New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Midnight Express

post #1 of 19
Thread Starter 


MIDNIGHT EXPRESS


Studio: Sony/Columbia 

Year: 1978 

Rated: R 

Program Length: 121 minutes 

Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 1080p 

Languages: English, French, Portuguese Dolby TrueHD 5.1; English Mono 

Subtitles: English, English SDH, French, Portuguese, Spanish


The Program

 

Midnight Express is a harrowing tale about a young American, Billy Hayes, who is arrested while trying to fly home from Turkey in 1970 with a modest stash of hashish taped to his body. While under most circumstances it would be difficult to feel sympathy for a drug smuggler, the brutality to which Hayes is subjected will make even the most passionate anti-drug activist root for him. Although Hayes is originally sentenced to a relatively light four-year prison sentence, Turkish law allows prosecutors to appeal sentences with which they does not agree. Less than two months before Hayes is scheduled to be released, the Turkish High Court throws out Hayes’ drug possession conviction and pronounces him guilty of drug smuggling, which carries a sentence of thirty years.

 

Based upon a true story, but considerably fictionalized, Midnight Express was nominated for six Academy Awards, winning for Best Adapted Screenplay (Oliver Stone) and Best Original Score (Giorgio Moroder). The film also was nominated for Best Picture, Best Director (Alan Parker), and Best Supporting Actor (John Hurt). It features a bravura theatrical debut by the late Brad Davis as Hayes. Davis took home a Golden Globe Award for Best Motion Picture Acting Debut (male). There also is excellent supporting work by Randy Quaid as a fellow prisoner. Irene Miracle, who won a Golden Globe for Best Motion Picture Acting Debut (female), plays Hayes’ girlfriend.

 

Midnight Express was a difficult sell to the studio, which was expecting more of a thriller and was squeamish about releasing a film which had a convicted drug smuggler as its protagonist. Nevertheless, the film proved to be a major hit, albeit a somewhat controversial one. Turkey complained about the way the country is portrayed in the film, and years later both Oliver Stone and the real Billy Hayes apologized to the Turks – sort of. Stone says that he never actually apologized, though he did express regret that the film was seen by some as anti-Turk.

 

I recall being on the edge of my seat while watching this film in a theater 31 years ago, and it has lost none of its impact. I guarantee that anyone who watches Midnight Express will always take extra care to avoid antagonizing the authorities while traveling in foreign countries. It is one of the more highly-regarded films of the 1970s and is highly recommended.

 

The Video

 

The 1.85:1 1080p widescreen transfer is very nice and smooth. There is a minimal but appropriate amount of grain, good contrast, and accurate flesh tones. There are many dark scenes but shadow detail is reasonably good. The Blu-ray transfer is a noticeable improvement over the 30th Anniversary DVD, but there are some inherent limitations which prevent it from being a demo disc. Some of the scenes were filmed with a deliberately hazy look, and others are done is slightly soft focus. On the other hand, during the scene where Hayes is being questioned by a customs officer at the Istanbul airport, you can count the beads of sweat on his forehead and face. Sony has been doing an excellent job of late at producing Blu-rays discs of older films which retain the look of film, and Midnight Express is no exception.

 

The Audio

 

The original soundtrack was recorded in mono, so fans of the film will be happy to learn that the mono soundtrack has been preserved here. There also is a remixed Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack, which adds some dimensionality and sounded perfectly satisfactory to my ears. Both soundtracks convey the dialogue very well and I did not detect any distortion or other annoying anomalies.

 

The Supplements

 

The extras include a booklet written by director Alan Parker, which essentially is his memoir of the making of the film. The booklet includes a number of photographs, including a color photo of Brad Davis, John Hurt and Alan Parker with the real Billy Hayes at the Cannes Film Festival. Parker makes some insightful comments about the “truth” of Midnight Express:

 

Certainly, it was based on a true story. But that doesn’t mean that it was a true story. As I have tried to re-count here, it had gone through too many hands and minds with too many agendas to be totally true. What is truth anyway, with such a project?

 

There also is a commentary track by the director and three featurettes about the production of Midnight Express, all of which originally appeared on the 30th Anniversary DVD. “The Producers” focuses on Peter Guber, David Puttnam and Alan Marshall, who produced the film. “The Production” covers how the film was cast, how the locations were chosen, etc. “The Finished Film” relates how the film was marketed, including the decision to have its premiere at Cannes. The featurettes include interviews with Alan Parker, Billy Hayes, John Hurt, and Oliver Stone.

 

The one extra which did not appears on the 30th Anniversary DVD is billed as “The Making of Midnight Express,” but it is actually a short film from 1978 entitled “I’m Healthy, I’m Alive and I’m Free.” It runs for seven minutes and intersperses footage from the film with reflections by the really Billy Hayes.

 

The Packaging

 

The single disc comes in book-style keep case in which the booklet is bound.

 

The Final Analysis

 

Midnight Express is an iconic film of the 1970s and is highly recommended. As Alan Parker says, he had to decide between making a prison film or an escape film, and he ended up making one of the most powerful prison films I have ever seen.

 

Equipment used for this review:

 

Panasonic DMP-BD50 Blu-ray player

Sharp LC-42D62U LCD display

Yamaha HTR-5890 THX Surround Receiver

BIC Acoustech speakers

Interconnects: Monster Cable

 

Release Date: July 21, 2009

 

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 19

I got this and watched it today.  Like The Deep from a couple weeks ago, Midnight Express brought back great memories of a decade of fantastic filmmaking.  Midnight Express holds up great after 30 year.  I enjoyed watching it again and having it amongst my Blu ray library.  They did a fine job on the disc.

post #3 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bradley-E View Post

I got this and watched it today.  Like The Deep from a couple weeks ago, Midnight Express brought back great memories of a decade of fantastic filmmaking.  Midnight Express holds up great after 30 year.  I enjoyed watching it again and having it amongst my Blu ray library.  They did a fine job on the disc.

Good to hear!. I was very happy with the job they did on the Deep, and all the screencaps I've seen seem to indicate they approached this one the same way
The 70's (especially the late 70's when I was a rabid moviegoer) produced a lot of my favorite films...selections well beyond the usual big crowd pleasers.
A couple others that Sony owns that I hope they kick out soon are 1776 and China Syndrome. In fact, considering this was the 30th anniversary of the latter as well as the Three Mile Island incident, I'm surprised (though not necessarily disappointed) they chose ME to get an out of the blue release rather than exploiting the anniversary of CS.
post #4 of 19
Indeed...the 70s produced some great movies.  Midnight Express is a powerful movie and I will definitely be ordering it.

Edit: typo

Edited by Dave H - 7/20/2009 at 12:26 am GMT
post #5 of 19

I am glad that Sony did not tamper with the AQ and PQ and kept it as it should be.  It has it's 70's feeling intact. They could have easily pumped up the sound and sharpened the picture.  The 70's is when I discovered film as a teenager and I am happy to see these films coming to Blu ray.  The featurettes on this disc are great.  Midnight Express cost $1.7 to produce back then.  Now that would not pay for one actor. Peter Guber was great to listen to.  During his time at Columbia he greenlit Taxi Driver, The Last Detail, Tommy...all of which the higher ups were nervous about.  All of which I'd love on Blu ray.  That was really a great time for film.  Yeah, I was thinking a couple weeks ago when it was on TCM that I would love 1776 on Blu ray...Hopefully next year.  Also, The China Syndrome, The Last Picture Show, California Suite, Murder By Death, Shampoo would be welcome by Sony for some 70's classics.

post #6 of 19
Quote:
I am glad that Sony did not tamper with the AQ and PQ and kept it as it should be.


From my past conversations with their asset Manager, I
get the feeling that the people over at Sony realize the
importance of preserving the integrity of their masters when
it comes to DVD and Blu-ray transfers.  This is one studio
you do not have to worry about DNR issues.
post #7 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronald Epstein View Post




From my past conversations with their asset Manager, I
get the feeling that the people over at Sony realize the
importance of preserving the integrity of their masters when
it comes to DVD and Blu-ray transfers.  This is one studio
you do not have to worry about DNR issues.

 


Good to hear. 
post #8 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ronald Epstein View Post




From my past conversations with their asset Manager, I
get the feeling that the people over at Sony realize the
importance of preserving the integrity of their masters when
it comes to DVD and Blu-ray transfers.  This is one studio
you do not have to worry about DNR issues.
 

Even though some titles like Ghostbusters get complaints, I'm really glad Sony does their best efforts for movies on Blu-ray.
post #9 of 19
From the photo the case looks rather square compared to other blu-ray cases. Is is smaller or is it wider than other cases? I can't really tell from the pic. I'm just afraid that it'll look strange on my shelf.
post #10 of 19
It is a Digibook. Yes it will stick out compared to regular BD cases. So don't put it on your shelf if how your shelf looks is more important than how the film looks. Or put all your digibooks together so the shelf looks right, starting with this, presumably your first one. There are a lot of good movies in Digibooks. I might go so far as to say that if it's in a Digibook, you can be guaranteed you're getting a good movie. Yeah, I'll say that.
post #11 of 19
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by felipenor View Post

From the photo the case looks rather square compared to other blu-ray cases. Is is smaller or is it wider than other cases? I can't really tell from the pic. I'm just afraid that it'll look strange on my shelf.

A standard BD case is 5 3/8" by 6 3/4" . The Sony case for Midnight Express BD is 5 5/8"  by 7".
post #12 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by CraigF View Post

It is a Digibook. Yes it will stick out compared to regular BD cases. So don't put it on your shelf if how your shelf looks is more important than how the film looks. Or put all your digibooks together so the shelf looks right, starting with this, presumably your first one. There are a lot of good movies in Digibooks. I might go so far as to say that if it's in a Digibook, you can be guaranteed you're getting a good movie. Yeah, I'll say that.

Actually, I have some Warner digibooks. Is this the same size of a Warner digibook?
post #13 of 19
^ Yes, they're exactly the same size. ME is the only non-Warner "digibook" I have. You wouldn't think 1/8" diff would stick out much on a shelf, but it sure makes a lot of itself.

[Edit: so much for my arithmetic, it's 1/4" diff which makes more sense by how it looks, doh.]

I am not sure if digibook is a Warner's trademark or something, or if it's really a package "type", it's just what we/I call them...
Edited by CraigF - 2/5/10 at 9:50pm
post #14 of 19
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CraigF View Post

I am not sure if digibook is a Warner's trademark or something, or if it's really a package "type", it's just what we/I call them...

Sony doesn't seem to have given their version of the package a name. In the press releases it's just called a booklet.
post #15 of 19
I notice that WB are re-releasing some of their digibook releases in normal cases lately Maybe Sony will do the same thing
post #16 of 19
Quote:
Originally Posted by Robin_B View Post

I notice that WB are re-releasing some of their digibook releases in normal cases lately Maybe Sony will do the same thing

Well, I find digibooks way more beautiful than regular cases, so for me it's digibooks all the way.
post #17 of 19
Has Sony released any other films in gigibook aside from Midnight Express and A River runs through it?
post #18 of 19
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by felipenor View Post

Has Sony released any other films in gigibook aside from Midnight Express and A River runs through it?

Yes, at least three that I know of: Dr. Strangelove, Easy Rider, and Silverado.
post #19 of 19
I'll be picking up these 5 then. Any other Sony title on digibook?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF Blu-ray Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread: