Thanks for the great review, Herb!
I picked this up today along with a couple of other gems, but this was the first one I popped in as I LOVED this film in theaters.
Herb's judgment of the picture and sound quality are on target. Both are outstanding.
The only complaint I have is with the extras on disc 2. Not with the presentation -- you can simply go to the last page and get a menu which lets you select everything, and also I kind of like picking my way through the comic presentation and seeing what I can discover. What I want to know is WHY, oh WHY, were the featurettes presented in NON-ANAMORPHIC widescreen? If you're going to bother with showing the film segments 2.35 letterboxed, and the interview and behind-the-scenes stuff 1.85 letterboxed, then why not go the extra step and make it proper anamorphic so we don't all have to fiddle with our TV's settings?
Also, the datafile-type extras (like on Batman's weapons and equipment, allies, enemies and such) all seem like they were done in anamorphic WS (the proportions of the characters and items and whatnot all look correct to me). So why not the featurettes too? Rrrrgh, it's annoying.
Regardless, a GREAT damned film and a GREAT damned presentation. Outstanding. I'll be watching this one many more times.
cheers,
Phil