post #31 of 151
10/24/08 at 1:18pm
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
|
Originally Posted by MarcoBiscotti
are you serious... if you want to see the same 25 cartoons over and over again that broadcast in every single saturday morning block for the past forty years, just turn on your television set or pick up any one of the dozens upon dozens of home video releases that reissue the same slop. that's what those premiere collections were for. the looney tunes golden collections were great and I'll take any number of obscure one-shots or pre-'48 films over the same overplayed chuck jones 50's cartoons and boring crap like the roadrunner, foghorn leghorn, etc. these people should be applauded for putting together such thoughtful collections appeasing both people like yourselves who only want to watch the same bugs bunny cartoons twenty times in a row and actual film enthusiasts and collectors with an interest in owning the lesser seen but equally great works of these directors.
|
| Warner is simply going to change gears in how they release these, is all. While the studio hasn't finalized their new plans, and therefore cannot share them yet, you will of COURSE continue to see the Looney Tunes on home video in 2009. Possibly even more total shorts in a given year than we've seen in the past (but again, the plans aren't finalized, so please do NOT take that as some sort of "promise"). And these ought to all be new-to-DVD shorts, too. The indication we have from informed sources is that the studio is not planning to double-dip by mixing in already-released "Golden Collection" cartoons on the upcoming titles...whatever those titles turn out to be. We'll have details about it all when the studio is ready. The only thing we know right now that we won't see are the words "Golden Collection" as part of the title (and also "Spotlight" too, we're sure). |
|
Originally Posted by Elena S
Thanks, David.
If they're not going to release by character (which I still think is a mistake), why not release a set of Oscar-winning & nominated cartoons? Are they afraid if they do this no one will buy the other ones? |
|
Originally Posted by MarcoBiscotti
are you serious... if you want to see the same 25 cartoons over and over again that broadcast in every single saturday morning block for the past forty years, just turn on your television set or pick up any one of the dozens upon dozens of home video releases that reissue the same slop. that's what those premiere collections were for. the looney tunes golden collections were great and I'll take any number of obscure one-shots or pre-'48 films over the same overplayed chuck jones 50's cartoons and boring crap like the roadrunner, foghorn leghorn, etc. these people should be applauded for putting together such thoughtful collections appeasing both people like yourselves who only want to watch the same bugs bunny cartoons twenty times in a row and actual film enthusiasts and collectors with an interest in owning the lesser seen but equally great works of these directors.
|
| Thanks for the review, Mark. You said "My guess (and fear) is that we'll be inundated with no-frills sets devoted to the most famous Warner characters, leaving the lesser-known cartoons to languish in obscurity." Truth be told, Warner cancelled the Golden Collection series last year, after reviewing sales of Vol. 5. George Feltenstein (Warner Home Video Sr. VP of Catalog) and I lobbied for one more set to get the lesser known more obscure material out there before the vault doors were completely shut. The Bosko, Buddy, propaganda and one-shot shorts on this set were selected intentionally. We might never have this chance again. I sleep better knowing PAGE MISS GLORY, BOSKO'S PICTURE SHOW, RUSSIAN RHAPSODY -- and even NORMAN NORMAL -- amongst others included here, are restored. If the sales are better than expected, the Golden Collections could possibly continue. So tell all your friends to buy it! In the meantime, Warners is still restoring the library, 60 cartoons a year, and we are working to configure new packages to release on a regular basis. |
|
Originally Posted by Kevin Martinez
That's optimistic?
The situation is pretty dire. Obviously Warner Bros' confidence in the profitability of Looney Tunes on DVD has been severely diminished. Because the earlier sets were so heavily geared towards the obscure/unknown stuff, the low sales of them means we won't be getting any more of them. Ever again. |
|
Originally Posted by Kevin Martinez
That's optimistic?
|
|
Originally Posted by Brian Himes
Well, I finished watching this collection (except for the special features) and I have to say that I'm not all that pleased with this set. If this is what they call 'saving the best for last' then someone really needs to learn the meaning of the word 'best.' Because in my opinion, this was the worst of all of the sets. There were very few (maybe 10) cartoons that I was familiar with. I'm one of those folks that used to watch the Bugs Bunny Road Runner Show (the 90 minute version and later reduced to an hour) in the 70s and those are the cartoons that I'm most familiar with and those are the cartoons that I really want. Most of the shorts on those shows were from 1948 and later. At least when I was watching the show. While I have nothing against any of the cartoons produced before 1948, there are not the ones that I'm really after nor are they the ones that I'm familiar with. I enjoy watching them to a degree, but they are not the ones that I continually revist over and over again.
So, needless to say discs 2 and 3 in this set really did nothing for me. For those that really are looking to get the black and white shorts, then this set is a treasure. There are lots of the old black and white shorts. I did watch the 15 bonus shorts, but these in my opinion were a travesty. The picture and sound were dreadful. It was pretty obvious that no remastering had been done to these shorts. You could see the reel change dots at the end of a couple of them and one of the black and white shorts even jumped a bit at the beginning. Not WB's best work at all. As I said earlier, I haven't watched the special features other than the bonus shorts so I can't give an opinion on the contents. All in all, this set, in my opinion, is the worst of the entire collection. I'm really disappointed in it. |
|
Originally Posted by David Rain
Frankly, I'd like to see everything released & I'll be holding my breath until that happens. In the meantime, I don't have a problem with the early and/or obscure stuff being released. Just because these shorts are considered by some to be unpopular doesn't mean they aren't very entertaining.
. |
|
Originally Posted by Tony S
I see future sets as being similar to the Woody Woodpeckersets. Something like Bugs Bunny and Friends, Daffy Duck and Friends...etc. By adding "and friends" they can add whatever they want, including the obscure early b&w shorts.
I'm sure that having lots of sets like this on the market will the casual buyer a lot to chose from. A lot of people have the mentality that they have to buy GC 1-5 before they can buy Vol 6. That's a lot of why sales decline with each volume released. Going the Character and friends route would eliminate a lot of that. Just look at how many different Scooby Doo releases there are. If Scooby was released chronologically in only expenseive 4 disc sets, It probably wouldn't have went past Vol 6 either. Instead there are many different titles to chose from priced reasonably, which is very attractive to the casual buyers and soccer moms. I think if WB goes that route with Looney Tunes they are sitting on a gold mine. WB characters are very recognizable and kids love them when they are exposed to them. . |