Re: THE WIRE season 3 (ongoing thread) (SPOILERS!)
Hannibal Lecter was also originally written as a sociopath, killing people for no other reason than they're stupid or crass, and the audience roots for him. Well that's a cop-out.
I root for him. As long as it's a movie. I often want to slap some crass or intentionally stupid person upside the back of the head. The irony being, taking such actions would in themselves be crass. Anti-heroes allow a certain vicarious release of uncivilized emotions.
Anyway, one reason Hannibal the movie (and book) didn't work for me is because Lecter is a sociopath.
Profile of the Sociopath -- one characteristic is "incapable of love". But Harris made
Hannibal out to be a love story (with Clarice). It was the worse pandering. Hannibal as originally written wasn't in love with Clarice, he just found her interesting -- and interesting was the end all to Hannibal Lector. He said it all at the end of
The Silence of The Lambs -- the world is a more interesting place with Clarice in it. That's the
only reason she wasn't on his bad side. Nothing to do with love.
Anyway, back to Marlo. He was definitely fascinating to watch, but only in a sort of clinical way for me. I might watch a documentary on Nazi human experiments, but only for the information, not enjoyment. Marlo wasn't that bad, but I found myself thinking, "Here's a guy who seems to have no redeeming value whatsoever as a human being."
Still, I'm able to admire good qualities in bad people, so while I was put off by Marlo, I did admire his focus and instinct. He also had a certain amount of vision.
One thing is for sure... The Wire rocks, in all it's incarnations.