Quote:
Originally Posted by
mattCR 
I'm not to say it wouldn't bomb anyway. I'm saying the decision to bump Jay for Conan and move Jay may turn out to be a strategic terrible move.... That's the question that hovers over this.
I think the point, though, is that there is a difference between making that assertion based on sound foundation, and making that assertion simply because you don't like the ramifications of this being
a success. The vast majority of criticisms of The Jay Leno Show and NBC programming it five nights a week, stem from animosity for the content of the program, not sincere informed concern for its chances of success. There are a lot of people in Hollywood who stand to lose a lot (like a good number of future jobs) if this is a success. And there are a lot of viewers who favor scripted programming who stand to lose a lot, as well. And that fear of this being successful is prompting a lot of the criticisms, with practically nothing else serving as foundation for the assertion that this was, as you say, "a strategic terrible move...."