Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › TV on DVD and Blu-ray › Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134) - Page 5

post #121 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

This is like "Who's On First?" with both T & J sets needing to be replaced.

I'm puzzled about T & J Set 2. Are those uncensored replacement discs arriving OK? Or is Warner's fulfillment center sending out bogus discs for Set 2 too?

"Set 1 only needs #1 fixed, but #2 arrives too."

"Set 2 needs #1 and #2 too, so you get #1 and #2 too."

"I don't know!" ... "Third Base!"
post #122 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

I got the volume 2 discs finally, here in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada,

Just thought I'd mention it in case other canucks have been waiting on these for ever.
post #123 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Russ...

When you get a chance to audition your new Volume 2 discs, let us know if they're indeed the uncensored 'toons. Thanks!

Stay warm.
post #124 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jeff Krispow
Hi Everyone,


Further, if you've already received the incorrect replacement discs, hold onto them for now -- there is no need to return them just yet. It's probable that you will need to return these with your original Disc 1 as soon as the fulfillment facility receives and ships you the correct uncensored disc.…



Regards,

I sent my old discs back and kept the new ones. I hope this does not cause trouble in the future exchange.
post #125 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

The Volume Two replacement discs are fine. It's just the Volume One replacement that is not correct.
post #126 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

I can check my vol 2, what am I looking for?
post #127 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Thanks for those details Jeff.
b
post #128 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by Russell G
I can check my vol 2, what am I looking for?
Russ...the details are in Message #62. Thanks for checking!
post #129 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

I received my Volume 1 replacement today. The first thing that I noticed that was odd was that they sent me both disc one and disc two even though the only disc with censored cartoons was disc one. The second, more important thing that struck me as odd was that the discs are exactly the same as the ones I already have. No censored scenes have been restored. The file dates on the video files are still from August of 2004. Very frustrating.

Regards,
post #130 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by Michael Rogers
I sent my old discs back and kept the new ones. I hope this does not cause trouble in the future exchange.

I did, too, before I realized that the new discs were entirely the same as the old discs. I hope that they know this, and will automatically send out the right replacement discs without a phone call from me prompting them to do so. After all, they know that what they did send out was bad, so it would show to reason that they would have to resend to all the same people they sent to initially. Automatically.
post #131 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Quote:
Originally Posted by buttmunker
I did, too, before I realized that the new discs were entirely the same as the old discs. I hope that they know this, and will automatically send out the right replacement discs without a phone call from me prompting them to do so. After all, they know that what they did send out was bad, so it would show to reason that they would have to resend to all the same people they sent to initially. Automatically.
They are still trying to figure out what went wrong on their end, so I would not assume anything. When in doubt, call.

Regards,
post #132 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

I called them Friday to report the same problem. I figured I would get a "yeah, we're aware of that" response, but the person who answered the phone didn't seem to have come across the issue before. She had to put me on hold, then informed me that her boss would have to speak with HER boss and they would give me a call.

FWIW, it didn't sound like English was the lady's first language. Nor the last time I called, when I asked for the replacement in the first place. There were two misspellings in my name and address on the label.
post #133 of 190

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program

Hello,...in reguards to Tom and Jerry Vol 1,
Looks like, according to THE DIG. BITS, that we are to give another call if we received the defective replacements, as replacements. i hope i read that right!!
Anyways, i just did so and the lady that answered, seemed to know (to some extent) what has happened, but somewhat confused as well.

i left my name and address (actually...i was in their computer) and was told to return the disc when i received another envelope. i wonder which disc(s) i am to return? ...and what i am to do with the other prepaid envelope. Hope there are clear instructions that in "fine" in the next envelope.
post #134 of 190
Thread Starter 

Re: Important Announcement: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program


January 30, 2007 -- Updated Notice regarding Tom & Jerry Spotlight Collection: Volume 1, Disc 1 (Version 2)

Previously, Warner Home Video had advised consumers who purchased Tom and Jerry Spotlight Collection: Volume 1 DVD that certain episodes on Disc 1 had an alternate picture/audio track. Warner Home Video offered to replace Disc 1 with a disc that had the original picture/audio track, which some consumers requested. Those consumers were inadvertently sent an incorrect replacement disc.

Consumers who recently received the incorrect replacement disc, and any other consumers who still wish to have Disc 1 replaced with the original picture/audio track, should contact Warner Home Video at 1-800-553-6937 so that a self-addressed stamped envelope can be sent to you for return of your current disc. Please note that the replacement disc will be sent to you in approximately 4-6 weeks.
post #135 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I just called 2/1 and was told corrected versions for people who received incorrect versions were shipped 1/31. They did not take my name again, I was in the system, so I'm waiting now to see if corrected discs arrive. Next to no time at all on hold.
post #136 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Someone on the DVDTalk forum reported getting their replacement today.
post #137 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

got my 2nd replacement today, too. couldn't review it, as I'm at work and will have to wait until I get home.
post #138 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I received my new replacement disc today. It does appear to be different to the previous one sent. I checked the video files and the creation date was December 30, 2006. Also they have a new warning about the racial content in the beginning. Haven't had a chance to check the cartoons to verify the original content is restored. At least it looks like Warner got it right this time.
post #139 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Did you guys make a second call or are they just sending the corrected discs out to the same people?
post #140 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

They appear to be automatically sending them without calling.
post #141 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I'm in shock. After almost 5 months and numerous calls to the hotline (the last one just 24hrs ago, funnily enough) I just received a call from my San Diego based friend to let me know that the Tom & Jerry Vol. 2 replacements have arrived!

Now I just hope the Vol. 1 discs don't take that long (I know from my hotline call yesterday that they haven't been shipped yet).

One caveat, though: The package contains the standard letter saying to send the discs back in the pre-paid envelope. The envelope, however, is not pre-paid, so I have to pay for it!
post #142 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I received my Volume One disc today. "The Milky Waif", "The Truce Hurts", and "The Little Orphan" are indeed uncut. Unfortunately, they are also absolutely riddled with aliasing which the censored versions were not. It seems crazy that they would initiate a replacement program for Tom & Jerry Volume One that introduces the mastering defect for which they have announced that they will initiate a replacement program for one of the Looney Tunes Golden Collections, but there you have it.

Note - only the three previously censored shorts have this problem. The rest of shorts on the disc have no aliasing artifacts.


Regards,
525x525px-LL-vbattach96.jpg
post #143 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Absolutely ridiculous.
post #144 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I got mine today but haven't had a chance to watch it yet.
post #145 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

To be fair, the aliasing issue will be a function of how your own DVD player de-interlaces the signal. I have some that seem to be able to handle it and others that give you the result sampled above. This makes it less of a concern than it was for certain cartoons on the fourth disc of "The Looney Tunes Golden Collection Volume Two" which had aliasing artifacts visible on just about any player on which I had the ability to review them.

Regards,
post #146 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I took a look at The Milky Waif and The Little Orphan and I don't think I would have noticed the aliasing unless I had known to look for it. However, it was more noticable (but not THAT bad) on The Truce Hurts.
post #147 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Hi folks,

I'm sorry that I've been out of touch here for the past week -- after reading a few things here a little while earlier, I wish I could have been here to comment -- but unfortunately my laptop was damaged and out for repair, plus we were having our house repiped.

(The Tragic Tale: One of our cats somehow managed to send the laptop flying like a frisbee, landing several feet away from it's normal resting spot where it smacked into our hardwood floor... precisely on that little power connecter which plugs into the laptop. The connector end was twisted beyond all recognition, as was the interior of the DC plug inside the laptop. Oh, and the center "plug part" broke off and went through the back of the laptop plug and into the DC board, which apparently is what shorted it out. Apple wanted $810 to repair a $50 part… for those of you with Mac, be aware that this is their new 2007 "flat fee" repair rate for any phyiscal damage, be it a broken key on the keyboard, or a damaged LCD which averages $1000+. Thankfully, Apple provided us with a little sheet of paper with three local authorized repair center that could repair my laptop for far less... actual part cost + minimal labor charge. *Whew*).

First off, as you all obviously already know, the corrected uncensored Tom and Jerry: Spotlight Collection Vol. 1 replacement Disc 1 is available and shipping. I really wanted to pass on this good news last week, but obviously was unable to. The remastered discs were received at the fulfillment house on (or just before) January 29, and they began shipping out on January 31.

The first shipments are being sent out to those people who had received that initial incorrect two-disc replacement set -- i.e., you are automatically being "reserviced with the correct uncensored disc" as my contact promised, without the need for calling in.

My replacement disc was shipped out automatically on January 31 as well, and I received it the very next day, February 1. Several other friends also received their replacements on Feb. 2 or 3, as did several folks here.

I also really wanted to let you know that the newly-shipping disc was 100% fixed, corrected, uncensored, and uncut. The previously-censored footage has been reinstated to both The Milky Way and The Truce Hurts, and The Little Orphan is now featured in its original version (rather than a censorship cut, the offending material was instead re-animated). And as BrianP already stated, the remastered edition contains a new "forced" pre-show notice regarding the racial content on the disc.

I normally hate to say things like "I told you so," but in this case I'll make a rare exception for those disbelivers out there. I'm not sure how much clearer I could have stated it, but I told you that the problem would be rectified as soon as is possible, that there was NO need to call in, and that EVERYONE would be reserviced with the correct uncensored disc as soon as it was available. These were the facts -- not assumptions -- as provided to me by someone directly in charge of resolving this issue. (Although I did have some additional information which I was asked to keep private, I was allowed to pass on some very specific information regarding this replacement-of-the-replacements program.)

* * *

Which in turn brings me to that rather strange Warner "Press Release" that circulated around to several websites and forums, including this one. I'm not sure who wrote this Press Release, or which Warner department circulated it, but the specific information regarding the replacement/exchange process is completely incorrect. The replacement/exchange process had already been determined a week prior to the writing of this "PR" -- automatic reservicing of ALL consumers, NO need to call in, NO need to return discs prior to reservicing. Further, the fulfillment house already had the discs in-stock, packaged with an explanatory letter, and ready to ship out -- THE SAME DAY this "PR" was written and circulated, which "suggested" that the discs wouldn't even be available for at least a month.

Again, I don't know who wrote that "PR," but it's recommended that you ignore the exchange process that's listed (which is completely opposite the actual process). If you did receive the initial incorrect two-disc replacement, you should automatically receive the proper uncensored Disc 1 shortly. However, if you DON'T receive your uncensored disc within a reasonable amount of time (say… by the end of the month), only then should you give them a call so they can resend it.

* * *

Personally, I find the entire progression of this Tom and Jerry: Spotlight Collection Vol. 1 Replacement Program rather interesting, "from a certain point of view" that is.

I find it interesting that Warner sends out an inaccurate PR regarding the replacement-of-the-incorrect-replacement disc... yet they never bothered to announce the initial Tom and Jerry: Spotlight Collection Vol. 1 Replacement Program, which officially began January 2.

I also find it interesting that I am the only one who announced the Replacement Program even existed. Frankly, it was purely by chance that, during a completely unrelated conversion, I asked the right person the right question -- "Are we ever going to see this remastered?" -- only to be told "Call the regular replacement line on Monday…" (and I thought he was just joking around with me). Needless to say, I was overjoyed at the news, and pleased that I was allowed to spread the word here on the HTF (and elsewhere) that this Replacement Program did indeed exist!

And lastly, I also find it interesting that when there is an unfortunately supply error with an incorrect disc, some people will completely ignore and/or disbelieve the specific 100% correct "insider" information on how the replacements will be handled. (Not so much here on the forum, but I got several really… ummm… peculiar emails.)

It's a weird world, folks!

* * *

But in the end, all I can really say is that I'm just very, very pleased to see this long 26-month journey come to a close, as we all finally have our two uncensored volumes of Tom and Jerry shorts.

This will happily suffice until such a time that George Feltenstein is able to finally gain control over all the classic cartoons… and can release a complete uncut set of T&J shorts, newly transferred and fully restored.

.
..
...

Oh, and before I forget, there were some people wondering (again, a couple people here, but several more emails I received) if there were any problems with the Tom and Jerry: Volume 2 replacement program -- i.e., was the fulfillment house sending out the "wrong discs" or somesuch. The answer is… there are NO problems with the Tom and Jerry: Volume 2 replacement discs. The fulfillment house only has the properly remastered discs featuring the reinstated original audio tracks.

And with that, I'll be off. I wish everyone a slightly-late Happy Groundhog Day, and hope that you are enjoying (or soon will enjoy) Tom and Jerry in all their uncensored glory!

Regards to all…
post #148 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Got all 3 discs (vol. 1 and 2) today and all is okay.
post #149 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

Does anyone know how to tell the new version from the old version when picking it up today? Is there a way to tell on the cover? As I live in Europe, I wouldn't like to go through the whole replacement programme with Warner.

/Mikkel
post #150 of 190

Re: Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)

I would guess that if the new versions of the discs are just being sent out that it'll take quite awhile before they are available on store shelves or to online retailers. The retailers will also probably go through their existing inventory before they get the corrected ones in stock too.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: TV on DVD and Blu-ray
Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Blu-ray, DVD, Streaming Video and Digital Downloads › TV on DVD and Blu-ray › Warner Home Video Tom & Jerry Replacement Program (UPDATE 1/30/07 POST #134)