Quote:
Originally Posted by
Joe Karlosi 
I'll be looking forward to it. I am kind of stunned that you feel somewhat like I do about revisits. But who knows, if we all start chatting more again it could influence me to see more first-timers. Without you I never would have enjoyed the Luis Bunuel films I have.
O.K., so let's start with the "stunner" first, then.
Consider the list below of my Top 20 movies. You will find in there also the total number of viewings that each film received from me over the years; whether I own it on DVD (and, in some cases, in what number of quantities - obviously, we're talking about different editions here i.e. regions or labels) or not; and, finally, the number of times I've seen that particular film on DVD (which, for all intents and prurposes, is the optimal home viewing medium so far):
1. BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN (1935) – Watched: 9; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 2
1. THE OLD DARK HOUSE (1932) – Watched: 5; DVD Own: 2, Seen: 3
2. THE DISCREET CHARM OF THE BOURGEOISIE (1972) – Watched: 5; DVD Own: 2, Seen: 1
3. NORTH BY NORTHWEST (1959) – Watched: 6; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
4. HIS GIRL FRIDAY (1940) – Watched: 4; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
5. CITIZEN KANE (1941) – Watched: 6; DVD Own: 2, Seen: 1
6. M (1931) – Watched: 6; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 0
7. THE THIRD MAN (1949) – Watched: 4; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
8. DOUBLE INDEMNITY (1944) – Watched: 3; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 0
9. THE RULES OF THE GAME (1939) – Watched: 3; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
10. THE PASSION OF JOAN OF ARC (1928) – Watched: 4; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
11. A MATTER OF LIFE AND DEATH (1946) – Watched: 3; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 0
12. TO BE OR NOT TO BE (1942) – Watched: 3; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 0
13. DR. JEKYLL AND MR. HYDE (1931) – Watched: 5; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
14. NOSFERATU (1922) – Watched: 4; DVD Own: 2, Seen: 0
15. SHERLOCK JR. (1924) – Watched: 5; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
16. NIGHT OF THE DEMON (1957) – Watched: 4; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 2 (i.e. both versions)
17. EYES WITHOUT A FACE (1959) – Watched: 5; DVD Own: 1, Seen: 1
18. A MAN ESCAPED (1956) – Watched: 3; DVD Own: 0, Seen: 0
19. SANSHO THE BAILIFF (1954) – Watched: 2; DVD Own: 2, Seen: 0
20. THE SCARLET EMPRESS (1934) – Watched: 2; DVD Own: 0, Seen: 0
Should I really be considering the majority of these as 'favorites' when I've seen some of them just twice and, in some cases, I haven't even deigned them of a single whirl in my DVD player?
Technically, being favorites and all, I should even be considering an upgrade of a few of them - BRIDE OF FRANKENSTEIN, NORTH BY NORTHWEST and NOSFERATU - to the more recent 'improved' edtions on the market (and I'm not even talking about BluRay here)! But how sensible would that be in view of the fact that I haven't given the 'older' DVD editions that much of a workout during these last 8 years?
Therefore, I'm starting to see how, say, dedicating one day a week to revisiting famliar movies and another one to those films with which I'm not all that familiar, makes a whole lot of sense after all. For example, it burns me up that I haven't seen VERTIGO (1958) in about 15 years but, then, I only own the older SE DVD rather than the upgraded 2-Discer! Also, it burns me up that I've seen Wojciech J. Has' THE SARAGOSSA MANUSCRIPT (1964) - one of Luis Bunuel's favorite films - just once when I bought the Image DVD 7 years ago! But, then, I've just acquired two other films from the Polish director this very week - THE NOOSE (1957) and his 'masterpiece' THE DOLL (1968) - and, therefore, shouldn't I sensibly be watching these 'new' ones first before giving SARAGOSSA a second look?
But, then, if we're talking about listing favorites, there's this other thing for me to consider: the following are my favorite 12 film-makers and, next to each, is listed the amount of unwatched (as in 'new') films of theirs that I have in my entire movie collection (not just DVDs):
Robert Bresson: 1
Luis Bunuel: 0
Carl Theodor Dreyer: 3 features; 4 shorts
Howard Hawks: 6
Alfred Hitchcock: 6 features; 1 short
Fritz Lang: 10
Kenji Mizoguchi: 13
F. W. Murnau: 3
Jean Renoir: 3
Josef von Sternberg: 3
Orson Welles: 0
James Whale: 5
Should I really be entertaining the notion of revisiting VERTIGO again when I've got UNDER CAPRICORN (1949) lying here unwatched, too? Incidentally, just a few hours ago, I received Optimum's 8-Disc Set of "The Luis Bunuel Collection" which, in most cases, consists of improved DVD editions (i.e 30-minute documentaries and 1 Audio Commentary) of Bunuel films which I already own on DVD or VHS. When I ordered the set online, I told my brother that we really should watch the supplements immediately (if nothing else) - even though I do own 3 books on Bunuel already! But, if Bunuel is my favorite director, so has James Whale directed my 2 all-time favorite films...and I've got 5 of the man's movies sitting here collecting dust!!
So, when all is said and done, it's not such a clear-cut victory for the Karlosi camp as it first appeared, is it

? But, admittedly, I certainly do feel now (more than ever before) that taking time out from searching for and making new discoveries - say, twice a week -- is a feasible and, indeed, desirable idea. After all, even Michael revists stuff far more regularly than I do myself

.
Edited by Mario Gauci - 9/9/09 at 11:06pm