Advice: Get Smart or U.N.C.L.E.?

As an owner of the Get Smart box set, here's my two cents...

I could not get into U.N.C.L.E.  I rented the first season through Netflix and it didn't click for me.  I was psyched for it because I love Mission: Impossible, Wild Wild West, The Saint, Danger Man...a lot of the 60s spy shows.  To be fair, I only saw the first season, so you'd have to get an U.N.C.L.E. fan to weigh in as to the quality of the rest of the series.  Personally, I found it too goofy for my tastes.  To me, it was like the worst elements of the Bond movies rolled into a series.

Get Smart, on the other hand, is fun but I don't know if the big box is worth the dough.  If I had to do it over again, I'd have waited for the individual releases and just picked up the first three seasons.  Seasons 4 and 5 (IMO) aren't as much fun because (1) Max and 99 get together and lose their romantic tension; (2) the spy craze was burning out (I think Mission: Impossible fizzled out too).  The show didn't have the same kind of legs as, say, Dick Van Dyke because of the spoof element. 

Seasons 1 and 2 are the most consistently funny and there are some hilarious bits of wordplay and physical comedy that play very well.  Some would argue that the box is worth it for the special features, but features have never been that important to me personally.  I'd recommend buying Season 1 and seeing how you like it.

Well they're both spy oriented shows with one an obvious comedy and the other more serious initially but more lighthearted in later years. I don't actually own either one. I saw Get Smart in reruns in my youth and while it was fun at the time I passed on it as far as owning it. Man from U.N.C.L.E I had some interest in owning but you can only get the complete series and while the first year seems interesting the later 2 years many believe went off the deep end, so I couldn't justify buying the whole set.  I may rent the first season some day.

But if you are interested in Spy genre then there are others to also consider. Personally, I went for the following instead and would choose them anyday over the ones you listed:

- Avenger (specifically the Emma Peel years)
- Saint (early Roger Moore)
- Dangerman/Secret Agent
- Honey West
- Man in the Suitcase

Some of these were blind buys for me but I've watched a few episodes of each and have no regrets. Avengers I have seen all the way through on TV through the years and have no qualms in recommending or watching it repeatedly.

Edit: Following with Jack, I also have the first three seasons of Mission Impossible and would recommend that one to.

I've got both at home, and I would give UNCLE the edge, especially with its cast of guest stars to give it more long-running novelty (William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy are together in one good pre-Star trek episode), but my wife would probably give Get Smart the nod, since she loved it as a kid.  I think you have to take them in context, since they're both very formulaic, so there's not a lot of stretching beyond the initial concepts.  Luckily, you can find them both available much cheaper than their list prices if you keep your eyes peeled.

I would also strongly concur with recommendations for The Saint and Danger Man--I think those both really hold up with less allowance for nostalgia!  Also Man in a Suitcase, but you'd still have to get an import version of that, I think.  I like pretty much any US or British 60s spy or detective show, but some are better-written than others.

Matt,

I have the complete Get Smart set that I bought from Time/Life and I'm presently almost done with S2.  I've enjoyed the show so far and the transfer Q is outstanding.  I watched the show when it originally aired but haven't seen it again until the DVD release.

As others have posted (very well) here, I'd say, you probably should consider sampling S1 of Get Smart before deciding on buying further seasons.  One thing that I'd mention here is that the 1st season set included the black/white pilot episode and (imo) the pilot had a different flavor to it than the 1st official color episode and the early seasons of the show.  When I watched the pilot ep, I wasn't impressed but once I started into the color regular season eps, I've enjoyed the show so far.  After reading posts here, it'll be interesting for me to see how the later seasons click for me as well, after Smart & "99" get together, etc.

UNCLE: I only have the 1st season, thanks to a very good friend , and have watched a couple of eps.  The 1st season is B/W and so far I've liked them but I haven't seen this show since its original airings and back then, I wasn't a big UNCLE fan.  I rememer following the show somewhat but I didn't watch it every week.

I agree with Brad's "spy show" list completely.  Great list, Brad!

"Secret Agent" (Danger Man) is among my all-time favorite shows, as well as the Saint B/W shows.  I have all 3 of the sets that Brad mentioned, including "Man In a Suitcase".  That one was recommended by "Bob H" on this Bd.  I went the "region-free" route to get the early Saint complete B/W set from the UK as that's the only way to get the entire B/W set.  I'm about 1/3 complete with that set and about 2/3 thru the Danger Man Megaset.

If you're a Patrick McGoohan fan, I highly recommend "Danger Man" as a B/W UK spy show.  The latest megaset also includes the early 30-min "NATO" episodes that began the series.  I haven't seen those yet as I'm going through the 1-hr series first,  That's the shows that aired internationally and was seen on US TV in the 60's,  Tip: There were 2 megasets released by A&E and the 1st megaset doesn't include the 30-min shows which were only aired in the UK.

The transfers are excellent with both the Danger Man and Saint B/W sets.  The Saint set is Region 2 PAL and those transfers are awesome, imo.  Crystal-clear quality.

The Danger Man set includes the original "US opening" theme which was a top-40 hit by Johnny Rivers back in the 60's.  It's included as an "extra" on all of the discs, if I recall from my last disc view of the set.

If you're thinking of a choice between UNCLE, or the shows from Brad's list, I agree with Brad in that I think you'd prefer either Danger Man or the Saint to UNCLE when comparing "spy" genre shows.  I don't have the Avenger set but plan on adding that one to my collection eventually.

I almost bought that complete UNCLE set a few months ago when Amazon had that "deal of the day" sale for the set but I passed on it since the show did move into the "mid-60's camp" genre compared to the S1 flavor.

I also, have both the complete Get Smart and U.N.C.L.E. sets and  U.N.C.L.E.  gets my vote if you can only buy one.

I  am still stuck in Season 3 of Get Smart, which I bought from Time-Life when it first was released.  U.N.C.L.E., I zipped right through in a couple of weeks.

It's a popular opinion that U.N.C.L.E. lost it's way or got campy in later seasons. But I remember the original press for the show where it was stated  to be a show "with it's tongue firmly in it's cheek". So, I agree when Jack said above it was  "goofy" from the start. I mean, Elsa Lanchester as a mad scientist in season one. You can't get campier than that.  But U.N.C.L.E. was great fun and probably the biggest deal of the TV spy craze in the 60's. 

And Matt, remember, Get Smart was spoofing the spy craze, so it's better to watch the spoofee before watching the spoofer.

I have recently rewatched THE SAINT both the R2 Network b&w set and the R1 A&E color set and I'd now say that The Saint is  the best of the international man of mystery genre. (With the possible exception of the giant ant episode. And until I rewatch the complete Danger Man/Secret Agent series.)  

As Jeff thankfully mentioned, some of the sets are best from the UK so keep that in mind. I have the same R2 b/w set of the Saint which is suppose to be much better the the US A&E sets. Also, the Man in the Suitcase is a PAL release. So if you aren't region free then those could be an issue.

The Avengers set from A&E region 1 is good quality so no fear there. The Emma Peel years are 1965 and 1966 in b/w, and 1967 in color. While I saw a little of the Saint growing up, I saw all the Avengers when aired on A&E in the late 70's and I believe again some time in the 80's. It was the first TV series I bought back in the late 90's when first released. I have not seen enough of the others yet to completely say but I think it would be hard to dethrone the Avengers as my favorite (but it could happen). There is just something about the interplay between Mrs Peel and Steed that never seems to get old.  While there is an ending to the Emma Peel run at the end of 1967 there really is no beginning setup. So you could even start with the 1967 color year season and not miss anything, then go back to the b/w years if you find you like it enough.

They're all enjoyable, so if you are like some of us you will end up with most of them eventually.

I love Get Smart and have been very impressed with the quality of the complete set. 

It also goes on sale from time to time, I bought it from Amazon after a tip from here when it was on sale. I think it was only $65 or so.

Brad,

Thanks, no problem.

The main difference between the US A/E B/W Saint set and the R2 Network UK set is that the UK set is the only one that contains all of the B/W episodes.  I don't recall how many eps are not included in the A/E set though.

As far as the transfer Q's, I haven't seen the US A/E versions but as you know, that UK set is A+ transfer Q.

You're right about the "..Suitcase" set in that it's a PAL set but if I recall, it's set for Region 0 so anyone interested may consider that in a purchase decision.

Bottom line for me, that Region Free player is the best DVD decision I've made a few years ago.

Back to your original question though, I'd probably have had a tough time choosing between Get Smart or UNCLE but with UNCLE, I was mainly interested in S1.  Given that, I'd take Get Smart but by a close margin.

Are you kidding? Choosing one is like Sophie's choice.

Get Smart is a comedy, and a great one at that.

UNCLE has more action and suspense, and later, campiness.

Both are terrific. Just ask yourself if you want a top-notch comedy or top-notch action show.

Hi Matt!

I have both Complete Series sets from  Time-Life.  I have watched both completely and enjoy both shows.  However, I think U.N.C.L.E. has the edge over Smart.  Yeah, Smart is a spoof and shouldn't be taken seriously, but U.N.C.L.E. was such a better show.  Better scripts, acting and music. 

Since you can't afford both and want an honest opinion of what to spend your hard earned money on, I suggest seeing if you can rent the first seasons of both shows to see which one you like more. 

 

I agree with past posts that don't think Seasons 4-5 of Smart are as good as the first 3 years.  NOTHING beats seasons 1 and 2 of Get Smart when it comes to comedies.  U.N.C.L.E. gets better in season 2, slips in Season 3 (with some good episodes still), and comes back strong in season 4.

 

As for Special Features: Get Smart has some great bloopers and Intros by Agent 99.  U.N.C.L.E. has some great interviews with the cast and behind the scenes info.

Rent both shows and then decide.  :)

Since both are fairly expensive purchases, I think your best bet is to rent the first disc or two of each series and see which you enjoy more.

You need to remember that some shows probably ran out of ideas or how to spice the shows up after long durations. I am looking at buying the Man from U.N.C.L.E next year, because i am huge James Bond/Spy series fan.

I have the 1-3 season for Get smart and will be picking up season four in October. I grew up watching get smart in syndication and glad that i have this show on dvd.

I recommend the equalizer/Callan/etc as other spy series that could be of interest too you.

Ditto on the Equalizer.  I have the S1 set and it's a great 80's spy/"CIA" flavor type show. 

Skip both and buy all three seasons of I Spy (which you can get for about $14 each). The exotic locations are real, the stories aren't dated (because they don't depend on gimmicks or tired fads), and the chemistry between the leads Robert Culp and Bill Cosby is unmatched in television buddy history. Oh, and did I mention Bill Cosby. So this series has your spy element PLUS a very and engaging sense of natural humor. You won't be disappointed.

If you are going down the Region 2 route 'Callan' has excellent storylines. Very different to UNCLE though, very bleak & serious.

May I also recommend 'Sandbaggers' (R2), this is not an action/adventure series in any way but very believable.

Yes, both aired in the U.S. at times. I believe the Avengers aired on one of the major networks back in the later 1960's. It was apparently nominated for Emmy's in 1967 and 1968. I did not catch it until aired by the BBC on a PBS channel in the late 1970's.

The show Honey West was created in the U.S. due to the success of the Avengers in Britain, but when the Avengers was brought to the U.S. a year later Honey West was cancelled. Apparently, the feeling was there was not enough room for two dynamic female spy leads.

The Prisoner is the classic of all thinking man (read: smart) spy series and holds up marvelously. So much so that it is being re-released this October in a complete blu-ray set domestically. It first aired in the United States on PBS, I believe, then later, and often, on A&E, which released the previous box DVD set.

The Avengers originally aired in the United States on ABC, if I recall, then later, repeatedly on A&E like The Prisoner. If you both like chess, The Prisoner is definitely your cup of tea. If you like your spy dramas light, whimsical, sophisticated, with tongue firmly in cheek, and featuring the prototype sexy, smart, female spy that both men AND women adore, you can't go wrong with Diana Rigg as Mrs. Emma Peel in The Avengers. It continues to sell so well that it will probably get a blu-ray release, as well. Skip the horrible movie made more recently, though, and, IMHO, anything post-Diana Rigg.

Matt, all the UK  shows mentioned ,so far, except ,I think, Callan, aired on the US networks, usually as summer replacements or mid-season replacements for US shows that were cancelled.

DANGER MAN was on CBS: April 1961- to September 1961.
SECRET AGENT was on CBS: April 1965 to September 1965, and December 1965 to September 1966.
THE PRISONER was on CBS: June 1968 to September 1968 and rerun: May 1969 to September 1969.
MAN IN A SUITCASE was on ABC: May 1968 to September 1968.
THE AVENGERS, were on ABC March 1966 to September 1966, January 1967 to September 1967, and January 1968 to September 1969.  THE NEW AVENGERS were on CBS LATE NIGHT in 1978-1980.
THE SAINT black and white episodes were syndicated to US independent stations in the early 60's. NBC picked up the color episodes which were aired: May 1967 To September 1967, Feb. 1968 to Sept 1968, and April 1969 to Sept. 1969.  

Just a suggestion, but if you're not particularly interested in the extras, Target has a package of the first and second seasons of "Get Smart" for $19.99. That's pretty tough to beat!

Hmm, edit that remark, 'cause Target just beat their own price. The two-season "Get Smart" package is in Target's ad for $14.99 this week.

Would you believe $13.99?

I own both full sets and highly recommend both series.  Which would I recommend first?  Depends on what you're in the mood to watch.  Comedy? - Get Smart.  Drama/Adventure/Buddy? U.N.C.L.E.  Price?  Get Smart wins as individual seasons typically are available at a very good price. The drawback if you're into extras is that the individual seasons don't have the bonus disk of extras per season that the box has.

Get Smart:  S1-3 are the best.  It kind of jumped the shark when Max and 99 got married.  I got tired of waiting for the individual seasons to be released and purchased the box set from TL.  While I got a good, from them, price I still feel a bit ripped off.  Cheesy packaging and extras that I'll never watch, *but* I really don't regret the purchase... just the price.  Run to Target this week for the $14.99 (or maybe less) price for the first 2 seasons.  Even if you don't like 'em it's a very inexpensive way to find out and possibly less than a rental if you don't like 'em and sell them off.

Man from U.N.C.L.E.: I like it all.  Even the more campy S3, but lean more towards the 1st and 2nd as the best seasons.  I purchased the 1st season to be sure my fond memories of its' original airing were on track and then picked up the box set from CH for ~$65 during a sale.  One thing to watch out for on this one if you start with S1 is that the opening is rather weak and feels like it goes on forever.  It's identical for *every* episode and does nothing but introduce the principals.  Fortunately it changes to an vastly improved open about half way through the season.  The "put an innocent in jeopardy by having them help" ploy each episode can get a bit tiresome but overall it works well and introduces a bit of uncertainty into the proceedings.

I also recommend "I Spy" as a great, more realistic take on the spy genre.  It's lots of fun with good stories, dialog, and location shooting.  It's the series that put Bill Cosby on the map.  It can also be picked up for less than $40 everyday at amazon or DD for the entire 3 season run and regularly goes on sale for less.  I got all 3 for ~$15 during a B1G1 sale at DD sometime back.

Of course you should also consider adding these at some time:
The Avengers (Emma Peel series is best, currently OOP)
Danger Man (aka Secret Agent) - currently OOP.
Danger Mouse (if you like Danger Man and/or animation)
The Saint (also OOP)
The Prisoner
Honey West
Dangerous Assignment (a fun little series of 39 episodes from the 1950s.  The first TV spy series.)

Bottom line:  Pick up the Get Smart S1/S2 set from Target first.

I have a question for those of that have The Man From UNCLE. I've never watched the show so on a blind buy I got a set from an ebay seller. The case was sealed but when I opened it up, it looks used as discs have fingerprints om them and I've so far at least one that is scratched. Were the individual sets inside the case sealed? What I got the individual sets each have a plastic cover, but they look badly worn.

The individual sets were not sealed.

Thanks for the response. Judging by all the fingerprints and scratches I think I'll be sending this back and look to get one elsewhere.

Duane,

That's a bummer about your UNCLE eBay set.  That eBay buying can be tricky at times.  I've almost bought a couple of megasets off eBay but passed on them for the same concern as what you found with your UNCLE set.  I actually had better results going thru iOFFER for another series set that I wanted to buy.