Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

post #1 of 20
Thread Starter 


Blu-ray Disc/DVD REVIEW



ronsreviews_covers_84452.jpg

RIO BRAVO


Studio: Warner Brothers
Film Year: 1959
Film Length: 2 hours 21 minutes
Genre: Western

Aspect Ratio: 1.85:1

BD Resolution: 1080p
BD Video Codec: VC-1 @ under 20MBPS
Colour/B&W: Colour

Audio:
  • English Dolby Digital 1.0
  • French Dolby Digital 1.0

    Subtitles: English, French, Spanish
    Film Rating: Unrated







Release Date: June 5, 2007

Film Rating: /

Starring: John Wayne, Dean Martin, Ricky Nelson, Angie Dickinson, Walter Brennan and Ward Bond

Screenplay by: Jules Furthman and Leigh Brackett
Directed and Produced by: Howard Hawks




Rio Bravo is Howard Hawks’ famous answer to High Noon, a straight-ahead Western with the standard characters and a solid cast to play them. Hawks also responds to the onset of television programming here, by incorporating no less than 3 plots within the main narrative. One story follows Dean Martin as the fallen, drunken town deputy and his path to redemption. Another story follows a fanciful romance between John Wayne’s sheriff and a young Angie Dickinson. Both stories are played out within the main idea – the sheriff locks up a local hoodlum for murder and has to battle the hoodlum’s rich brother and an army of bad guys who want to free their man. It is interesting to see the film today as a period piece – it shows John Wayne settling into middle age and Howard Hawks reaffirming his stature as one of the top Hollywood directors of his day. The movie definitely takes its time along the way, and there aren’t too many suprises here, but this is a great way to experience solid Hollywood filmmaking circa 1959.

Rio Bravo was released in May of this year as a 2-Disc standard DVD special edition with the film on one disc and almost 2 hours of special features on the other. An “Ultimate Collector’s Edition” was also released at the same time, containing lobby cards, a press book and a comic book along with the discs. Warner Brothers has now released the film as a single-disc Blu-Ray, which contains all the features of the 2-disc standard release without the extra paper goods from the Ultimate edition. The difference for the Blu-Ray release, obviously, is the new 1080p VC-1 transfer, which is the best the film has ever looked for home video release.


VIDEO QUALITY: 4/5

Rio Bravo is presented in a very nice 1080p VC-1 transfer which brings out the rich colors of the film, from the costuming to a picturesque sunset. One area where the transfer really shines is the detailing of Angie Dickinson’s costumes: Her initial checkered outfit comes across as a solid image without the quivering that would happen in a 480p transfer. (Going back and forth on that costume alone between the 1080p feature and the 480p featurettes immediately makes this clear.)

The print itself is a bit dated and grainy. The cross-faded transitions particularly show a drop in print quality. However, these are simply issues of the print itself, which has clearly been restored – and the Hi-Definition transfer brings out the best qualities of the restoration. The grain in the print limits some of the detail, but the transfer still succeeds in many areas, especially the costume details.

AUDIO QUALITY: 3/5

Rio Bravo is presented in what sounds like the original mono mix in both English and French. Voices and music are mostly clear, although the source audio still has dropouts here and there. John Wayne’s arrest of Claude Akins has one such dropout that makes his first line hard to understand. This is not a fault of the audio quality of the disc – simply a problem of the track itself. Other than that, there isn’t much to speak of in this area.



SPECIAL FEATURES: 4/5

The Blu-Ray presentation of Rio Bravo includes all of the special features from the standard DVD edition, presented in standard definition.

  • Audio Commentary with Richard Schickel and John Carpenter – The feature commentary from the 2-disc edition has been included here. Essentially, we are presented with the views of a reliable historian on the one hand, and the film’s biggest fan on the other. The two men have not recorded this track together – instead, they have each watched the film separately, recording scene-specific comments that have now been spliced together. This isn’t a bad thing – the perspective on the film simply shifts back and forth, which provides a nice variety. Both men clearly have a lot of affection for this film, and it shows.

  • Commemoration: Howard Hawks’ Rio Bravo (33:24) (480p anamorphic) – This newly-created featurette (included from the 2-disc edition) is a loving look back at the film, using interviews with various directors, including John Carpenter, Peter Bogdanovich and Walter Hill along with film historians and the only surviving member of the cast, Angie Dickinson. Howard Hawks is present in audio clips from interviews conducted before his death in 1977. The central issues of the film and its production are addressed, including Hawks’ dislike for High Noon, and his inclusion of similar material to that of To Have and Have Not in this film for the romantic scenes. The only aspect that goes unaddressed is Hawks’ remakes of this film in the following years.

  • Old Tucson: Where the Legends Walked (8:35) (480p anamorphic) – This is another newly-created featurette also included on the 2-disc standard release. This time the focus is the Arizona backlot where the exteriors of Rio Bravo were filmed. There is a little information here on the various films that have been produced at the simulated Western town, but much of this plays as an extended commercial for both movie producers and tourists to come visit the site. (It’s more likely to attract the latter these days, given the various western towns and ranches available in the Los Angeles area within a short drive.)

  • The Men Who Made the Movies: Howard Hawks (55:03) (480p full-frame) – As on the standard definition 2-disc edition, the Blu-Ray disc includes this 1973 television documentary on the career of Howard Hawks. It is interesting to note that the documentary was put together by the same Richard Schickel who contributes to the commentary on this disc. The documentary primarily consists of 1973 interview footage with Hawks, intercut with clips from films directed by Hawks over the years. The last film discussed in the documentary is Rio Bravo, effectively stopping at the final peak of Hawks’ career. (The documentary refers to Hawks as involuntarily retired at this point, and Hawks died within a few years of participating.)

  • John Wayne Westerns Trailer Gallery (9:59 total) (480p full-frame) – As on the standard definition 2-disc, a series of 5 movie trailers for John Wayne westerns are included here. Four of them are for films from 1932 and 1933, featuring a shockingly young Wayne riding his white horse Duke! The fifth one is for Rio Bravo and shows a lot less color and detail than the 1080p transfer seen on the feature presentation.

    Subtitles are available in English, French and Spanish for the film itself, but not for the special features. The usual Blu-Ray pop-up menu is accessible during the film, this time in the form of a western-themed wooden horse hitch.


    IN THE END...

    Rio Bravo is an old-fashioned Western that wears its heart and its values on its sleeve. For John Wayne or Howard Hawks fans (or both), getting this film is a no-brainer. For film buffs who don’t know the film, this is a good way to experience it and then learn about it from the same disc. Yes, it’s a bit slow and there aren’t a lot of twists or turns here, but there is an undeniable amount of heart on display, not to mention a pretty good story. Given the superior 1080p transfer and the presence of all the disc extras from the 2-disc standard release from a month ago, it’s a very attractive Blu-Ray indeed.

    Kevin Koster
    June 18, 2007.

post #2 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

One of my favorite films that I'm so happy to have on BRD. Though, I had little problem with the video presentation, some will disagree because of the lack of grain and the film coloring being too brownish. I was too young to remember how this film looked in a theater, but I had no issue with either of those criticisms. My only complaint as far as this release is some gross errors in the film commentary by Richard Schickel.




Crawdaddy
post #3 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Crawford
One of my favorite films that I'm so happy to have on BRD. Though, I had little problem with the video presentation, some will disagree because of the lack of grain and the film coloring being too brownish. I was too young to remember how this film looked in a theater, but I had no issue with either of those criticisms. My only complaint as far as this release is some gross errors in the film commentary by Richard Schickel.




Crawdaddy


Robert,

This has been one of my favorite films since I first saw it on HBO in the late 70s. However I must admit that I don't know much about the behind the scenes stuff. Specifically what errors does Schickel make in the commentary?

Doug
post #4 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

I am not sure if the slightly brown tint to the film is accurate, and to be honest, I do not really care. The film is an excellent release. It looks and feels fresh while still maintaining the feel of a Western made in that time period. How can one ask for more?
post #5 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin EK
John Wayne’s arrest of Claude Akins has one such dropout that makes his first line hard to understand. This is not a fault of the audio quality of the disc – simply a problem of the track itself. Other than that, there isn’t much to speak of in this area.



I believe this "drop out" is the result of removing a word (possibly a mistake by Wayne) from the line of dialog in the original editing of the movie. It's been in every version of this movie I've ever seen. The point being its not so much a drop out as an intended edit by the filmmakers.

Doug
post #6 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Except for high levels of grain in a couple of scenes, I found the picture quality stunning, very dimensional. Yes, I guess the flesh tones are too brownish for some but not for me.

Thanks for the review.
post #7 of 20
Thread Starter 

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

I honestly didn't find the flesh tones to be too brownish. I agree that Dean Martin's coloring is a little darker for much of the movie, but I figured that was an intended part of his character's drunken situation.

I too am curious about errors made by Richard Schickel in the commentary. I got the impression that he has a pretty good handle on Hawks and his films, particularly given that he put together the Hawks' retrospective on the same disc. But anybody can make a mistake...

As for the drop-out in Wayne's dialogue, I agree that this may have been done to deal with an on-set issue (such as a flubbed line or something else like that). But it's so obvious that it's hard to think that there wasn't another solution - it's really jarring. This is only a single moment, of course - and one moment doesn't spoil the whole track.
post #8 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin EK

As for the drop-out in Wayne's dialogue, I agree that this may have been done to deal with an on-set issue (such as a flubbed line or something else like that). But it's so obvious that it's hard to think that there wasn't another solution - it's really jarring. This is only a single moment, of course - and one moment doesn't spoil the whole track.

This kind of edit was not all that uncommon at the time this film was made. At the time it was thought that most people would only see a film once and things like that kind of edit would not be noticed. Also people have been conditioned to see and hear much faster now than in 1958. You could get away with a lot more then.

Doug
post #9 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin EK
I honestly didn't find the flesh tones to be too brownish. I agree that Dean Martin's coloring is a little darker for much of the movie, but I figured that was an intended part of his character's drunken situation.

I too am curious about errors made by Richard Schickel in the commentary. I got the impression that he has a pretty good handle on Hawks and his films, particularly given that he put together the Hawks' retrospective on the same disc. But anybody can make a mistake...

As for the drop-out in Wayne's dialogue, I agree that this may have been done to deal with an on-set issue (such as a flubbed line or something else like that). But it's so obvious that it's hard to think that there wasn't another solution - it's really jarring. This is only a single moment, of course - and one moment doesn't spoil the whole track.
Right off the top of my head, he referred to Bond's television series as "Wagon Master", which was actually a 1950 film directed by John Ford that Bond was in, but his TV series was called "Wagon Train". Also, the film "3:10 to Yuma" he mistakenly stated that Glenn Ford played the character that was transporting the outlaw to prison when in fact, Ford actually played the outlaw while Van Heflin played the other character transporting the outlaw. By the way, this great film has been remade with a October release starring Russell Crowe in Ford's part and Christian Bale in Heflin's part.




Crawdaddy
post #10 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
By the way, this great film has been remade with a October release starring Russell Crowe in Ford's part and Christian Bale in Heflin's part.
That will be very interesting - even if 80% (or so) of the remakes aren't really satisfactory.
At least the choice of those two actors is very promising.


Cees
post #11 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cees Alons
That will be very interesting - even if 80% (or so) of the remakes aren't really satisfactory.
At least the choice of those two actors is very promising.


Cees
The original actors talked about for this remake were Tom Cruise and Eric Bana. I would assume that Cruise would play Ben Wade with Bana playing the Heflin part. I might be in the minority on this, but that casting would've worked well too.
post #12 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
Originally Posted by Robert Crawford
Right off the top of my head, he referred to Bond's television series as "Wagon Master", which was actually a 1950 film directed by John Ford that Bond was in, but his TV series was called "Wagon Train". Also, the film "3:10 to Yuma" he mistakenly stated that Glenn Ford played the character that was transporting the outlaw to prison when in fact, Ford actually played the outlaw while Van Heflin played the other character transporting the outlaw. By the way, this great film has been remade with a October release starring Russell Crowe in Ford's part and Christian Bale in Heflin's part.




Crawdaddy


Okay I got ya. As far as you know how were his facts on the actual subject at hand Rio Bravo?

Doug
post #13 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Quote:
I would assume that Cruise would play Ben Wade with Bana playing the Heflin part. I might be in the minority on this, but that casting would've worked well too.
True. Although I must admit I'm a bit biased against Cruise (do not remember any bad performance though).


Cees
post #14 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

Finally watched this last night, Skin tone colors seemed off, oversaturated -way too brown, made everyone look like they just returned from a vacation in the tropics. I did get used to it after a while. PQ overall was pretty good.

I can't imagine this was how it was originally intended but I don't have a half century old memory to base my opinion on so what do I know. I can barely remember what I had for dinner last night.

On a side note - I'd love to see my favorite Hawks/Wayne collaboration Red River in HD someday but I'm not going to hold my breath.
post #15 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

I was gonna describe the fleshtones as a bit orange but everybody else is calling 'em brown. They're close on the colour palate. I always liked this film and I'm thrilled to own it finally.
post #16 of 20

Re: HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended

thanks for the review! I'll be picking this one up ASAP!
post #17 of 20

The DVD Talk thread on oop titles has this title going oop along with some other dvd editions of the film.  Does anyone know what is going on with it?  Is Warners going to release a new verion?  Is this a title that Warner licensed (as they once did with Stagecoach) and the license is now expired?

post #18 of 20


Quote:
Originally Posted by JoeDoakes View Post

The DVD Talk thread on oop titles has this title going oop along with some other dvd editions of the film.  Does anyone know what is going on with it?  Is Warners going to release a new verion?  Is this a title that Warner licensed (as they once did with Stagecoach) and the license is now expired?



This has always been a Warner title, no matter the video format, so unlike Stagecoach, I expect it to remain a Warner title.

post #19 of 20
Might there be a new version coming out to cause the current to oop?
post #20 of 20

I fully expect, at some point, Warner to go through older titles with lossy sound and give them lossless audio; hopefully this is one (and they can tickle the transfer while they are at it...)

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Blu-ray
Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › Blu-ray › HTF BLU-RAY REVIEW: Rio Bravo - Recommended