New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Galaxy Quest

post #1 of 27
Thread Starter 
 

Galaxy Quest
 
Studio: Paramount Pictures
Year: 1999
US Rating: Rated PG - For Some Action Violence, Mild Language and Sensuality
Film Length: 101 Mins
Aspect Ratio: 1080p High Definition - 2.35:1
Audio: English 5.1 Dolby TrueHD, Spanish 5.1, Thermian 2.0
Subtitles: English, English SDH, French, Spanish, Portuguese
 
Release Date: November 17, 2009
Review Date: November 5, 2009
 
 
The Film: 4 out of 5
 
"I'm not even supposed to be here. I'm just "Crewman Number Six." I'm expendable. I'm the guy in the episode who dies to prove how serious the situation is. I've gotta get outta here"

It has been almost 10 years since the perfectly-pitched parody of Star Trek premiered in theaters. Boasting a healthy $45MM budget, a solid cast and visual and make-up effects from the best in the industry, it was warmly received by critics and audiences alike, finishing its run with a respectable $90MM worldwide gross. With the resurgence of Star Trek, and the phenomenal success of Paramount's J.J. Abrams led reboot, Galaxy Quest should garner some new fans, and some newfound appreciation of its pure-bred fun.

Relegated to the rotation of sci-fi conventions and gimmicky celebrity appearances, the cast of the long-since cancelled television show ‘Galaxy Quest’ have seen better days. Since their weekly science-fiction show was taken off the air, the popularity of the show has stayed alive thanks to the dedication of legions of fans who gather at conventions, dressed as their favorite characters and live happily in the minutia of the show’s canon. During a convention appearance, Jason Nesmith – one of the cast members who portrayed the rough and tumble, handsome captain Taggart is approached by what he believes is a small band of dedicated fans, but what is in actual fact representatives of an alien race, the “Thermians”, led by Mathesar (Enrico Colantoni). This misunderstanding of who these beings are lead all the actors from the old TV show, in full costumer, to end up on a full size, working replica of the space ship from their show. The Thermians had built the ship based on “historical archives’ beamed to their planet (the TV episodes), and have now reached out to the heroic crew to help them defeat the evil Sarris (Robin Sachs), a reptilian baddie bent on the destruction of the ‘simple’ Thermion people. Needless to say, this mix up has some humorous consequences.

Galaxy Quest is a glorious spoof of the Star Trek premise and legacy – affectionately mocking the onscreen ham and off-screen reports of in-fighting, line stealing and general dynamics from Gene Rodenberry’s classic adventures to “where no man has gone before”. It ingeniously finds humorous material aplenty in the science-fiction ideas propped by a now defunct television sci-fi property while excelling at space adventure of high order. Galaxy Quest triumphs as entertainment. It captures the cardboard set and traditional parameters of the Star Trek confines, complete with ‘Irwin Allen rock and roll’ and the prescient and attuned captain bravely saving the day, while appreciating and celebrating such sci-fi.

But the real core gem at the center of this entertaining universe is the cast. Serving as the William Shatner/Captain Kirk larger than life, ego-hound Jason Nesmith (Commander Peter Quincy Taggart) is Tim Allen. Allen manages to find the excess of ego and actor bravado that has been sewn as myth and reality into Shatner’s legacy, and pulls off the ‘over-acting’ balanced with the somewhat washed-up actor, turned real hero brilliantly. Alan Rickman as Sir Alexander Dane (Dr. Lazarus of Tev'Meck) is delightfully wry and very funny as the ‘Spock’ spoof. The rest of the cast are more than equal to the task of affectionately ribbing the Trek personnel icons.

Sigourney Weaver as Gwen DeMarco (Lt. Tawny Madison) is excellent, Tony Shalhoub as Fred Kwan (Tech Sergeant Chen) is weirdly un-phased by the out-of-this-world circumstance, and is hilarious doing it. Daryl Mitchell as Tommy Webber (Lt. Laredo) is suitably freaked out by the whole experience and finally, Sam Rockwell as Guy Fleegman (Crewman # 6) is simply excellent – portraying the ‘redshirt’ of the Galaxy Quest universe with the pride, followed by the panic, wonderfully.

Galaxy Quest was written by David Howard and Robert Gordon and directed by Dean Parisot – and it hits the mark in almost every respect. Bolstered by superb special effects from the Gods of visual magic, Industrial Light & Magic, and special make-up effects from the legendary Stan Winston Studios, the production quality is better than some of the films from the Star Trek franchise that the film lovingly sends up (with the clear exception of the Star Trek reboot). Non-Trek fans will have plenty to enjoy in the original story, excellent cast and top-notch effects and Trek fans will lap up the nods and winks that appear in every corner of the film. Great stuff!
 
 
 
The Video: 4 out of 5
 
Galaxy Quest arrives on Blu-Ray for the first time in a solid 1080p High Definition transfer (created for the 10th anniversary, and used on the Deluxe Edition DVD release earlier this year). It is presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1, opening with the windowboxed scene from the ‘television show’, and opening up to the full 2.35:1 as the film transitions to the convention.

The digitally remastered treatment on blu-ray looks great. The print, aside from some specks here and there, is clean (compared to the original Dreamworks DVD release, this version is immaculate). The color balance is good, though it doesn’t ‘pop’ quite as I was expecting, but that is not a knock against the image. The look of this disc is wonderfully retentive of the proper film like quality, with pleasing contrast and wonderful details throughout. A quick comparison between this blu-ray edition and the Deluxe DVD release from earlier in the year reveals how terrific the detail level is on this release. It isn’t slick or glossy, but the new amount of detail that you will see; the prosthetic on Alan Rickman, the few stray hairs on Sigourney Weaver’s head, the dust and small rocks that tumble from the rock monster, particularly just after it has been transported into the room with the bad-guys aboard ship. The DVD appears to be brighter, but the blu-ray is by far superior.
 
As with the DVD, the effects show the very best clarity of this entire presentation.  A must own for fans.
 
 
The Sound: 4 out of 5
 
The inclusion of a Dolby TrueHD audio track is welcome, and it provides and pleasing, engaging audio performance. David Newman’s terrific score sounds rich and heroic, and the ship ambience and thrusters give the woofer a good rumble. The action sequences; the ship to ship battles, the rock monster rampage, and the journey to the center of the ship (which is very funny) all sound great, rich in audio detail and quite active in the surrounds, and the dialogue is clear in the center channel. Excellent sound design delivered solidly.


 
The Extras: 3.5 out of 4
 
Galactopedia: I like special features like this – when done right, they can augment the entertainment on a movie that you have seen many times before. Exclusive to the blu-ray release, topics appear onscreen through the movie, and you can navigate through an encyclopedia of fun facts. Jumping from the Galactopedia track and normal view takes a good 15 -20 seconds, so be prepared for a delay if you choose to opt in or out of this track while watching the film.
 
Historical Documents: The Story of Galaxy Quest – (18:13) – Interviews with the writer, director and others discussing the fun of the spoof and effort of making the film.

Never Give Up, Never Surrender: The Intrepid Crew of the NSEA Protector: (23:24) A look at the cast of the film and the fun of embodying/parodying the crew from Star Trek the original series. Tim Allen is relaxed, fun and open talking about himself and the film.

By Grabthar’s Hammer, What Amazing Effects: (7:03) A quick look at Industrial Light & Magic’s superb visual effects and other special and make-up effects. Using new and old interview footage to cover the ground.

Alien School: Creating the Thermian Race: (5:23) This is fun stuff as they discuss Enrico Colantoni’s idea of how the Thermian recruitment leader, Mathesar, and the Thermain race, should sound and act.

Actors in Space: (6:10) A look at the has-been actors that found themselves thrust into an interstellar adventure and how that ‘pathetic’ life is a very real thing in and around Hollywood. You will find Nicholas Meyer (Star Trek II, VI director) here and the actors discuss being thought of as the characters they have played.

Sigourney Weaver Raps: I kid you not. Ms. Weaver (along with Sam Rockwell, Daryll “Chill” Mitchell and others) taped a rap for her agent’s birthday – encouraged by Daryl “Chill” Mitchell

Deleted Scenes: Eight deleted scenes. Some good stuff here, especially the scene with Tony Shaloub trying to avoid having to answer a tough technical question.

Thermian Audio Track: This was interesting for about three seconds before it became grating.

Theatrical Trailer: (1:54) – Original theatrical trailer available in HD (the only special feature available in high def).

Previews
 
 
Final Thoughts
Galaxy Quest ten years later remains highly entertaining and fun from start to finish. A perfect cast, stellar visual effects, imaginative make-up and a romp of an adventure to boot. The supporting cast sports some familiar faces, with Missi Pyle (numerous TV appearances, Boston Legal in particular) as Laliari and Rainn Wilson (NBC’s The Office) as Lahnk – both awkward, goofy Thermians. Justin Long seems to have begun his ascent into geekdom here, playing a young nerd/fan of the show who is rejected by a salty Jason Nesmith, only later to be relied upon to help save the day. He now continues to appear as the ‘Mac’ guy in the Mac computer commercials, and has played John McClane’s tech wizard sidekick in Live Free and Die Hard.

At the end of the day, Galaxy Quest is a loving, faithful and extremely fun and funny spoof of Star Trek. And this blu-ray is absolutely the best way to enjoy it. Recommended!
Overall Score 4 out of 5

Neil Middlemiss
Kernersville, NC

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Galaxy Quest [Blu-ray]
post #2 of 27

Quote:
Originally Posted by Neil Middlemiss View Post
 
Galaxy Quest arrives on Blu-Ray for the first time in a solid 1080p High Definition transfer (created for the 10th anniversary, and used on the Deluxe Edition DVD release earlier this year). It is presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1, opening with the windowboxed scene from the ‘television show’, and opening up to the full 2.35:1 as the film transitions to the convention.

Technically, the original theatrical aspect ratio was 1.85:1 for the first twenty minutes or so (until Taggart leaves the Protector for the first time), then it opened up to 2.35:1. But (a) I don't remember if the 1.85 material was matted at the sides or the 2.35 material matted at the top/bottom; and (b) I don't think any home video presentation has maintained that, for good reason (it loses a lot of its effect when it's so obviously windowboxed).
post #3 of 27
In theaters, the 1.85:1 portion was matted on the sides.

I wish they'd have used branching to at least give us the option of watching the multi-ratio version. 


Nevertheless, this is a hilarious movie, well worth owning.

post #4 of 27
Thread Starter 
Andrew - you are correct about the theatrical opening. I don't think I was as clear as I meant to be in the description of the opening, but you are right that the home video presentation of the film has never replicated exactly the transition from 'show' to 'movie'.
post #5 of 27
Too bad about the multiple aspect ratio thing. It's not like somebody is going to be watching this on an old analog tv!

Is it just coincidence that this is coming out the same day as Star Trek?
post #6 of 27
Can't wait to add this to my collection!  An all-time favorite, but I still have the original (non-deluxe-version) DVD.  Looking forward to the upgrade.  Thanks for the review! :)


post #7 of 27
"HEY! Don't open that! It's an alien planet! Is there air? You don't know! "

By Grabthar's Hammer... I will be getting this on Blu. Thanks for the review.

Shame it's still only the PG version, Sigourney Weaver yelling "Well fuck that!" at one point redubbed to "Well screw that!" for cinema release.
post #8 of 27
I absolutely love this film.  I really can't believe that it's 10 years old already.  I still remember watching it in the theatre like it was just yesterday.

Definitely upgrading from the original DVD release.  It's a must have for my blu-ray collection!

Thanks for the review Neil.
post #9 of 27

Quote:
Originally Posted by SilverWook View Post

Is it just coincidence that this is coming out the same day as Star Trek?

Total coincidence!  :D

I just pre-ordered mine this morning.  Love love love this movie and I was heartbroken when the BD didn't hit with the DVD earlier this year.

post #10 of 27

Quote:
Originally Posted by cafink View Post

In theaters, the 1.85:1 portion was matted on the sides.

I wish they'd have used branching to at least give us the option of watching the multi-ratio version.

Thanks for the information. Yeah, that would've been nice to see. (I don't even think branching would be needed--surely they could've used an approach similar to the "windows" on Pinnochio/Snow White?)

Quote:
Originally Posted by SilverWook View Post

Too bad about the multiple aspect ratio thing. It's not like somebody is going to be watching this on an old analog tv!

Given the complaints about windowboxing for credits even here, I can't imagine that windowboxing main content by default would go over well.

Quote:
Originally Posted by SilverWook View Post

Is it just coincidence that this is coming out the same day as Star Trek?

Probably not. Though I would have been even more amused by the counterpoint provided by the original release date, day-and-date with TOS Season 2 on Blu-ray.
post #11 of 27
Glad to hear this one looks (and sounds) great -- yeah, would've been nice to have the option for the original VAR, but I guess that may never happen now.  Was a little reluctant to preorder this given Paramount's iffy track record for catalog titles (even though this one is not that old) -- otherwise, might've already ordered it to go w/ the new Star Trek BD.

And thanks for the review, Neil. 

_Man_
post #12 of 27
Forgot about this as no UK release date announced yet so guess I need to import the US BD. Great movie, still a terrific DVD and the best non cannon ST movie since ST6!
post #13 of 27
The trivia track was actually written by Mike & Denise Okuda who worked on various Trek shows and films and wrote the trivia tracks for the Trek DVDs and Blu-Rays.

http://web.me.com/michaelokuda/michael_okuda/Books_%26_DVDs.html
post #14 of 27


Quote:
Originally Posted by Steve Christou View Post

Shame it's still only the PG version, Sigourney Weaver yelling "Well fuck that!" at one point redubbed to "Well screw that!" for cinema release.

I recall, either via the commentary or a documentary on the DVD, a discussion on this.  They made the movie and thought, we've got a movie kids can go see except for this one word.  Sigourney understood and agreed to the redub.  Why make a movie like this that kids can't see just for one word?

This movie is just so right-on in it's loving parody of Star Trek that I can imagine the original ST cast  enjoying it too.

post #15 of 27
I have a copy on preorder. I don't expect it to look appreciably better than my D-Theater tape but it should sound better and I'll get extras. The review sounds encouraging.
post #16 of 27


Quote:
Originally Posted by Johnny Angell View Post




I recall, either via the commentary or a documentary on the DVD, a discussion on this.  They made the movie and thought, we've got a movie kids can go see except for this one word.  Sigourney understood and agreed to the redub.  Why make a movie like this that kids can't see just for one word?

This movie is just so right-on in it's loving parody of Star Trek that I can imagine the original ST cast  enjoying it too.
 

Well, technically you can use the word 'f&ck' once in a PG-13 movie, if it's not used for the 'deed' itself. But the way I heard it was that it was substantially darker, but was toned down after preview audiences thought it was too dark. So they made it more suitable for younger audiences.
post #17 of 27
I vividly remember seeing this in theaters and know it was matted on the sides at 1.85:1 because when the ship's space doors opened up - whoosh! - the aspect ratio opened up to 2.35:1 with the doors and the effect was jarring in a good way!  It was like being right there with Taggart since I saw this in a really-BIG screened theater!

I wonder if the effect would still be cool if the Blu-ray windowboxed the 1.33:1 parts to the 1.78:1 screen, then opened up to the 1.85:1 part to fill the screen, and then when the space doors open up, the aspect ratio would change drastically to 2.35:1?  I know it wouldn't be the same as a 1.85:1 windowbox opening up to 2.35:1 but this might appease the windowbox-haters.

It's too bad the 1.33:1 goes straight to 2.35:1.  Oh well, just glad to have it on Blu-ray.
post #18 of 27
Thanks for the review! Look forward to this one too!

This is of course, in some circles, considered the other official Star Trek film because it is a very warm and sweet gift to the Star Trek fans, and not a parody.

Great that this is coming out on the same day that JJ Abrams' Star Trek is coming out, now that is a counterpoint! It's as if they planned it this way.
post #19 of 27
How can you say it's not a parody? Que?
post #20 of 27
It may be a friendly embracing parady, but it's definitely a parody.
post #21 of 27
It is a parody, but one with such a grasp of the genre that it betters most of the films that it is parodying at their own game, as well as being an hysterical comedy.

GQ is absolutely a better adventure movie than most of the Trek films.  It also happens to be a great comedy.
post #22 of 27
Okay, I looked up parody just to make sure I fully understood the definition. I stand corrected, it is a parody.

I always thought that when most people refer to a parody of Star Trek, it's usually a negative one where the point is to mock particular elements of the original material in a very bad light. 

In one definition, it does say that a parody is best when you cannot separate it from the original. And I think that's why so many fans call this an unofficial Star Trek film. Patrick Stewart used a better term for the film I thought, he called it a tribute.

Guy was a spot on reference to the famous Redshirts!

Edited by Nelson Au - 11/13/09 at 7:45pm
post #23 of 27
+1 with respects to wishing they preserved an option to go from 1.33 to 1.85 to 2.35. But barring that oversight, a very good A/V transfer.

And while the overdubbed Sigourney Weaver line would've been cool to have, you can pretty clearly make out the real word when you see her lips move. 

Very glad to have this in my BD collection.
post #24 of 27
Just watched my US import (UK release is not until March 2010).

Still IMO a perfect movie. Its aged very well and everything is just about perfect cannot think of anything which could be improved upon. The BD is very good especially the costume detail on the Stan Winston Studios Sarris makeup that looks just amazing and like its from a 2009 movie!!!

They even interviewed all the main actors recently and edited this into the existing DVD extras (in a clumsy way but at least they made some effort!!). Hard to believe it was not a massive Men In Black size hit back in the day but the marketing & release date hurt it so it never did as well as it should have and a sequel is very unlikely.


post #25 of 27


Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul_Warren View PostHard to believe it was not a massive Men In Black size hit back in the day but the marketing & release date hurt it so it never did as well as it should have and a sequel is very unlikely.

 

I sequel would be tough to do.  Much of this movie's humor was derived from shock the crew went through because fiction had become fact.  I don't think that would work so well a second time.  If they did a sequel maybe a key element could be the crew still doing the show when they are too old for the parts.  A geezers in space angle.

BTW, was there a commentary on the DVD?

post #26 of 27
Thread Starter 
post #27 of 27

Thanks Neil! Just ordered it! 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Galaxy Quest [Blu-ray]