Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › DVD › Official HTF DVD Reviews › HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

post #1 of 28
Thread Starter 
ronsreviews_covers_HVD002040.jpg
Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom
Directed by Pier Paolo Pasolini

Studio: Criterion
Year: 1976
Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1 anamorphic
Running Time: 116 minutes
Rating: NR
Audio: Dolby Digital 1.0 mono Italian, English
Subtitles: English
MSRP: $ 39.99

Release Date: August 26, 2008
Review Date: August 21, 2008


The Film

3/5

Pier Paolo Pasolini’s scathing indictment of both the Fascist-minded intelligencia in the last year of World War II and the unthinking conformists of his own time makes for a graphic and altogether horrifying film Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom. Controversial hardly describes this kinetic attack on the senses, described by some as a masterpiece and by others as the worst kind of arty trash. I rather take a middle road. Pasolini has important things to say and uses a shocking manner of visually symbolic expression with which to say them. As is often the case with passionate filmmakers, however, his excesses to make his point are often the very things which take away from the film’s eventual effectiveness.

Four aristocratic Italian men (symbolically calling themselves the duke, the magistrate, the bishop, and the president) during the last year of the war round up an extremely appealing group of fresh-faced young people and bring them to a villa for their own sadistic pleasures. Every manner of depravity and cruelty is inflicted upon the seventeen boys and girls (one boy is shot trying to escape from the truck conveying him to the villa; in retrospect, he made the right decision) as three artfully gowned prostitutes recount sexual tales which inspire the captors to indulge in their own freakish and ever-growing outlandish fantasies. During their time at this tastefully appointed mansion (the only good taste on display is the architecture and horticulture), even the guards begin to take part in the sadism and sexual games, but the four primary perverts and their increasingly grotesque desires are the focus of the story. There can be only one end for these pathetic and submissive victims, of course, as Pasolini symbolically climaxes his story in a orgy of violence and near-numbing loss, all directed at Italians who let the Fascists take over their country instead of fighting for their own honor and freedom both during the war and in his own present time. Fingers get pointed at others to save their own necks (to no avail), but very, very few stand up for their own rights.

Pasolini’s screenplay (written with Sergio Citti and others including some inspiration from Dante's Inferno) is based on the novel by the Marquis de Sade (which was left incomplete; much of the vulgarity in the film is suggested by the parts which were completed), but it’s been set in Italy near the war’s end for the director’s dual purpose. It’s a nasty, ugly piece of goods on display even when one is keenly aware of the director‘s objectives. Ironically, Pasolini’s direction is most stately and deliberate, almost classy even when dealing with the scatological and bestial nature of these sex games. The prostitutes are gowned gorgeously, there is baroque music being played as their saucy, diabolical tales are being recounted, and the camera moves with studied grace as various youths are submitted to the desires of the aggressive men.

Of the four primary men, Aldo Valletti’s salacious, sadistic President and Paolo Bonacelli’s more tender, needful Duke make the greatest impressions. Signora Castelli’s more elegant and less debauching stories are well represented by Caterina Boratto while Else de Giorgi gives her seemingly endless stories of defecation and repulsion a gleeful grace. Oddly, the children, as beautiful and well appointed as they are, make no individual impressions. They’re there to be used and abused as so much cattle, ultimately faceless once they’ve served their wicked purposes.

One of the older men says at one point that nothing is more contagious than evil. I’m not sure if that’s a quote from de Sade’s work or if it’s a Pasolini invention for the film, but how ironic that after making this utterly gruesome and shocking examination of the face of evil, Pasolini’s own life was snuffed out by a youth in a similarly shocking and brutal way. Sometimes the ironies of life are beyond comprehension.


Video Quality

4/5

The anamorphically enhanced 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio makes for a beautiful DVD. Though early on the color appears a bit dated and there are one or two dust specks and a troublesome hair, in the main, the picture quality is quite impressive. Sharpness is a notch below optimum, but flesh tones seem very realistic, color is firm if just a touch subdued, and blacks are nice and deep. The white subtitles are easy to read. The film has been divided into 23 chapters.

Audio Quality

3/5

The Dolby Digital 1.0 mono track is clear lacking hiss, crackles, or pops. There’s not much range in the mix; neither highs nor lows distinguish themselves, but it’s a solid mono track. There is an English-language dub available for selection, but I listened in the original Italian (which is also dubbed).

Special Features

4/5

The first disc contains a theatrical trailer using the English dub of the film. The sound here is quite shrill and distorted, nothing like the audio mix on the film itself. The anamorphic widescreen trailer runs 3 ½ minutes.

The rest of the bonus features are contained on disc two.

Salò: Yesterday and Today” is a 1975 4:3 documentary shot on the set of the film on the last day of shooting. This 33 ¼-minute look in black and white and color of Pasolini’s working methods along with an interview with him is perhaps the best bonus on the disc.

“Fade to Black” spends 23 ¼ minutes with three world class directors including Bernardo Bertolucci and John Maybury and film scholar David Forgacs as they discuss the film and their own reactions and interpretations of what it means. It’s in anamorphic widescreen.

“The End of Salò is a 39 ¾-minute documentary discussing the writing of the script, the banning of the film in Italy, and the preparations for the French dubbing which went on despite Pasolini’s murder the preceding weekend. It’s presented in 4:3.

Production designer Dante Ferretti talks for 11 ½ minutes about his four film experiences with director Pasolini and specifically about his work on Salò. It’s in anamorphic widescreen.

Film historian and director Jean-Pierre Gorin analyzes the movie as a modern allegory in a 27-minute critique filmed in anamorphic widescreen.

The enclosed 80-page booklet offers some film stills, six different interpretations of the movie by film critics and historians as well as excerpts from writer-critic Gideon Bachmann’s production diary, all fascinating.


In Conclusion

3.5/5 (not an average)

Pier Paolo Pasolini’s cold, detached examination of sexual corruption on a grand and inglorious scale makes Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom a one-of-a-kind experience. Fans of the film will be thrilled with the excellent video transfer offered here, and the outstanding line-up of extras will delight them even more. For all others who might be curious by the film’s notorious history, consider yourselves warned.


Matt Hough
Charlotte, NC

Gear mentioned in this thread:

post #2 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Thank you for your very insightful and respectful review.
It is obvious that you though very long and hard about SALO, as one should, before dismissing it.
post #3 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Am I mistaken in that there was supposed to have been a commentary also?
post #4 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

They went to all this trouble of creating a stellar transfer and terrific extras and yet it is still cut (by about 25 seconds). The British release is still the only uncut version.
post #5 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeff Adkins
They went to all this trouble of creating a stellar transfer and terrific extras and yet it is still cut (by about 25 seconds). The British release is still the only uncut version.

Why was that, exactly? (If you know). Was it left out in the American prints? Is the recitation supposed to be there? I'm curious.
I know Criterion works hard to get the best possible version of the film out, often trying to get director's or dp's approvements (okay, that's going to get difficult here, I know) and it would seem like an odd mistake to make, even twice.
post #6 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Brian Borst
Why was that, exactly? (If you know). Was it left out in the American prints? Is the recitation supposed to be there? I'm curious.
I know Criterion works hard to get the best possible version of the film out, often trying to get director's or dp's approvements (okay, that's going to get difficult here, I know) and it would seem like an odd mistake to make, even twice.
I wish I had an answer for this. At the very least they should have included the scene in the supplements with an explanation as to why they didn't include it.
post #7 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeff Adkins
They went to all this trouble of creating a stellar transfer and terrific extras and yet it is still cut (by about 25 seconds). The British release is still the only uncut version.

I've always been curious about this movie but would, as always, like the complete version; which sceen is left out and how does it impact the Criterion version?
post #8 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

From the IMDB:

The Criterion DVD omits a short 25-second sequence during the first wedding ceremony, where one of the masters quotes a poem by Gottfried Benn. The sequence is intact on the R2 BFI DVD.

Time Magazine gives the disc an A- in the current issue.
post #9 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

It appears that old R2 BFI dvd (which looks absolutely horrid) is apparently the only one that includes those extra 25 seconds. Cut by Pasolini in the 70's perhaps?

Regardless I expect the BFI's upcoming Blu-ray to omit the sequence as well since they're probably going to use the same restoration/transfer.
post #10 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Could it be that the publishers of the poem wanted too much money to reclear it? I think any literature that's still in copyright has the same issues that pop songs have when they're featured in a film.
post #11 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Dalek
It appears that old R2 BFI dvd (which looks absolutely horrid) is apparently the only one that includes those extra 25 seconds.

The scene is also present on the German DVD from Legend Home Entertainment.
You're quite right about the wretched picture quality on the BFI disc though. Cut or not, the new Criterion disc is an absolute godsend by comparison.
post #12 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Edward Heuck
Could it be that the publishers of the poem wanted too much money to reclear it? I think any literature that's still in copyright has the same issues that pop songs have when they're featured in a film.
That's a likely scenario. I had never thought of that but I'll bet you're right.
post #13 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

So damn tempted to pick this up. Saw it at a film festival many moons ago.

However, I think it has been banned for a second time in Australia. Pretty bizarre when you can wander down to your local Blockbuster and pick up Cannibal Holocaust.
post #14 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Edward Heuck
Could it be that the publishers of the poem wanted too much money to reclear it? I think any literature that's still in copyright has the same issues that pop songs have when they're featured in a film.

That's almost certainly it. Benn didn't die until 1956, so his poetry is definitely under copyright. Who knows, maybe Pasolini didn't clear it in the first place and Benn's heirs objected to his work being associated with the film at all.
post #15 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

According to the BFI site, the upcoming blu-ray will be "fully uncut":

"PRE-ORDER Salo, or The 120 Days of Sodom: Blu-Ray
Pasolini, Pier Paolo
Currently not in stock: please check publication date or contact us for information
The BFI is proud to present its first Blu-ray release.

Banned, censored and reviled the world over since its release, Pasolinis final and most controversial masterpiece is presented here fully uncut and uncensored in a brand new restoration. The content and imagery of Salo is extreme: it retains the power to shock, repel and distress. But it remains a cinematic milestone: culturally significant, politically vital, visually stunning.

Based on a novel by the Marquis de Sade - and taking as it setting the miniature fascist republic which Mussolini established in 1944 in Italy - this is a film about power, corruption, and the degradation of the human body. It is a devastating, angry cry from one of the most controversial auteurs in cinema history."

BFI Filmstore Italy

If this pans-out, I will add this to the newly reissued Criterion version for a personal "Ultimate Edition" (no PAL capabilities for the blu-ray's second disc of extras.).

Jimmy

PS- The original Criterion dvd was in fact withdrawn due to licensing issues, but the issues were with the Pasolini estate. Perhaps the estate has ownership of the poem in question? Who knows...
post #16 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimmy Nugent
According to the BFI site, the upcoming blu-ray will be "fully uncut"
I just ordered the BFI/MGM Blu-Ray from England. I've read a couple of places that said the poem will be intact. We'll see. For $34 it's worth taking a chance on.
post #17 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

After hearing about this movie for years I finally saw it a few months ago.

As a lover of movies........frankly I thought "Salo" was crap.
post #18 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Michael-

To each his own. In my opinion, Salo is probably one of the most frightening movies I've ever seen, with Irreversible running a close second. It reveals the depravity and viciousness inherent in the human species. The sense that these atrocities probably did and still do occur is incredibly unsettling. To me, Salo is the grandfather of modern day torture-porn, but holds the distinction of plausibility. Salo makes the Hostel films look like kinky travelogues.

Just my 2 cents...

Jimmy
post #19 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Criterion addresses the missing seconds on their blog:

On Five: The Criterion Collection Blog
post #20 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

It looks like the new BFI DVD will also carry alot of the Criterion extras as well.
post #21 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon Martin
Criterion addresses the missing seconds on their blog:

On Five: The Criterion Collection Blog
As I suspected the poem scene is an anomaly confined purely to that particular element used on the BFI dvd. As its not in the original negative (which I assume was cut by Pasolini) then its redundant.

Since its been mentioned that the German dvd includes that scene can anyone confirm that its a different transfer from the R2 BFI?
post #22 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

From the Criterion blog:

Quote:
Meanwhile, Lee touched base with James White, the technical director at the BFI, who was in Rome this summer working on a new transfer of the film for their upcoming rerelease. James used original film materials in Rome that didn’t contain the scene either. He said he didn’t know where the BFI got the print with the extra footage.

Interesting. if I'm interpreting this correctly, then they're basically saying that BFI's upcoming rerelease will also be missing the scene, as it's not contained on any of the new elements they're working with. It's still possible BFI will include the scene as a supplement (or pull an Anchor Bay and splice it into the main film).
post #23 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Fielder
From the Criterion blog:



Interesting. if I'm interpreting this correctly, then they're basically saying that BFI's upcoming rerelease will also be missing the scene, as it's not contained on any of the new elements they're working with. It's still possible BFI will include the scene as a supplement (or pull an Anchor Bay and splice it into the main film).

Well, there should be a drastic difference in PQ if they did that. I agree with Dalek, if it wasn't in the original negative, it probably shouldn't be there. It will be the Criterion for me.
post #24 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

And if you watch the clips connected with the blog, it seems clear that this was an editorial decision rather than a simple missing scene. No jump cuts or sudden changes in theaudio.
post #25 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Just an update for anyone still interested, a poster on CriterionForum.org who received a screener of the new BFI disc confirmed that the poem scene has been inserted into the new print.

Here's what the BFI booklet says about it:

Quote:
In order to present Salò in its complete and uncut form, this DVD edition includes a brief scene which was cut from the original negative and is only available in a 35mm print held at the BFI National Archive. Although efforts have been made to make this inserted material consistent with the overall feature, the noticeable contrast in image quality is due to the difference in source material.
post #26 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Fielder
Just an update for anyone still interested, a poster on CriterionForum.org who received a screener of the new BFI disc confirmed that the poem scene has been inserted into the new print.
See this is a problem. If the scene was cut from the original negative then IT SHOULD NOT be put back into the film. Its revisionism and it also sticks out like a sore thumb due to the ropey quality of the BFI's element.
post #27 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

They should've put it into the deleted scenes section, indeed. Wish Criterion had it as well, but after seeing it on their blog I see it's nothing special.
post #28 of 28

Re: HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom

OK, just to clear up some of the speculation:

1. The new BFI edition does indeed contain the missing scene, but the source was a 35mm print in the BFI National Archive, not the ropey original DVD edition. So while there's a shift in image quality (chiefly contrast), it's nowhere near as drastic as one might imagine - we're certainly not talking a Wicker Man situation where ropey video was the only option.

2. There's no right or wrong answer as to whether or not it should be included - as the mere fact that it was present in some 35mm prints suggests that it was in the original negative at some point! So it's by no means certain whether it was intentionally deleted or whether it was removed from the original negative for another reason (i.e. damage).

3. Contrary to early reports/rumours, the BFI Blu-Ray is DEFINITELY Region B - a contractual obligation set by the rightsholder.

More details here.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF DVD Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread:

Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › DVD › Official HTF DVD Reviews › HTF DVD REVIEW: Salò, or The 120 Days of Sodom