Re: The best of the best: The SP-FX houses
Thoughts on the nominees:
Outstanding Visual Effects in a Visual Effects Driven Picture:
I Am Legend
Transformers
The Golden Compass
Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End
Spider Man 3
I prefer Pirates, but it'll be seen as something already done. TF is new. It'll win.
Outstanding Supporting Visual Effects in a Motion Picture:
Ratatouille
Zodiac
Kite Runner
We Own the Night
Blades of Glory
Only saw two of these, but Zodiac has exceptional effects...the very definition of this award.
Best Single Visual Effect of the Year
Transfromers - Desert Highway Sequence
Pirates of the Caribbean - Jack and Davy Duel
300 - Crazy Horse sequence
Surf's Up - Riding the Visual Effects Tube
Spiderman 3 - Birth of Sandman
The Crazy Horse effect is one of my very favorites...I love watching it (although it uses a lot of camera trickery as well to work). But the birth of Sandman sequence is also brilliant.
Outstanding Animated Character in a Live Action Motion Picture:
Spiderman3 - Sandman
Waterhorse - Carusoe
Pirates of the Caribbean - Davy Jones
Enchanted - Pip
Transformers - Optimus Prime
I Am Legend - Infected Leader
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!
Seriously. Davy Jones should walk with this.
Outstanding Animated Character in an animated feature:
Surf's Up - Chicken Joe
Shrek 3 - King Harold
Beowulf - Beowulf
Surf's Up - Cody
Ratatouille - Collette
Overall, Pixar's animation efforts in Ratatouille obliterate the competition. But I thought Beowulf was fantastic. Many of the rest of the characters in the film, not so much. Beowulf himself was amazing, though.
Outstanding effects in an animated motion picture
Beowulf
Shrek the Third
Ratatouille - food
Surf's Up
Ratatouille - rapids
The rapids were more visceral and immediate, but I was amazed by the food. A much bigger accomplishment, imo.
Outstanding Created environment in a motion picture:
Sweeney Todd - the old bailey
Pirates of the Caribbean - The Maelstrom
Zodiac - Washington and Cherry
Harry Potter - Hall of Prophecy
Rush Hour 3
I Am Legend - Times Square Hunt
Only saw four of those. I did love the Times Square stuff.
Outstanding models or miniatures in a motion picture:
Pirates of the Caribbean - practical and digital ships
Live Free Or Die Hard - freeway sequence
Transformers
Harry Potter -Hogwarts
Spiderman3 - building crane destruction
Got to go with Hogwarts or the Pirate Ships...but that's my love of the design more than the execution

I thought it was a good year for VFX. Some very strong efforts, and a greater tie between the technical and artistic sides of the craft (especially in Pirates). I am depressed that Sunshine wasn't anywhere on the list. I would have picked it for a few things. Nice to see Zodiac on the list.