Re: "TERMINATOR: The Sarah Connor Chronicles" Season 2 Thread
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Quentin
I don't think you guys are thinking outside of the box enough...
Just because no one recognizes John or his name doesn't mean he can't/won't still be the leader of the resistance. He's just not the leader the way we all initially presumed he would be.
|
I did:
Exactly. If you accept the events of T3 on the overall storyline, John would have had to find his way to the bunker and start forming the resistence.
Even if he did not, he would have been in the trenches and slowly worked his way up to leader. It's possible that's what would happen in this new timeline.
However while it's possible, the likelihood that an already established human resistance would cede authority anytime soon to a teenage boy is slim to none.
Quote:
| Instead, he may now take over as a teen (not a man) who knows more about what they're fighting than anyone else (and who also has an alliance with 'good' machines). He could still send Kyle back to father him and still send Derek back to help him. |
I could buy this except that Kyle is shown returning from the past looking exactly like Sarah remembers him. Had Kyle been among those who initially found John in the future, and had we not seen Sarah's hallucinations of Kyle, I could buy that an older Kyle (who looks more like Michael Biehn circa 1984) was sent back by John after rising up in the ranks over several years.
Quote:
| Of course, that doesn't have to be the answer either. He could hop back and forth between the past and 'present' helping his mother AND helping the future. |
This makes no sense, since each "hop" back to the past would create an entirely new future. All the risk he takes in the future would be invalidated by the changes he makes in the past. I suppose he could use the intel from each new future to shape the fight in the past. That being said, the more rare of a thing that time travel is the better. If this John were to make it back to the past (thus restoring the mainstream spectrum of timelines), he should stay there, in my less-than-humble opinion.
Quote:
| As for Allison/Cameron. I like the idea that the dog is Weaver. Heh. Now THAT is thinking outside the box. But, I think it likely is Allison and that THIS future John has reached is years ahead of the future where humanity begins to win and time hopping begins. Lots of time for John to fall in love with Allison, see her die, create a T-800 that looks like her, become leader of the resistance, etc. |
I actually really like the idea of John falling in love with the real Allison. That would be the best justification for throwing John in the future, since something lasting could come out of it. It would also give Summer Glau a more substantial (though less interesting) in the show. Every character moment with Cameron was a revelation, but by the nature of being a terminator there weren't very many of them. With Allison, John could have the experience he clearly longed for with Riley (and, on some level, Cameron).
Quote:
| Unfortunately, this episode, as good as it was, has no real answers. We're all just guessing/theorizing. |
Exactly. That's why I thought it was irresponsible for a show that knew it was probably going to be cancelled. Until that ending, I could have drawn a line in my head between this show and T4 (and even the key events of T3, if not the exact circumstances). It still wouldn't be a satisfying ending, but we could seek that out through other sources. This ending gives us all a lot to chew on, but still leaves the show well outside the Terminator mainstream.
Quote:
| For that matter, while I assume that was Weaver on the USS Jimmy Carter, why would she answer 'no' to 'will you join us'? And, how/why did Cameron interpret 'will you join us' as 'give my chip to you to carry on the fight'. |
Weaver was disappointed by the crew of the Jimmy Carter, which lacked faith in John Connor and was paid the price for it. She said as much to John Henry in the basement, warning him that humans like Ellison can prove disappointing. Rather than betray humanity, however, she worked out her own unilateral solution for saving it. But Skynet figured out her intentions, and forced her hand.
Cameron is a terminator designed and programmed to destroy humanity, but later reprogrammed to protect John Connor. Knowing as she did the proposal future John offered to WeaverBot, she must have decided that joining Weaver and John Henry was in John Connor's best interest. John Henry implanted her chip in Cromartie's skull, essentially giving Cameron access to John Henry and vice-versa. Cameron -- in Cromartie's body, with John Henry's knowledge -- hopped into the future shortly before the rest of them arrived in the basement. WeaverBot and John Connor hopped through on the same time portal.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Will_B
As an aside, I suspect that John can now save the original Allison. If we believe he'll still need to send Cameron back in time, then, Allison will still need to be taken prisoner and serve as the model for Cameron, but, John can likely give her better advice on how to escape. Hopefully.
|
It's possible that the Cameron he sends back will be built and programmed in Allison's image by John Connor himself, as Quentin suggested, in this new timeline. The difference being that the new Cameron wouldn't want to kil John Connor on some level.
Quote:
| Remember that the show runners stated they wouldn't be following the events of T3. They only needed to adhere to T1 and T2 -- which they did, and which they have. Clever! |
What they said was that the arrival of Cromartie and Cameron (which led to the first jump foward in time) changed the future as seen in T3. Somewhere in the show's universe, the nuclear bunker exists (as does Kate Brewster). However, John is no longer Kate's contemporary because of the jump foward and there's no reason to believe he would have ever ended up in that bunker to wait out Judgement Day (since the date of Judgment Day itself has also clearly changed).
As the self-destructing chips in the lastest generation of metal shows, the time travel creates a strange symbiosis: Each attempt to kill John Connor better prepares him to be the leader of the resistance. John Connor's more sophisticated tactics in turn make Skynet's methods more sophisticated.