New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HTF REVIEW: The Fountain - Page 3

post #61 of 70
5/24/07 at 8:05am

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Quote:
Originally Posted by Felix Martinez
Great movie; another of WB's recent shoddy compression jobs.

I've read this a few times; I noticed some compression artifacts in some of the darker scenes and it prompted me to revisit the calibration of the projector, which, it turns out, was running a little iight. With my blacks back down where they're supposed to be, those artifacts vanished on my hundred inch screen.

Are we just seeing some imperfect reviewer calibration, or is it genuinely badly compressed?
Reply

Gear mentioned in this thread:

The Fountain (Widescreen Edition)
post #62 of 70
5/24/07 at 9:17am
Thread Starter 

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

My opinion, expanding on my comments from the review, is that the scenes that exhibited compression artifacts were the scenes that were, ... well, ... difficult to compress. It is not a pervasive issue on this DVD presentation, which, as a whole, does not suffer from the wire to wire softness exhibited on, for instance, the "Superman Returns" DVD.

Regards,
Reply
post #63 of 70
5/24/07 at 11:02am

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aaron Reynolds
I've read this a few times; I noticed some compression artifacts in some of the darker scenes and it prompted me to revisit the calibration of the projector, which, it turns out, was running a little iight. With my blacks back down where they're supposed to be, those artifacts vanished on my hundred inch screen.

Are we just seeing some imperfect reviewer calibration, or is it genuinely badly compressed?
I author DVDs. Believe me. Baaaaad. Not unwatchable - static shots and close-ups look real nice, but pretty bad IMHO, especially for a 2007 release of a 90-odd minute film. Something has gone south, compression-wise with WB's new DVD releases over the past year or so. Doesn't seem to have affected their catalog titles ("The Other" comes to mind).

Ken has mentioned before that perhaps it is affecting those releases that use DIs (digital intermediate process), which may explain the compression anomalies on new titles. But other studios are doing bang-up jobs on their new titles and DIs are not relegated to WB features. Honestly, something is wrong. Either they're recompressing a compressed master, or they've set the bitrate too low...all speculation, but I haven't had time to demux these things and see what in the world could be going on. But I've been incredibly disappointed with WB's new DVD release output for some time now.

I think Blood Diamond was another affected title; haven't seen that one, tho.

Was hoping this title would snap back to their previous high benchmark of quality, but alas, not the case.
Reply
post #64 of 70
5/24/07 at 2:25pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

I finally got around to watching this last night, and I've got to say that I'm still thinking about it today at work. The first 20 minutes had me very confused, but I stuck with it, and I was simply floored by my emotional response by the end of the movie.

What a fantastic combination of visuals, sounds, and thoughts on film! I think I'm going to watch it again this weekend just so I can enjoy the beginning more.

edit: And I've already ordered the score from Amazon...what a masterpiece!
Reply
post #65 of 70
5/24/07 at 2:56pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Ken, thanks for the review. I love this film.
Reply
post #66 of 70
5/24/07 at 3:47pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Quote:
Perfectly cast, there's no way I could even imagine Brad Pitt being in this movie after seeing the job Hugh Jackman did.

I agree. I simply can't picture Pitt

Warning: Spoiler! (Click to show)

performing the "ring tatoo" scene as well as Jackman
Reply
post #67 of 70
5/25/07 at 7:57pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Neither can I, Richard. I noticed no compression issues, but I haven't watched it yet on my 16:9 Toshiba. I'll let you know if they show up on that display when I get a chance... which will be sometime in July.
Reply
post #68 of 70
5/25/07 at 8:45pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Quote:
Originally Posted by Seth Paxton
I immediately equated Soderbergh's tighter, quicker abstract love-story version of Solaris with DA's Fountain. I'm sure there are people that hated one but loved the other, but I wouldn't be able to understand why. To me both are wonderful - subdued tones applied to amazing flights of fancy.

The casual audiences sees those imaginations and effects and goes into "rock my world SF experience" mode and of course neither film is headed that way, so they turn on it for being "weird" despite pretty obvious plotlines (IMO). It might be fantastical or allegorical, but the connections are rather spelled out in both cases.

I went into The Fountain in the theater with very high expectation as I loved both Pi and Requiem for a Dream; this movie far and away exceeded my expectations and confirmed my belief that Arronofsky is a director with a singular and unique vision. I truly hope he continues to make films a interesting as he has up to now.

I also loved Soderbergh's Solaris (can't believe I decided not to see it in the theater) and could not stand the Tarkovsky version (I know it's blasphemy but it bored me to tears). I would definitely agree that these two movies would flow together very well as companion pieces.

Great cinema and I truly hope this movie finds the audience on dvd it could not garner in its theatrical run.

Michael
Reply
post #69 of 70
5/29/07 at 11:51am

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Rented this with an open mind and heart. I stood by the film until the God awful Zen Buddhist ending with a flying Hugh Jackman that killed the entire movie for me. Brad Pitt saved Warner some serious money by backing out of this ________ I can’t even think of a word best to describe how I feel about this movie.
Reply
post #70 of 70
6/5/07 at 9:48pm

Re: HTF REVIEW: The Fountain

Quote:
Originally Posted by JohnRice
A lot of critics need to hang their heads on the lambasting of this one. Richard Roper's shrugging off of it, saying "It's a complete mess" is particularly sad.

Sorry - I agree with Roeper, it's a complete mess.

I don't need to be beat over the head in a movie to understand it, but this film to me didn't have one drop of glue in it anywhere to hold anything together.

I really don't like waisting the first 20 to 30 minutes of a film saying to myself "What the hell is going on". Only to find at the end I'm saying to myself "What the hell just happened".

Really sorry for this blind buy.
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF DVD Reviews

Gear mentioned in this thread:

The Fountain (Widescreen Edition)