The Red Shoes (rewatch) - I've been putting off watching this Blu-Ray because, as you might have guessed, it's another one that I feared I shouldn't have purchased. I only gave it a 7 on the first viewing, but that was nearly eight years ago and the review was rather insipid, so there was a chance that this time around I'd see it for the masterpiece it's usually hailed as. So let's get this out of the way: I still don't like ballet. And maybe that's because I'm a total philistine who doesn't get ballet. I understand that it takes skill and precision and endurance, but it just doesn't do anything for me. It reminds me of ice skating, where it's the exact same 4 or 5 moves over and over again in different combinations. How many pliés and pirouettes and leaps am I supposed to be impressed with before I get bored? It's not dynamic enough. And as a storytelling medium, well, it seems to me that the actual storytelling is all the stuff that occurs around the dancing, while the dancing itself only expresses a handful of vague emotions.
Now that my little ignorant rant is over, I'll say that if you're going to do ballet, this is the way to do it. With absolutely jaw-dropping visuals, and a bit of magic. Like Busby Berkeley, Powell & Pressburger inject the dance routine with moments that are impossible, but reach for a more ecstatic truth. It is a real feat that they managed to construct a 20-minute ballet sequence that ends up being my favorite part of the film. Because really, I just don't care enough about the rest of it. I mean, it's interesting and all, but I don't get swept away by it like I do A Matter of Life and Death or even A Canterbury Tale. I don't find the characters very compelling. Moira Shearer is one of the most photogenic creatures ever to grace the screen, but I don't really believe her motivations. The film wants me to buy into this grand artistic obsession and dying for one's art, but it doesn't ring true to me. I think that if I believed that Victoria was as driven as we're meant to think she is, the film as a whole would have worked much better for me. Nonetheless, the film is very watchable with a lot of terrific scenes. And it's still got some of the most beautiful cinematography I've ever seen. My opinion has changed enough for me to bump up the score a notch, but not enough to want to keep it in my collection. Rating: 8
post #1141 of 1166
12/18/10 at 3:17pm
- Martin Teller
- Martin Teller
- Location: Portland, OR
- offline
- Joined: August 2006
- Posts: 2,370
- Select All Posts By This User





