Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: District 9 (Highly Recommended)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: District 9 (Highly Recommended)

post #1 of 32
Thread Starter 



District 9

 

Studio: Sony/TriStar

Year: 2009

Rated: R

Program Length: 112 minutes

Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 1080p

Languages: English, French 5.1 DTS-HD MA; English Audio Descriptive Track

Subtitles: English SDH, English, French, Hindi

 

The Program

 

District 9 is a rarity, a film about aliens from outer space which is thoughtful, intelligent and extremely well-made. Produced by Peter Jackson and briskly directed by Neill Blomkamp, District 9 tells the story of an alien spacecraft which visits Earth and inexplicably comes to a halt in the sky over Johannesburg, South Africa, where it hovers for two months. When the occupants of the spacecraft seemingly make no effort to come out, a team of humans is sent up to cut open the door and see what is inside. What they discover are a million weak and malnourished aliens who have lost the ability to control their ship.

 

The plight of the aliens brings out the best humanitarian instincts in the people of Johannesburg, who initially are happy to provide food and shelter for these visitors. A camp called District 9 is built to house them, but problems soon surface. The aliens turn out to be scavengers, and the humans consider them to be bottom feeders and dub them with the derogatory name “prawns.” District 9 is fenced in to keep the prawns separate from the humans, with unsatisfactory results. Prawns who manage to get out and mingle with the South Africans are accused of robbery, rape and murder. District 9 turns into a massive slum, where crime runs rampant. This general condition last for twenty years, and public outcries finally convince the authorities that the prawns must be moved away from the city. A decision is made to relocate the prawns to a remote area of South Africa, far from Johannesburg.

 

A private security company called Multi-National United (MNU) is given the task of implementing the relocation. Wikus van de Merwe (Swarlto Copley), a bureaucrat in the Alien Affairs Department of MNU, is put in charge of the operation. The assignment requires his department to visit each shack in District 9 and convince the residents to sign a document stating that they are willing to be relocated. Difficulties immediately crop up, as some of the prawns resist and turn violent. In the course of visiting the homes in the slum, Wikus comes across various forms of contraband, including weapons and prohibited electronics equipment. While searching the home of a prawn known as Christopher Johnson, Wikus discover a strange-looking canister which he assumes is a weapon of some kind. While examining the canister he inadvertently sprays an unknown substance on his face. It soon becomes apparent that this substance is having a profound physical effect upon Wikus. Within hours, parts of his body begin to take on the characteristics of a prawn.

 

One thing which has puzzled Multi-National United for two decades is the fact that humans have never been able to operate the alien weapons which were found on the spacecraft. When MNU discovers what is happening to Wikus, they take him to a research laboratory and confirm that he is now able to fire the weapons. When Wikus realizes that his employer is prepared to sacrifice him so that they can conduct experiment on his body, he manages to escape. However, he soon discovers that the only place he can hide is in District 9, where he has to co-exist with the despised prawns. In District 9 he turns to the prawn Christopher Johnson for help, and the two create a most unlikely alliance.

 

The decision of the South Africans to segregate and relocate the prawns is awash in irony, given that country’s long history of apartheid. However, it also conjures up images of Palestinians in Gaza, Japanese-Americans being forced into detention camps in the United States during World War II, and the Indian Removal Act of 1830 which led to the forced march of Cherokees that became known as the “Trail of Tears.” Director Blomkamp nevertheless wisely resisted any temptations he may have felt to become preachy about the political and social issues. In fact, many of the prawns are odious creatures, and it easy to see why the residents of Johannesburg wanted to have them sent away. On the other hand, there is little reason to believe that forcing intelligent creatures to live in a ghetto is going to have a happy ending.

 

Ultimately, though, District 9 is an exciting, high-octane sci-fi action film with many explosions and thrilling shootouts. It grabs the viewer’s attention immediately and never lets go. It is highly recommended for anyone who is a fan of the genre.

 

Two predictions: there will be a sequel to District 9, and if anyone in the West ever makes a film about 21st century Iran, Swarlto Copley will play Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

 

The Video

 

The 1.85:1 1080p transfer is superb, hardly a surprise given Sony’s outstanding track record with Blu-ray releases. The image is properly framed and satisfyingly film-like. The opening of the film is done in semi-documentary style, and the video during that portion is deliberately variable in order to convey that effect. The special effects are extremely well-done and are seamlessly integrated into the footage. The prawns in particular are very lifelike and believable. This is not a particularly colorful film, as much of the action takes place in the grimy confines of District 9, but the colors are solid and accurate. Inky blacks and excellent shadow detail are evident, particularly in the nighttime scenes. It is obvious that great attention was placed on creating a very detailed and repulsive slum, and it shows. The detailed images of Wikus’ metamorphosis from human to prawn may make the more squeamish viewer squirm a bit. I saw no evidence of digital artifacts, excessive DNR, edge enhancement or other anomalies. This is just another first class Blu-ray transfer.

 

The Audio

 

The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack is superb. Whether it is explosions, automatic gunfire, or helicopters sweeping through the sky, the soundtrack places the viewer right in the middle of the action. Dialogue is mostly confined to the center channel and it is clear and understandable (there was an occasional word with which I had trouble because of the Afrikaans accents, so the English subtitles came in handy for me). The subwoofer gets a workout during the battle scenes. The prawns speak in their own language, so English subtitles automatically appear when they have dialogue. The musical score is very evocative and is given an expansive soundstage.

 

The Supplements

 

Extras are plentiful on this Blu-ray release. A commentary track by director Neill Blomkamp provides some insight into what he was trying to achieve and how his background of growing up in South Africa influenced his sensibilities. I would have liked the commentary better if he had provided more information about the mostly-unknown cast.

 

There are 22 deleted scenes, so it is obvious that most of them were cut in order the keep the running time of the film at a manageable length.

 

Also included is a three-part documentary called “The Alien Agenda: A Filmmaker’s Log.” The first part covers the pre-production of the film, including Peter Jackson’s involvement and the decision of set the action in South Africa. The second part provides insight into the actual filming, with emphasis on the Johannesburg locations and the challenges involved in shooting scenes for which special effects will be added later. The third part goes into some detail about the editing process.

 

There are also four featurettes which have self-explanatory titles, mostly about the technical aspects of the film:

 

“Metamorphosis: The Transformation of Wikus”

 

“Innovation: The Acting and Improvisation of District 9”

 

“Conception and Design: Creating the World of District 9”

 

“Alien Generation: The Visual Effects of District 9”

 

An interactive satellite view of Johannesburg and District 9 is called “Joburg from Above: Satellite and Schematics of the World of District 9.” Viewers can zoom in on such locations as Christopher Johnson’s shack and MNU headquarters (“Joburg” is slang for Johannesburg).

 

Owners of PlayStation 3 can try out a demo game called “God of Wars III.”

 

Other features include cinechat, movieIQ, and BD-Live features which were scheduled to be activated on the release date.

 

Finally, the BD release includes a digital copy in standard definition. All of the other BD extras are in high-definition.

 

The Packaging

 

The BD disc and digital copy come in a standard Blu-ray keep case.

 

The Final Analysis

 

District 9 is one of the most imaginative and original alien/sci-fi films which I have seen in recent years. It also is intelligent, violent, fast-paced and exciting, with exceedingly high production values. It deserves my highest recommendation.

 

Equipment used for this review:

 

Panasonic DMP-BD50 Blu-ray player

Panasonic Viera TC-P46G15 Plasma display, calibrated to THX specification by Gregg Loewen

Yamaha HTR-5890 THX Surround Receiver

BIC Acoustech speakers

Interconnects: Monster Cable

 

Release Date: December 22, 2009

 

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 32
Richard:

Nice job, as always.

Picked this up today as a blind buy.  Very much looking forward to it after your raves about PQ, SQ & story.
post #3 of 32
 Thanks for the review Richard. I have this coming tomorrow from NetFlix. Looking forward to seeing it. Also, i cant believe i am getting a new release from NetFlix, the week it comes out!
post #4 of 32
Thread Starter 
That's terrific to get a hot new title so quickly from Netflix. You'll love it, I'm sure!
post #5 of 32
Quote:

The Final Analysis

 

District 9 is one of the most imaginative and original alien/sci-fi films which I have seen in recent years. It also is intelligent, violent, fast-paced and exciting, with exceedingly high production values. It deserves my highest recommendation.

I agree 100%

After my huge disappointment in a blind buy of Tarantino's latest last week....watching this tonight I had the complete opposite reaction. What a great ride this film was from start to finish.

I had no idea what D9 was about other than an alien ship had come to earth and we had them among us. What a unique take on the sci-fi genre. Can't wait to recommend this to friends.
post #6 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mike caronia View Post

I had no idea what D9 was about other than an alien ship had come to earth and we had them among us. What a unique take on the sci-fi genre. Can't wait to recommend this to friends.
 
You hit the nail on the head. I did not see this in a theater and I deliberately avoided reading about it because I knew I would be reviewing it when the BD came out. I was immediately caught up in it.Great from start to finish..
post #7 of 32
Doesn't that review give up the entire movie except the end?

anyway I liked the movie it was great to watch something as original as this.
I think the menu let's you choose either alien or human, but I didn't notice what the difference was.


There was 2 things that had me confused.
Did...
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
His father in-law put him in charge with the intention of causing Wilkus to be infected?

What was the plan of the aliens.
When the alien was in his house with his son at one point I thought he was saying to his son that their plan was ruined or something like that.
Just seemed like there was something more to what was going on with them.
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
 
post #8 of 32
well, I was waiting for a review of this disc, and it sounds like my kind of flick.....I'll pick it up tomorrow. Thanks.
post #9 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by TonyD View Post

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

What was the plan of the aliens.
When the alien was in his house with his son at one point I thought he was saying to his son that their plan was ruined or something like that.
Just seemed like there was something more to what was going on with them.

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
I thought the plan was just "escape and get the hell back home". But the plan was ruined when their fuel source was confiscated.
post #10 of 32
Thanks for the great review, Rich. I pre-ordered this a while back and it arrived yesterday. After I catch Invictus at the theater today, I plan on spinning this - which I am now, thanks to your review, even more excited about watching.

Neil
post #11 of 32
 Good review although I do believe too many plot points were divulged in the film synopsis.
post #12 of 32
I almost rented this today. Saw it once in the theater and while a fantastic film, there's just not enough there to warrant a purchase, no rewatch factor in it for me.

Great review though and a rental at some point.
post #13 of 32
Great review. Was going to rent this first but the steelbook at futureshop beckoned me and I wasn't disappointed. Great movie.
post #14 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Southpaw View Post

 Good review although I do believe too many plot points were divulged in the film synopsis.
 

You can't write a decent review without talking about the plot, and the question of how much information is too much information is a subjective one and not always an easy one to answer. In this case, I decided to address what happens to Wikus in part because the packaging clearly states that one of the extras is called "Metamorphosis: The Transforrmation of Wikus."  Anyone who sees that is not going to be surprised that Wikus undergoes a metamorphosis.

That said, we reviewers try to be sensitive to spoilers, but there may be occasions when we reveal too much.
post #15 of 32
Interesting that you talk about it being very "film like". District 9 was shot completely with the Red One 4k digital camera. I wonder if they added grain to the image to help it look more like film?

Doug
post #16 of 32
 This certainly was one of the impressive looking films I have ever seen.  The effects were just so transparent.  I tend to have a keen eye for CGI and normally find it annoying when too much is on the screen, but this film did a great job.  The story is pretty original and enjoyable.  My only complaint is that the lead character is pretty much completely unlikable.  As others have said, he is this strange mix of the manager from "Flight of the Conchords" and Michael Scott from "The Office".  Not a good mix.  
post #17 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Douglas Monce View Post

Interesting that you talk about it being very "film like". District 9 was shot completely with the Red One 4k digital camera. I wonder if they added grain to the image to help it look more like film?

Doug

My personal approach is that I don't look up the technical specs before I write a review, because I don't want them to influence my opinion on what I see. To my eyes, it looks like film, and as someone else pointed out the CGI doesn't look like CGI.

IMDB says that the source format is 4K Redcode RAW, the master format is Digital Intermediate, and it was printed on 35mm film.
post #18 of 32
Thread Starter 
I was going to mention in my review that this BD was a bit slow to load, but then I realized that my BD50 didn't have the latest firmware update, so in fairness I didn't want to make a negative comment which might be unwarranted. I just installed the latest update (2.1) and now the disc loads pretty quickly.

Anyone who encounters slow loading might want to check his or her Blu-ray player and make sure it has the latest firmware installed.
post #19 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Richard Gallagher View Post




My personal approach is that I don't look up the technical specs before I write a review, because I don't want them to influence my opinion on what I see. To my eyes, it looks like film, and as someone else pointed out the CGI doesn't look like CGI.

IMDB says that the source format is 4K Redcode RAW, the master format is Digital Intermediate, and it was printed on 35mm film.
 
Oh I wasn't questioning that it looked like film, I just thought it was interesting how film like it looked when it was a completely digital product. I imagine the 35mm prints were strictly for theatrical presentation. I suspect the blu-ray comes ported directly from the digital master files.

Doug
post #20 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Douglas Monce View Post



Oh I wasn't questioning that it looked like film, I just thought it was interesting how film like it looked when it was a completely digital product. I imagine the 35mm prints were strictly for theatrical presentation. I suspect the blu-ray comes ported directly from the digital master files.

Doug

 

Whatever they did, they did it right. I certainly didn't have the feeling that I was watching a digital print. I wish now that I had seen it in a theater so I would know how well it compares. I just now read Roger Ebert's review and he talks about the seamless merger of the CGI, so I suspect that the Blu-ray accurately reflects how it looked in theaters.
Edited by Richard Gallagher - 12/25/09 at 12:15pm
post #21 of 32
I haven't seen the film yet but I'm looking forward to it. It also looks like I'll have the chance to work with the Red One on an up coming project. Should be exciting.

Doug
post #22 of 32
I also saw this and think it was an excellent movie. However I don't feel like owning this. It's an example of where an excellent movie doesn't necessarily mean a blind buy!
post #23 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by TonyD View Post

Doesn't that review give up the entire movie except the end?


There was 2 things that had me confused.
Did...
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
His father in-law put him in charge with the intention of causing Wilkus to be infected?

I thought the review gave away a bit much on the story, but different strokes... (And I avoided reviews until after seeing the film, to avoid such spoilers.) But the review makes me want to to rewatch it on my new Blu Ray player :)

And, to your first question:
Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
The FIL gave Wikus a job (and so, station in life) appropriate for a man marrying his daughter.
post #24 of 32
Wait, if you've already seen it, it's by definition not a blind buy, right? 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sam Davatchi View Post

I also saw this and think it was an excellent movie. However I don't feel like owning this. It's an example of where an excellent movie doesn't necessarily mean a blind buy!

This was a blind buy for me, and I just watched it last night with my girlfriend and two other friends. We all enjoyed it, and I thought it had a very unique twist on the alien story, not to mention the interesting parallels with real-life situations in that part of the world.

I'm glad I bought it and unlike some others here, this will be a movie I will be re-watching. I thought it was very well done, and while the lead may be considered unlikeable at first, I found his character arc and plight to be very sympathetic and was rooting for him at the end.
post #25 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carlo Medina View Post


I'm glad I bought it and unlike some others here, this will be a movie I will be re-watching. I thought it was very well done, and while the lead may be considered unlikeable at first, I found his character arc and plight to be very sympathetic and was rooting for him at the end.

My reaction was that he is more the typical bureaucrat than personally unlikeable. Perhaps "unsympathetic" describes him better than "unlikeable." I agree with you that he grows on you. On the other hand, an argument can be made that the real protagonist is actually a different character, and I'm sure you know who I'm referring to.
post #26 of 32
I watched it last night and really enjoyed it. Wikus was definitely the protagonist from my point of view - a middling, cowardly beaurocrat who's pomposity and ineptitude got him into the situation he was in, and who's basic human decency was reawakened by the brutal shift in perspective caused by his predicament. The story arc was very much about his character from start to finish. The story of the 'Prawns' was the catalyst for his transformation, both literally and figuratively.

A great movie all around that I think really transcends itself somewhat beyond it's genre trappings and one of the best I've seen in 2009.
post #27 of 32
By the way, I was so impressed with Sharlto Copley's performance that I went on IMDB to look up his next role...which is as Howling Mad Murdock on the upcoming A-Team movie!

Great...now I can't get the A-Team theme song out of my head...
post #28 of 32
While being a well-enough made film, I'm amazed that folks keep saying how "original" DISTRICT 9 is. 

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)
 The whole transformation plotline seemed to have been lifted almost verbatim from Cronenberg's THE FLY, right down to him losing his fingernails, and much of the rest of the set-up seemed to me to have been lifted from ALIEN NATION.  Not only do we have a race of "worker" aliens stranded on Earth, but DISTRICT 9 even offers up its own variation on ALIEN NATION's aliens drinking spoiled milk-  the "prawns" unexplained obsession with cat food. 
This seemed like a hodge-podge of ideas from other films remade in a faux-documentary style.  Again, it's a well-enough made film for the most part, but not even close to being "original" IMO.

Vincent
post #29 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vincent_P View Post

While being a well-enough made film, I'm amazed that folks keep saying how "original" DISTRICT 9 is. 
This seemed like a hodge-podge of ideas from other films remade in a faux-documentary style.  Again, it's a well-enough made film for the most part, but not even close to being "original" IMO.

My review:
Quote:
"District 9" is unexpected, original, scary, gory, intense, and riveting. It has the realism and cold desperation of "Children of Men". It's like "Die Hard", "The Fly", and a fictional documentary were smashed together. If you like all of those movies, this is a must see; otherwise stay far away.
 It is this exceptional almagamation of other pieces that makes it if not "original" so interesting.
post #30 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaveF View Post




My review:
 It is this exceptional almagamation of other pieces that makes it if not "original" so interesting.
 
All my life I've read review after review of songs, books, movies, paintings in which the artist/author is said to have been influenced by a previous artist/author.  Yes District 9 has similarities to other movies.  Just how do you create a sci/fi movie, or a romantic comedy, that does not contain elements of something that came before?

Take PJ's The Frighteners.  That was a ghost story/comedy/thriller.  Gee, Ghostbusters was a comedy/ghost story.  Does that mean The Frighteners is derivative of Ghostbusters?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: District 9 (Highly Recommended)