New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Capote Review - Page 2

post #31 of 40
Regarding dirt on the Capote release disc, the information is as follows:

Because of a lower bit rate, which makes certain pieces of dirt and detritus less obvious, an early screener had 25 bits of positive dirt and 30 bits of negative, plus a processing stain at 2:43. This dirt was noted between the first shot following the titles at 1:13 to the final exterior shot at 3;00.

The final production disc, which is missing the processing stain, has 33 positive bits of dirt and 34 negative, within the same one minute forty-seven second period. That's a total of 67 bits of dirt in a short period of time.

Unacceptable for a studio release of what I recall to be a newer title. Capote should not be in need of restoration or repair quite yet.

The message here is that no one at Sony Home Video seems to care about the quality of their final discs, and that someone with an eye for quality should be hired to do QC.

Just a friendly suggestion.

RAH
post #32 of 40
Quote:
Hoffman is not pulling a Rich Little here. He delivers a truly amazing portrayal of the real life enigma that was Truman Capote.
I agree. There was a thread on this subject of acting vs. impersonation a little while back. Someone made a very good point that acting the role requires showing that person in various states of emotion, not just what we know that person is identified by (e.g. voice and walk). Truman Capote himself was an "acting stunt," an over the top personality to begin with, so I think it's being unfair to dismiss Hoffman's portrayal as mere mimicry.
post #33 of 40
Thread Starter 
Quote:
The entire look of the film, with its somber muted yellow and brown tones and dark look is most likely entirely intentional.


Sorry the review isn't posted yet -- I will try to finish it tonight. But in the meantime, FYI, the filmmakers state very clearly in the making-of docs that the colors and design of the film are 100% intentional. They tried to avoid using any blues or reds whatsoever.

Dirt and scratches are present on the print they used for the DVD, but only a small amount (which is still too much for a brand-new film).
post #34 of 40
The dirt and scratches may be minimal, but VERY
noticeable.

It was enough for me to wonder why they used a
print in this condition.
post #35 of 40
Ron,

I doubt very much that it would have been an actual print. It should have been an interpositive. But regardless, the amount of both negative dirt and positive detritus is unacceptable for anything approaching a film of recent vintage.

Compare Capote with Fox's new release of the Brooks films, which range in vintage from 1974 to 1993 and the difference in care is obvious. Fox, like the other studios is handling their releases professionally and doing their QC homework.

RAH
post #36 of 40
Well this has firmly swayed me into the no-buy category. My theatrical viewing will suffice for now.
post #37 of 40
As Capote is a fine film, and a prime candidate for Blu-ray, waiting would be a good thing.

The defects seen herein would be so ridiculously obvious on Blu-ray that one would think that Sony would have to fix them.

But one would think the same for standard def, which means that the statement above means nothing.

RAH
post #38 of 40
I don't under why Sony can be so sloppy. In comparison, their Sony/Legacy releases on CD are often great!
post #39 of 40
As others have said, the dirt is obvious during the outdoor shots but I've also noticed it during the completely black parts. For instance, after the lost shot of the film and it has faded to black I could see specks. Very distracting and annoying.

I'm glad I rented this DVD instead of buying it. Hopefully Sony will fix this for the blu-ray release.
post #40 of 40

Re: Capote Review

We finally saw this last nite. Great flick but awfully mediocre DVD transfer. Dirt, white specks everywhere and some of the WORST EE I've seen on a major title in years. Forcefield bad, Gangs of NY bad!
Disappointing.... Definitely worth a rental to see the flick but I would not pay a dime to own this shoddy release. Bad job...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Official HTF DVD Reviews