Re: Should WB and the BDA give HD DVD owners a "peace offering" to welcome them to Blu?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Adam Gregorich
Casablanca and Robin Hood sold fairly well for for "older" catalog titles. Keep in mind that Casablanca was available via the 5 free offer, and I don't know how many people took that as a choice (like I did). They both outsold newer catalog like Excaliber and Road Warrier, and all the other titles I mention below. Viva Las Vegas, Jailhouse Rock, Cowboys and Forbidden Planet all sold a small quantity. Rio Bravo, Viva Las Vegas, Jailhouse Rock sold about the same on both formats, BD just edged out HD DVD on Cowboys and Wild Bunch, HD DVD had over twice the number of copies sold for Dirty Dozen and Searchers. That's Entertainment hasn't been out for long, but the numbers don't look good so far.
Note: I have no idea what the expectations were for any of these titles. When I say something didn't sell well I'm looking at the number of sales; WB might actually be pleased as it may have beaten their sales estimates for all I know.
|
For ten years we've tried to get a studio to admit what is the magical number they look for in units sold for classic film release to be profitable to them and to this day they have never answered that question. Therefore, for argument's sake let's say the number is 100,000 units sold considering the current HDM market penetration to this point. If 5-6 of those titles you mentioned had reach that point like Casablanca, Robin Hood, Wild Bunch, Rio Bravo and That's Entertainment we would be seeing announcements of classic films all over the internet.
As Edwin stated, it really comes down to this simple statement.
| If people want to see more classics on HDM then more people have to be willing to support HDM by buying in. Then they have to show the studios that it is worth releasing classics on HD, by actually purchasing the ones that have been released to date. |
I try to avoid telling people how to spend their own money simply because it's none of my business. However, I will speak my mind to those classic film buffs who insist that they won't buy into HDM unless the studios start releasing such titles in significant numbers onto HDM. Even more than DVD, to release many of these classic films on HDM it's going to take a significant investment on the part of the studios due to QA issues and production costs. Therefore, the consumers in return need to do the same by making an investment by buying the hardware and the classic software currently available to them. Over the last ten years or so, I can't tell you how many SD DVD titles I bought that weren't among my favorite films, but I figure by doing so, it will help encourage the studios to keep releasing similar titles in the future, some of which might be among my favorite films.