Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › A Few Words About By Robert Harris › A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

post #1 of 48
Thread Starter 
There are three films, each of which I probably saw twenty times in my cinema classes at NYU.

Ingmar Bergman's Wild Strawberries and The Seventh Seal, and Michelangelo Antonioni's L'avventura.

Always in 16mm in occasionally worn, but quality Janus prints, I was led to wonder what was just on the other side of the rainbow. What would these films have looked like in pristine 35mm black & white, properly graded with rich grays, full blacks and constantly readable sub-titles?

If there had been Blu-rays four decades ago I would have be able to find out. Today's cinema classes that take advantage of quality digital projection will be one of the beneficiaries of Criterion's newest incarnation of Mr. Bergman's classic, The Seventh Seal. And they will see the film as I would have liked to have seen it in 35mm, but even cleaner and better.

Make no mistake. The Seventh Seal is not only brilliant filmmaking, but having attained a well deserved stature over the past half century, is very near the top of any knowledgeable cineaste's list as one of the greatest films ever created.

There are no half measures here in referring to The Seventh Seal. And none have been taken in the creation of this new Blu-ray.

In normal Criterion fashion, there are a multitude of extras, inclusive (and this surprised me, as Criterion has just given it its own release), Marie Nyrerod's 2006, 83 minute documentary, Bergman's Island.

It's quite obvious that it is Criterion's intent that their Blu-ray of The Seventh Seal be available to everyone, even students, and the proof is in the pricing. Currently the documentary is $15 on Amazon. For $25 ($10 more) you receive The Seventh Seal in all its glory along the full Criterion treatment.

The Seventh Seal is a gorgeous Blu-ray in every detail both visually and sonically, with an audio track the likes of which I have never heard before synchronized to this film. Kudos to everyone behind this project!

The Seventh Seal is a must own.

Very Highly Recommended.

RAH
post #2 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

I wonder how it compares with the Tartan Blu-ray release. Some guy from the other forum reviewed it last year

It was beautiful.
post #3 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xylon
I wonder how it compares with the Tartan Blu-ray release. Some guy from the other forum reviewed it last year

It was beautiful.

They seem to be using the same restored print (for the 50th anniversary re-release??). Criterion shows higher bitrate than Tartan, however they look almost identical unless you check very closely.
post #4 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

I'm holding on to the Tartan just for the behind-the-scenes footage and Karin's Face, but buying the Criterion was an absolute no-brainer.
post #5 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

Quote:
Originally Posted by blimey
They seem to be using the same restored print (for the 50th anniversary re-release??). Criterion shows higher bitrate than Tartan, however they look almost identical unless you check very closely.
HF detail of the grain is far better resolved on the higher bit rate BD of Criterion. The difference is sometimes not subtle at all. Grain like this can really use 30+ Mbit/s AVC.
post #6 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xylon
I wonder how it compares with the Tartan Blu-ray release. Some guy from the other forum reviewed it last year

It was beautiful.
DVD Beaver (don't know if they're up to your standards, Xylon ) did a comparison, and there conclusions were that the Criterion appears sharper and had fewer compression artifacts than the Tartan release.

The Seventh Seal - Blu-ray Max von Sydow Ingmar Bergman
post #7 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

This Blu-ray is amazing A very happy buyer here.
post #8 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

UPS just delivered mine. A few minutes earlier and I would've been watching it right now. Instead I'll have to wait a bit, but hopefully I'll get to it soon. It sounds fantastic.
post #9 of 48
Thread Starter 

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

Seventh Seal is a perfect example of how the power of Blu-ray can enable proper film reproduction for the home theater.
post #10 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

the detail in this transfer is staggering. You could blow this up to 50 feet and it would still knock your socks off.
post #11 of 48

Re: A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michel_Hafner
HF detail of the grain is far better resolved on the higher bit rate BD of Criterion. The difference is sometimes not subtle at all. Grain like this can really use 30+ Mbit/s AVC.

The SL Tartan disc had a lot of problems replicating the rather coarse grain structure of The Seventh Seal and I am very happy to read that Criterion improved upon this.
post #12 of 48

Yes, the transfer is staggering, but the "Det" of Det sjunde inseglet is missing. The full title was there last week in the near pristine print of the film I saw at LACMA, but on the blu ray we only get sjunde inseglet off center, leaving a space that is clearly where Det had been. What kind of mistake would remove a word from the Main Title? And what idiot in QC didn't catch it? Criterion cannot claim to offer full representations of classic films on home video if the film as intended is not there. Worse, why have no reviewers caught this?

post #13 of 48

It was mentioned in DVD Beaver's review/comparison of the disc.

http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film2/DVDReviews34/seventh_seal_blu-ray.htm

 

It appears the "Det" was missing from the film print supplied by Svensk Filmindustri.

post #14 of 48


Quote:
Originally Posted by 24fpssean View Post

And what idiot in QC didn't catch it? Criterion cannot claim to offer full representations of classic films on home video if the film as intended is not there. Worse, why have no reviewers caught this?


DVD Beaver caught it (see their review here).  I would assume other reviews don't read Swedish, or didn't notice it.  Probably both.

 

I highly doubt that it's a QC issue.  The print you saw at LACMA is almost certainly not the same print used for Criterion's blu-ray.  Interestingly, the Tartan blu-ray also has the "Det" missing from the title (I own both blu-rays; it's one of my favorite films of all time).  Criterion didn't create the print.... Svensk Filmindustri provided it.  Criterion didn't make a "mistake," nor are they "idiots."  Jesus, what a tiny detail to bitch about.  Dude, sell your copy and get Criterion's earlier DVD from 2001.  It looks like shit by comparison, but at least it has your precious "Det" intact.  The rest of us will continue to thank Criterion for their work, and not hurl unfounded insults at them.

post #15 of 48

You're right, after all it is only home video and doesn't affect the actual negative of the film itself. Why not remove the entire title? Apparently that wouldn't matter either.

post #16 of 48


Quote:
Originally Posted by 24fpssean View Post

You're right, after all it is only home video and doesn't affect the actual negative of the film itself. Why not remove the entire title? Apparently that wouldn't matter either.

 

It's one word --- three letters --- missing for a few seconds.  White words against a black background.  Does this actually detract from your enjoyment of the film?  If it does.... wow, man.

 

post #17 of 48

No, it doesn't detract. But again we are talking about the integrity, the original intent of the filmmaker. Again it's only home video, who gives a squat?!. And trust me, in this industry, there are plenty of idiots pushing the buttons.

post #18 of 48


Quote:
Originally Posted by 24fpssean View Post

No, it doesn't detract. But again we are talking about the integrity, the original intent of the filmmaker. Again it's only home video, who gives a squat?!. And trust me, in this industry, there are plenty of idiots pushing the buttons.


Yeah, I'm sure Bergman is spinning in his grave over this travesty. 

 

I've studied Bergman.... watched his films, read his books, shopped at Ikea and dated a Swedish exchange student in high school (okay, those last two probably didn't enhance my understanding of the man).  I can say with a reasonable degree of certainty that he wouldn't interpret the missing "Det" as an assault on his "original intent."  He wasn't that petty.

 

post #19 of 48

Bergman willingly prepped two entirely different versions of both Scenes from a Marriage and Fanny & Alexander to accommodate both TV and theatrical releases. I don't think he'd be all that stressed out over a "The".

post #20 of 48

I dunno. "Unforgiven" (1992) is a totally different film from "The Unforgiven" (1960).

post #21 of 48

And let's not forget that Them! is most unlike M.

 

I mean, come on fellas, what The...

post #22 of 48

Damn this looks like an amazing bluray - I only wish Criterion would release this (and other blu titles) into the UK, or consider encoding region-free discs...

post #23 of 48

The depths that HTFer's will stoop to in order to bitch about something never ceases to amaze me.

post #24 of 48

My point has been made.

post #25 of 48

Wow - you reopened a thread that'd been dormant for six months so you could... what exactly? confused.gif

post #26 of 48

So I could re-open an old wound for people who've never touched film, never worked on a feature film, never seen theatrically the classic films they critic on blu ray, or who generally live through the internet.

 

Or perhaps it was just because I'd forgotten about this thread for six months because I was working.

post #27 of 48

It must be hard to have to associate with all us lowly internet peasants who haven't worked on a movie.

post #28 of 48


Quote:
Originally Posted by 24fpssean View Post

So I could re-open an old wound for people who've never touched film, never worked on a feature film, never seen theatrically the classic films they critic on blu ray, or who generally live through the internet.


I'm pretty sure you're the only one with any scar tissue showing here.

post #29 of 48


Quote:
Originally Posted by Brandon Conway View Post




I'm pretty sure you're the only one with any scar tissue showing here.



Yup.  One dude's who's bitter about a missing "det" - everyone else seems pretty content...laugh.gif

post #30 of 48

It would be a different story of course if "The" was missing from say the on screen title of, The Magnificent Seven, that would detract from my enjoyment of the film, in fact I'll be pretty pissed off and demand my money back. But since it happened to a foreign film, who cares? smiley_wink.gif

 

Thanks for the review RAH, The Seventh Seal is one of my favourite Swedish films, not that I've seen many. I'm not a big fan of the Dragon Tattoo trilogy. But I did enjoy Let the Right One in..

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › A Few Words About By Robert Harris › A few words about...™ The Seventh Seal -- in Blu-ray