Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Home Theater › Members' Theaters, HT Projects, Remotes, Seating, Accessories & Lighting › Lutron Spacer Installation 101 (Rev. 1/17/06 - Adding IR Emitters)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Lutron Spacer Installation 101 (Rev. 1/17/06 - Adding IR Emitters) - Page 3

post #61 of 97
Thread Starter 
About 12 feet.
post #62 of 97
Has anyone compared the Lutron Spacer System line versus Leviton's Decora Home control line? http://www.leviton.com/sections/prod...d/npleadin.htm

It looks like it uses the existing A/C wireing for communication (similar to if not actually X10). This would solve some of the wiring of I/R emitter issues for retrofit installations vs. the Lutron system.

In my small HT, I'm just looking to control...
1. Cieling fan
2. Cieling fan light
3. two wall sconces (wired to same switch)
4. Rope lighting.

Any advice as to which way to go?

-Erich

NOTE: URL edited by Administrator
post #63 of 97
A big thumbs up for Hank's Electric as a supplier for Spacer System components. I couldn't beat their prices anywhere, and my order was drop shipped straight from Lutron with free freight.
post #64 of 97
I'm planning to install the Lutron Spacer System in my HT. I have a pretty basic setup-- I'll just need two 600W dimmers. I'm wondering if anyone out there would be willing to loan or rent their remote to me so that I can load the commands onto my Sony Remote Commander. I'm trying to avoid buying a $65 remote that I'll never have to use again once I get the commands onto my universal remote.
post #65 of 97
Thanks Jay for the extremely informative summary, well done! Could anyone please answer a question for me ?
We had our house built with Cat5 run to all major gang switches and thermostats, for (hopefully) some type of home automation in the future. I now have an IR repeater system (Niles) in my home theater cabinet, and am using a IR receiver (Niles) and pronto remote to control my a/v equipment. I'm just wondering if there is any way I can utilize this same repeater system and the already installed Cat5 to control Lutron Spacer System dimmers ? I'm hoping the Cat5 runs weren't a waste of money, that was the only wiring I thought I would need (at the time).
post #66 of 97
Some Spacers have a clear back. You could try to run IR from the Niles block to the back of the Spacer to control it. That could work for a room. If you are wanting to do whole home lighting there are other options as well. Control4 and Creston are both releasing light switches that use wireless for control, and OnQ and HAI are using lightswitches that use a digital version of X10 for control that is a lot more reliable than X10. Lutron has Radio RA.
post #67 of 97
Good timing on the question for me! I just bought some Buffalo IR repeater flashers, receivers & repeaters, I have everything hooked up except for my Spacer System Dimmers. I just installed the Spacers - I have 2 side by side in a double ganged box. I haven't played with them much, I'm about to do so. As I understand it, the Spacer System remote controls 4 zones combined for the 2 dimmers. This is fine, I can come up with 4 settings for my 2 zones that will achieve what I'm looking for. So if my understanding is correct, the 1 remote will control both units. Would I use 1 or 2 flashers to control these 2 units - 1 signal (if I understand correctly) would control both. If 1 flasher, where would I mount it to control both dimmers?

Thanks,
B
post #68 of 97
If you have the spacers with the clear back an IR sensor placed on the side of one on the end should go through up to 3 that are side by side.
post #69 of 97
Thanks Adam!
post #70 of 97
I installed a Lutron Maestro remote dimmer switch, which works great, except for one problem (which several of you have mentioned): the IR receiving eye has a very limited reception angle/range. The problem is that the switch is at the top of the stairs and my home theater is at the bottom. I have to get just the right angle to get it to work.

I'm interested in an IR repeater system (like have been mentioned here), but this is the only device I need it for, so I'd rather not spend $100+ dollars to control only one device.

Does anyone know of an inexpensive one-input, one output receiver/emitter combo that would work for this? WIth the way everything is laid out, running a cable/wire between the two is not a problem at all.

Thanks!
post #71 of 97
Jeffery,

I went with a Buffalo system from PartsExpress.com - the biggest cost is the repeater device. I think the cheapest you can get by is just under $100, I don't know of anything less.

http://www.partsexpress.com/webpage....7&WebPage_ID=3

B
post #72 of 97
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Some Spacers have a clear back. You could try to run IR from the Niles block to the back of the Spacer to control it.
I had posed this same question early on in this thread and I don't believe anyone has tried it yet. It would stand to reason that the clear back of the control unit would allow this to work. The alternative would be to stick an IR bug to the sensor at the front. But as the sensor is embedded in the Zone 4 button it would probably come off all the time from use. And it would look like hell to boot. Anyone who successfully installs a rear sensor please report. The rather insensitive and narrow-angle sensor on the controller is my only real complaint about this product.


Quote:
the Spacer System remote controls 4 zones combined for the 2 dimmers.
More accurately the system has memory for four scenes across your two dimmers or zones (up to a maximum of ten zones split into two 5-gang boxes). A zone is dedicated lighting circuit, whereas a scene is a pre-programmed combination of on/off and dimmer settings for each zone.

Quote:
So if my understanding is correct, the 1 remote will control both units. Would I use 1 or 2 flashers to control these 2 units - 1 signal (if I understand correctly) would control both. If 1 flasher, where would I mount it to control both dimmers?
You are correct - one remote would run both dimmers. You could use one or both flashers. The spec allows for one flasher to control up to five (5) switches (they can be dimmer or straight on/off) in a single gang, with the flasher located in the middle and firing left/right/down. You could have up to two 5-gang systems controlled by the two flashers, or a total of ten (10) independent lighting zones. These zones could be actually be anywhere in the house, but the actual switches would need to be in a single gang with no partitions between.

If you use only one flasher (which I would recommend as it will easily control two dimmers) you would clip it to the top of either dimmer as directed. If you had three dimmers it would be in the middle. Hang on to the second flasher and you could use it for another gang in the future if necessary.

My installation includes five zones all housed in a single box. Since there is no chance that I will need the second flasher to control anything else, and since I pre-wired two cables from controller to gang, I used both. One on the Zone 2 dimmer and the other on Zone 4. You can see this in my installation pictures. So there is plenty of light to go around and control all the gangs. Note that these flashers are uber-powerful. One was controlling all the dimmers even when it was hanging outside of the gang prior to final installation.

Hopefully that makes sense. Let me know if you need any clarification.
post #73 of 97
Jay, et all:

Quote:
I had posed this same question early on in this thread and I don't believe anyone has tried it yet. It would stand to reason that the clear back of the control unit would allow this to work.


Works great. Spacer System dimmers all have clear backs, and an IR sensor in back, so all you have to do is stick an IR blaster in the wall box and you're good to go. No limit to the number of dimmers you can control this way, and no need to purchase the Lutron controller, unless you want the convenience.

The Spacer dimmer I have does not have a clear back box, so this trick doesn't work.

Not sure about the Maestro.

The workaround for me, when I just had a single Spacer dimmer at the top of the stairs, was to position an IR blaster in the opposite wall, pointing directly at the dimmer. The small hole for the blaster was not noticeable.
post #74 of 97
Has anyone tried using a regular Niles IR flasher. I would like to know if a blaster is really necessary? Or maybe I would be able to use the dual flashers and mount one on each side of the four-wide gangbox?

I am setting up with 4-main dimmers plus 5-accessory dimmers and will also be using the Niles IR system for controlling lighting and components housed in a cabinet.

The lighting of the room will feature 8- 5" can ceiling lights with nickel trim, 2- 4" can soffit lights with wall lighting trims and 4-wall sconces(two in the back and two in the front).

I am looking forward to finishing this basement HT project, but its going very slowly. Hopefully by the end of year, but its going to be close.

Speaking of electrical work, I just discovered that my breaker panel is a safety hazard. I urge all who are doing electrical work to see if your panel is a Stab-Lok panel made by Federal Pacific Electric. If it is, then I reccommend you replace it. FPE had an issue with double-pole breakers not breaking the circuit properly and house fires have been caused by them. FPE changed hands several times and are no longer in the breaker panel business. I don't believe there is much one can do to get replacement cost from FPE, but I know for sure either in NJ or NY there currently is a Class-Action suit regarding these panels.

I have heard estimates as high as 10% homes in the US have FPE panels. If your home was built before 1990, then look to see what brand of panel you have.
post #75 of 97
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Has anyone tried using a regular Niles IR flasher.

I have no experience with Niles products but presumably any home control system with programmable IR relays would work. You can get the codes to the Lutron remotes off Remote Central, but I'll bet Niles already has a set. The Lutron Master Control is nothing more than an IR repeater at the end of the day. It's transferring remote codes from one area (ex. the main room) to another (ie. the gang of zone switches).

That said the master control would simplify the whole layout and gives you a manual access point as soon as you walk in the room. Plus it's not that expensive. Biggest challenge is that it's designed primarily for new installations where you can easily run the traveller wires.
post #76 of 97
This is a very informative thread, Thanks folks!

I've just about settled on a Spacer system for my small media room. (13'x14' room). Direct view Loewe Aconda (so no need for a projector)

Design goals:
Use a Harmony Remote (IR) to drive the "scenes".
I also wanted to drive the ceiling fan with the same (as part of some "scenes"), but the Spacer system (nor any other lighting control package I've looked over) doesn't seem to support this. From what I gather I can't just use an incandescent Spacer dimmer for the fan. I may give it a go with a regular spacer switch (fan speed still would have to be controlled via a pull chain) and see what happens with that...)

Zones
I would have three zones.
1. Wall sconces (Spacer Dimmer)
2. Ideal-lume Fluorescent backlight (Spacer switch?
3. Rope lighting (Spacer Dimmer)

As my gang of switches are located by the entrance door (behind all seating), I'm guessing I'm not going to have much luck getting the IR signal to bounce back. I was thinking of putting a remote master on one of the side walls towards the front of the room (it would be ugly on the "viewing wall") to catch signals and via the travelers blast them back to the "entrance gang" of Spacer Units.

I originally wanted to simply use a Spacer lamp dimmer for my ideal-lume, but the spec sheets list it only for incandescent/halogen lighting. This looks like it would have taken a separate "action" with the remote to aim at the lamp control (physically different location than the other Spacer IR receivers, I didn't like this idea).

At this point, I'm thinking of adding an outlet controlled by a Spacer switch (not dimmer) to control it.

I still haven't decided if I want to locate the Equipment in the closet of this room (I thought I did, but then I like to be able to see the control panels of the receiver & DVD players. The HTPC will definitely go in the closet.
post #77 of 97
Very informative. I may consider using this type of lighting in my HT. I don't really have that big of an HT so maybe not. I am definitely using IR for components and getting the parts at Parts Express.

Don
post #78 of 97
Thread Starter 
I'm glad this thread is still getting some use. Don, I don't know if size limits you from this type of product. Actually, some very dramatic lighting and control through multiple zones could actually expand the perceived scale of your theater. It adds to the wow factor. When people see my room they are invariably amazed at how the lights fade in and out from scene to scene. In reality it's a very simple process and system but to those unfamiliar with the tech it blows them away.
post #79 of 97
Has anyone ever had an issue with the Lutron Spacer System switches not operating properly?

I have a SPS-1000M connected to two SPS-ADs. The tap switch on the ADs work, but the tap on the main dimmer does not work at all.

Just curious if anyone has had a problem with these switches before.

The replacement Lutron sent works, but they sent the wrong color.
post #80 of 97
Hello all,

I am looking to install a remote controlled dimmer for the 4 recessed lights in our HT. It should be pretty basic and I think I know how it is supposed to work but wanted to check with the experts here on the forum. First of all, here's the dimmer I will probably use:



Our lights can be operated by 2 different switches. This means that they are 3-way switches, correct? I only want to put a dimmer on one of these switches so I'm planning to replace one of the switches with the dimmer switch and leave the other as a "regular" switch. Will this work? As long as I don't touch the "regular" switch while I'm using the dimmer there shouldn't be a problem, right?

Of course, I know next to nothing about wiring so I could be planning to do something that will burn our house down.

So could someone let me know if this is how I should do it? And if it isn't, any suggestions?

Thanks.

With regards,
Darren
post #81 of 97
Just an update. I have successfully used a Niles IR repeater with the Lutron Spacer System.

The reason I am doing this is because my Lutron Spacer dimmers and components are at a very large angle from the seating position and the projector is ceiling mounted.


I have an IR sensor mounted on the wall directly in front of me near a corner so its not behind the screen. The IR sensor is connected to the Niles MSU250 repeater.

Since I have four spacer dimmers mounted in a gang box I had to use a dual IR flasher and mount one on the right and the other in the left side of the box. I suppose I could have used a single blaster which is larger but the box is already pretty full.
post #82 of 97
I was able to use a Sonance Optilinq IR repeater with my Lutron Spacer dimmer, but it took a few tries to place the IR emitter in exactly the right location.
post #83 of 97
I was wondering how I can go about and install this and make it functional if the light switchs are behind my seating area

Marc
post #84 of 97
Quote:
I was wondering how I can go about and install this and make it functional if the light switchs are behind my seating area


To make it work with good reliability I would install an IR Repeater system which consists of an IR sensor, control unit, and IR flashers that repeat the signal.

There are some cheaper units that are available that run on batteries and use RF to send the signal to the flashers.

I am using a Niles system that looks more like a professional install. I mounted an IR sensor in low voltage gang box with a Decora face plate. That sensor is connect via CAT5 to a Niles MSU250 control unit that is hardwired to the flashers. This system probably only makes sense if you have your wall stripped bare to the studs so you can do the wiring.
post #85 of 97
Thread Starter 
Hey All

There was discussion throughout this thread regarding the use of IR emitters to help control the Spacer Remote Master. As I indicated in my original post the only gripe I have with the Spacer system is the Wall Mounted Remote's lousy IR sensitivity. Because the case is clear we proposed sticking IR bugs to the back to facilitate better control. I finally got around to doing this now that my theater is complete and here are the results:

http://www.hometheaterforum.com/gall...g2_itemId=4664

First off, just placing the emitter on the back won't work. There are two layers of circuit boards in the way of the sensor. Nor can you place them on the side of the case to flash the sensor directly as there's not enough room to install into the gang box. I chose to install the emitter (actually two emitters - had a dual head kicking around) right inside the case.

The reason why the remote sensor is so lousy is that it's not even located in the fourth scene button, which I had assumed given the IR pane. Turns out the IR window simply directs the signal to the sensor on the circuit board. I placed the emitters on either side of the inner case to flank the sensor. They are in turn connected via extension cable to my RF base station in the equipment room. I'm fortunate to have a wood basement floor so was able to go below to fish through the wall.

End result is perfect response (after a bit of a boost to the base station's output - I split a channel to accommodate both the lights and the projector). No more line of sight, with the ability to create slick macros for movie time, intermission, etc. The photos in the gallery will save you much of the time I spent staring at the thing figuring out how I was going to accomplish this. Only challenge is opening the case - the screws are small and they use a non-standard bit. I was able to use a little flathead screwdriver that had enough grip to get them out.

I'm looking forward to further results from you guys.
post #86 of 97
Hello everyone!

I just had to chime in and let you all know this thread has been incredibly helpful to me. I want to especially thank Jay for starting this in the first place and making this seem like not such a daunting task after all. I'm typically very savvy with wiring things but for some reason this Spacer System had me wondering about my abilities.

I'm in the process of finishing the framing in my future basement home theater and the electrical is next on the list. I've got the main home theater room that is about 16' by 28' with an additional 14' by 20' section off to one side towards the back. I've come up with six different zones including ones for step lights, wall sconces, and various recessed cans. Had it not been for Jay's very helpful information, I would not be doing what I'm doing. It's this sort of sharing of information that reminds me of why I stick around the Home Theater Forum.

Thanks again everyone!
post #87 of 97
Thread Starter 
Hey David

That's great. I would strongly suggest you also consider running at least a CAT-5 for an IR installation as I documented above. To that you can wire the head for an emitter. Pre-wiring is cheap and well worth it even if you don't decide to do this in the future. Likewise I applaud your multiple zones. Double check before drywall goes up to make sure you don't want any more. A single Spacer master control can operate a total of ten zones split between two 5-gang boxes.

Good luck and keep us posted.
post #88 of 97
I have been reading that people are haveing difficulty with the IR reciever having a narrow range? I've got the Maestro IR dimmers and I don't have any problems at all. Just painted all my walls dark red (satin finish) and I can even bounce the signal off the wall and dim all the lights. Perhaps they identified a flaw and fixed it, but I couldn't be happier with the install. So much so that I've relplace a few other switches in other parts of the house.
I am curious, what is the difference between the "spacer" and Maestro IR?
post #89 of 97
Thread Starter 
Quote:
I have been reading that people are haveing difficulty with the IR reciever having a narrow range?
Pathetically so. It's my only complaint about the system. I think the big reason is not the sensor itself but rather how it's positioned. The actual IR sensor sits on the circuit board of the remote master, behind and off to the left of the window on the fourth scene button. You can see it here. So unless the IR signal is coming from dead on or slightly to the right of the master you're out of luck. Regardless of remote strength (and I've tried with a Pronto and Home Theater Master MX-850 both of which have very strong emitters).

If Lutron would have positioned the sensor a) directly below the IR window instead of being offset, and b) closer to the window itself it would perform much better. Someone handy with a soldering pen would be able to remedy this themselves. Alternatively you can just install emitters like I detailed above. If you already have an IR repeater system then the emitter install is the way to go, particularly if you run RF. I no longer have any line of site issues and can flawlessly incorporate lighting control into macros.
post #90 of 97
OK... I read this whole post and would like some qualifications:

I am in the framing stage ready to do drywall, and my electrician has run all my wiring for the two zones and two dimmer switches I will have in my HT room.

If I want to make life easy the best thing I could do is RUN CAT 5 to the dimmer switch and then back to my AV rack where I hope to have a RF-IR Repeater which will take commands from my RF remote and pass them through to the IR emitter.

Is this the correct procedure?

Thanks
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
Home Theater Forum › Home Theater Forum › Home Theater › Members' Theaters, HT Projects, Remotes, Seating, Accessories & Lighting › Lutron Spacer Installation 101 (Rev. 1/17/06 - Adding IR Emitters)