't quite come close to that but this here is still an entertaining little film. Running 20-minutes, this tells the story of a Geographic Society who build a special ship that will take them through the sky, to the sun and then under the sea. That's pretty much the only type of plot we get here as the master Frenchman really makes for an inter sting film that has more going on for it visually than anything story wise. I must admit that I found what little story we have here to be quite boring as none of the human characters are all that interesting (not too uncommon for 1904) but the places they visit really aren't that interesting either. The look of all the locations is what makes this film worth seeing as there's no doubt Melies put a lot of imagination into everything we're seeing. I really loved the hand-colored stuff as this too had imagination behind it and it wasn't just a scribbled mess. The underwater sequence is a good one but the highlight would have to be when the ship goes into the mouth of the sun.
Firefall, The (1904) 


aka Court-Métrage Mes filmsLa Cascade de feu
Decent magic film from Melies has him playing a warlock like character who turns flames into a woman and then back into flames again. This one here will probably be for fans of the director only as there's not that typical magic that comes along with many of the master's best work. There's a few impressive tricks here but those new to the director would certainly want to watch one of his great works before this one. I did like the effects of the fire turning into the woman and I'm sure this trick really knocked people for a loop back in 1904. The films runs just under three-minutes and is a decent time killer but that's about it.
Living Playing Cards, The (1905) 


aka Les Cartes vivantes
Extremely entertaining and fun film from the French master has him playing (what else) a magician who puts a plane piece of paper on a stool and magically turns it into cards. He then takes the trick even further by having the Queen and King walk off the paper. This here is certainly one of the director's most known films as the tricks are pure magic even though it's obvious to see how they're done. What makes this film work so well is the fact that Melies, the actor, really is charming and sells everything we're seeing. He has that certain grace about him that draws you to whatever he's doing and whoever is playing the King is also a real hoot. The final trick in the film is priceless and makes this one of the more memorable films from the director.
Black Imp, The (1905) 


aka Le Diable noir
Also known as THE BLACK DEVIL, this here is another high point for director Melies. In the film a man checks into a hotel for some rest not knowing that he's about to be haunted by a demon living in the room. It starts off simple as the man can't seem to be able to hang his coat up but quickly turns to a chair disappearing below him and eventually the demon pops out for a quick scare. This is yet another film that Melies is best remembered for and it's funny to see how many times he actually did this story. There's no question he was a fan of checking in somewhere only to be haunted as it's a subject he'd use many times throughout his long career. The special effects with all the chairs and furniture are easy to spot but that really doesn't take away anything from the film because it's just so charming. You can't help but have a smile on your face as one item disappears after another and the man grows crazier and crazier.
Magic Dice, The (1905) Fragment
aka Le Phénix ou le coffret de cristal
I'm really not sure how long this Melies film was suppose to last but we get about 90-seconds worth of it on the wonderful Flicker Alley set. The storyline is pretty simple as a magician (played by Melies) turns a dice into a much larger one and then does a few more tricks to it to make it spin around on its own. That's pretty much the only thing we get here but I found the special effects to hold up quite well with the jump cuts not being nearly as noticeable as in many of his films.
Lilliputian Minuet, The (1905) Fragment
aka Le Menuet lilliputien
Sadly most of this Melies film is now lost and all that remains (a little over 50-seconds) can be found on Flick Alley's wonderful set. What we do see in the footage has Melies and another person standing on opposite sides of a bench. On the bench are four small people doing a couple dances. The special effects of the small people are very obvious but it really doesn't take away anything from the film. How these small people were used reminded me a lot of a famous sequence in James Whale's BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN. There's not much available of this film but I'm glad it was included on the set.
Palace Of The Arabian Nights, The (1905) 


aka Le Palais des mille et une nuits
A 20-minute epic from Melies tells the typical story of a princess who wants to marry the young man she loves but her father refuses. The boy is visited by some sort of spirit who sends him on a quest and if he can overcome everything that will be thrown at him then the boy will receive riches. This isn't your typical Melies film from this period as this here runs ten-times longer than the normal films he was producing. With that said, even though a narration track was added for this film, I still found it rather confusing and in the end it might look good but it's not nearly entertaining enough. I think everyone knows the story here but there's way too much time spent on scenes that amount to nothing including one with some dancing girls. There's some minimum action including a nice sequence where the man must battle some skeletons followed by a fire breathing dragon. This stuff here was quite good and the film needed more stuff like this but we're often left with scenes of the boy just wondering around. The film was in black and white but many of the scenes were hand-tinted and for the most part it looked excellent.
Crazy Composer, A (1905) 

aka Le Compositeur toqué
Lesser film from Melies has a composer trying to come up with his latest piece but he's slowly going crazy from not being able to get anything good. Soon he falls asleep when a mysterious woman approaches and puts on an "act" that will give him the inspiration for his work. I was really surprised to see how lame this film was considering dreams are a subject that the director would visit quite often. This film certainly isn't anything original in terms of the story but Melies does very little with it once the entire dream sequence comes. There's very little magic on display and instead we're pretty much treated to a girlie show as various women dance around followed by some jokers jumping around everywhere. Running just over four minutes, this stuff gets pretty boring very quickly.
Enchanted Sedan Chair, The (1905) 


aka La Chaise à porteurs enchantée
Typical trick film from the French master has him once again playing a magician who performs a special trick. We see a clear glass case with nothing it in but soon a woman appears and this is just the start of the film. This trick film isn't really anything special especially when you compare it to the other works that Melies did around this time as well as similar themed films from his past. The trick shot of the woman appearing was pretty good but everything that followed with the cab was pretty bland. I'm sure Melies die-hards will want to check this one out but there are much, much better films out there from him.
Adventurous Automobile Trip, An (1905) 


aka Le Raid Paris --Carlo en deux heures
Extremely entertaining work from Melies has a man wanting to get from Paris to Monte Carlo but the train is going to take him seventeen-hours so he agrees to go with another man with a special car that will get him there in two. That's pretty much the story to this 10-minute gem that contains some very good imagination from the French director as well as a couple great jokes re-used from previous movies. What I enjoyed most about this film is its pacing that's extremely good and certainly a lot better than some of the previous long films from Melies. The movie has a great flow that really allows the viewer to get caught up in what's going on and this certainly helps with the charm. One of the highlights of the film are when the men are filling up the car and they go to leave they accidentally have the car in reverse and run a man over. It smashes him like a pancake but they leave behind on air pump and you know what's going to happen from here. The special effects still hold up pretty well and the drive through the mountains in priceless. This here isn't one of the director's best known works but it deserves to be.
Unexpected Fireworks (1905) 

aka Un Feu d'artifice improvisé
The nice thing about going through Flick Alley's terrific Melies set is that they offer up some films you really wouldn't expct to see from the director. This here is one of them as a man keeps bothering a woman by pinching her so she finally knocks him out. Then, a bunch of drunks break into a firework store and place them around the man to give him a big shock. There's really nothing special, magical or too interesting about this film other than it's something different from Melies. There's really not too much comedy and the only real entertainment comes from seeing all these fireworks going off in front of the actor and wondering how on Earth he didn't get seriously injured.
Legend of Rip Van Winkle, The (1905) 


aka La Légende de Rip Van Winckle
French filmmaker Georges Melies does his version of the famous Washington Irving story about a man who runs into the woods to get away only to take a nap that lasts for twenty-years. Certain key points of the story are left out here so purists might be upset but this is a pretty good take on the story. This 14-minute film is hand colored and we also get the added narration that Melies added for the majority of his longer movies. The color is extremely imaginative and really adds a lot to the film but I'm starting to feel that many of the added narration isn't really needed for the movie to be entertaining. I'm sure back in 1905 it was important to keep the viewers aware of what was going on since they were sitting through a longer movie but I don't think it's really needed. The highlight of the film is when Rip must fight off a giant serpent and cut it into three different pieces only to then have more bad things happen. The ending is handled pretty well and while this isn't the greatest version of the story Melies at least keeps it entertaining from start to finish.
Scheming Gamblers’ Paradise, The (1906) 

aka Le Tripot clandestin
I've always found this to be one of the weaker Melies films out there even though it's still got a fair number of fans. The film takes place inside a gambling house that can quickly be turned into a clothing store whenever the police are about to enter. Seeing how the set was built in order to change like it does is clever the first time you see it but then it just keeps on happening and to me it's never really funny or fresh. I doubt this was the first time the trick gambling house was done so I can't even give this film points for that. The entire technique behind the changing of the room is nice but that's about it.
Mix-Up In The Gallery, A (1906) 


aka Une Chute de cinq étages
Quick two-and-a-half minute short has Georges Melies playing a photographer who is trying to get the perfect shot of a couple who enter his shop. Soon a dimwitted assistant causes a major accident, which causes the camera to go out a window where the real trouble starts. Once again we're dealt a fairly interesting short from the legendary director. Newbies won't want to check this one out first as Melies has so much better work out there but fans of his will want to see it at least once. The entire film really centers on the two jokes and for the most part both of them work well enough to get you to at least smile. What happens to the camera once it's outside the window is the main highlight here.
Chimney Sweep, The (1906) 

aka Jack le ramoneur
Having seen over one-hundred films from Melies, to date this here is the worst. A poor chimney sweeper, a young child, dreams that he is rich and sitting on a throne as people dance for him. This 10-minute short was pretty much a chore to sit through and I can't remember a time when I was so bored with something from Melies filmmography. I've heard that this was Melies attempt to shine a light on child labor laws and perhaps what this was meant to be but that never really comes across on screen. Usually these longer Melies films come with a narration track and it's funny that I recently said they weren't needed but it actually was here. There's never any real idea where the film is trying to go or what it's trying to do. The fantasy sequence is way too boring to hold up the longer running time and there's not an ounce of that magic that Melies is so well-known for.
Luny Musician, The (1906) 


aka Le Maestro Do-Mi-Sol-Do
In terms of an original storyline, this Melies film doesn't contain that but it's still a lot of fun. A musician is in his room trying to learn a new song but the maid comes in and interrupts him, which causes him to fly off the handle and kick the tray out of her hands. Then the room comes to life and the musicians is about to find himself being tortured. Melies was a master at the trick film and this here shows his talents at the highest level. Even though we've seen this type of film from him before I still had a blast here as the sheet music kept moving to different levels where the musician couldn't read it and even better is when his violin turns to a tuba and then various other instruments. The highlight of the film are the last few moments when he's trying to play the piano but it starts dancing across the room and then violently attacks the musician. This isn't one of Melies best known works but it's a very good one.
Tramp And The Mattress Makers, The (1906) 


aka La Cardeuse de matelas
This four-minute film has some slapstick as a drunken tramp is walking down the street just as some mattress workers are going on their lunch break. The tramp sees the mattress as a nice place to lay and falls asleep only to be trapped inside when the workers return and sew the mattress up. When he awakes he gives everyone a good scare. The actual "scare" really isn't all that funny and that's the main reason this film doesn't work but it does remain pretty interesting in terms of Melies career because there's actually an edit to a different setting, which isn't normal for his work up to this point. Normally all of Melies films, outside the epic ones, took place in one setting so it's interesting to see him expanding things a little. The payoff for the tramp on the second setting is a nice little joke and certainly works better than the street scene.
Hilarious Posters, The (1906) 


aka Les Affiches en goguette
This here remains one of Melies best known works due in large part to it being shown on countless compilations as well as various free sites (like Youtube). The film has a billboard showing off various people and it quickly comes to life before going back to the billboard. In a twist, the billboard jumps back to life so that those on it can throw things at the man making money off of it. This type of trick show really isn't anything new from Melies but it still works simply because of the charm. The movie runs a quick three-minutes and manages to get a few nice laughs but the technology of the trick shot is pretty low-key especially when compared to some of the work the director was doing even earlier than this.
Desperate Crime, A (1906) Fragment
aka Les Incendiaires
This Georges Melies film isn't complete but seven-minutes worth of it are included on the Flicker Alley set and it's a real shame that the entire thing hasn't been found. The film was apparently one of his longer ones as it features narration and the footage starts off as a thief is burning down a market that he has just robbed. Later footage has him being captured and then we see him locked up in prison. Some great footage also includes him dreaming about the guillotine and the real highlight is when his body is put on there and his head cut off. I was extremely shocked to see how terrific the effect was when it came time for the head to be cut off. I paid close attention to see the "edit" but it went past me twice. This entire sequence is wonderfully done and I can't even begin to imagine how people in 1906 must have felt seeing this. The effect is beautifully done and the follow-up is extremely well done too. Hopefully the entire film of this will eventually show up.
Punch And Judy (1906) Fragment
aka L'anarchie chez Guignol
Here's another lost film from Georges Melies that's only available from the Flicker Alley set. We get a 29-second clip that's pretty hard to tell what's suppose to be going on in the entire film. We see a group of people, most women, sitting and watching a puppet show. The puppet show is a man and woman fighting but that's as much as we get. Again, it's hard to tell exactly what's suppose to be going on from start to finish but perhaps one day the entire thing will turn up.
Roadside Inn, A (1906) 


aka L'hôtel des voyageurs de commerce ou les suites d'une bonne cuite
Strange mixture of horror and slapstick as a man checks into a hotel where some of the other folks staying there decide to scare him by placing a demon like figure in his bed that will jump out once he goes to get it. This is a somewhat interesting film from Melies as his camera stays still (like always) but it captures half of the man's room and the other half is covering everything that's going on in the hall. This adds something original to the film and I must admit that I found this to be the most interesting thing here. What didn't work overly well was the comedy as it never really materialized and the "joke" just wasn't funny.
Soap Bubbles (1906) 


aka Les Bulles de savon vivantes
Decent trick film from Melies has a woman taking form out of a bubble. Melies plays the magician who continues to blow bubbles that take shape as various parts of this woman, which he then orders to take form. This here is certainly an entertaining little gem even if it isn't among the best work from the French master. I think the special effects hold up fairly well considering this film is now over one-hundred years old. There are a few funny bits and as usual Melies adds a lot of charm.
Merry Frolics Of Satan, The (1906) 


aka Les Quatre cents farces du diable
Entertaining 14-minute film from the French master has two gentlemen being haunted by Satan as they travel from one hotel to the next. Before long Satan throws them into a special carriage and takes them on a trip to Hell. The actual story here really doesn't mean too much because the real highlight here are all the special effects and various tricks that pop up. This here, thanks in large part to the title, remains one of Melies most popular films and it's understandable as there's a lot of fun to be had here. As with many of his longer movies, this one here features some narration and it's also hand colored, which is a big plus. The colors look great and they are used with quite a bit of imagination. Some of the best stuff in the film deals with Satan, painted red of course, popping out of various places and scaring the men. Another major plus is when we actually get to Hell and various other demons take form.
Mysterious Retort, The (1906) 


aka L'alchimiste Parafaragaramus ou la cornue infernale
A wizard falls asleep in his lab when a serpent comes out from a cabinet and soon takes shape in a variety of forms including a spider, a joker and a mysterious woman. This here is another one of Melies most popular films and it's easy to see why as we're given all sorts of nice humor, some weird situations and just an overall surreal atmosphere that really makes this stick out among his hundreds of pictures. I'm not sure what it is but I always love when that serpent shows up as I find it to be one of the most interesting figures from this early part of film. It's certainly nothing ground breaking and the effect of it is obvious but it makes for a lot of fun. The spider here and its web is another major plus. Fans of the director will certainly enjoy the humor here and if you're new to Melies then this is a good place to start.
Witch, The (1906) 


aka La Fée Carabosse ou le poignard fatal The Impossible Voyage
Colorful and engaging film from Melies about a troubadour who goes to see a witch to get his fortune told. He promises the witch a bag full of gold but it turns out to be sand so the witch seeks vengeance on him with various hauntings. Hand-coloring these films are always tricky as some of them look great while others look incredibly bad and silly. I've seen quite a few of these tinted films from this era and I must admit that this here is the best one I've seen. I really loved all the colors being thrown around and this is easy to see when the troubadour first goes to see the witch. The color of their outfits are really terrific and the look of the witch is rather breathtaking and will make you think of the 1939 version of THE WIZARD OF OZ. The story itself is pretty strong as well, although the subplot of the troubadour trying to save a princess being held captive stops the film in its tracks to a point. With that said, there are plenty of wild special effects and neat tricks to make this a must see from the filmmography of Melies.