Re: What kind of Movie Director would you be?
I have no idea what kind of director I'd be, but I can answer what type of director I'd like to be, by sharing traits from some of my favorite directors (and maybe some of the good instincts of some not-so-great directors).
1) Michael Mann - he is the hardest to nail down. I love his films, and I have a hard time verbalizing exactly why. His economy is breathtaking, and he frames shots like no one else. He invokes his themes visually, whereas most directors rely on dialogue (or worse, exposition), and this is a tremendous talent. He also is one of the very best at matching music to scene-specific visuals. A complete professional at his job.
2) Terrence Malick - this is very presumptuous of me. Because Malick is probably twice as smart and observant as I am, I could never hope to match his ability. What I love about Malick is that he brings fresh eyes to old situations and stories. It is literally like you are experiencing something for the first time with his films. This sounds pretentious, and I don't mean it to be so, but he is capable of using the right shots to enable his audience to subconsciously make connections. It's subtle and powerful. He also chooses the most beautiful shots ever

3) Big Jim Cameron - Cameron is a thinker. His dialogue is sometimes poor, but his scripts are always very strong. Few directors know the audience better. His characters exist, not just in the two hour runtime, but within the established framework of his universe. That lends a tremendous amount of believability to his films. He is also very creative in his action sequences, while always ensuring geography, motivation, and movements are understandable to viewers.
4) David Fincher - perfectionist. Uses visual effects much better than most. Rarely for spectacle, but for storytelling. Methodical. Dark sense of humor. Master of light and shadow.
5) Guillermo del Toro - just for his imagination. He can blend creepy, beautiful, whimsical, and horrifying better than anyone.
Other directors I love: Martin Scorcese, Brad Bird, Steven Spielberg, Chris Nolan, Ridley Scott, Darren Aronofsky, Peter Jackson, the Wachowski Brothers, the Coen Brothers, Bob Zemeckis
And this is only scratching the surface.