Quote:
| Harry, I know that you are a bit more of a TT fan than a VTTBOTS fan, so I figured you would nicely remind us of the sales figures (and there's nothing wrong with that at all). I too have monitored the rankings via Amazon, and I must say I am surprised and somewhat disappointed that TT has ranked better. Not so much because I'm looking for competition between the two series, but more so because I sincerely believe "Voyage" represents the best of the Irwin Allen series. |
I certainly cannot deny you your choice for what was the best - and viewing these old black & white episodes, with the superior stories and direction, I might have to agree. So if it were just a comparison of TIME TUNNEL with VOYAGE's first season, I'd pick VOYAGE as the better TV series of the two, story-wise. With the later season silliness with the rubber-suitd monsters, VOYAGE took a turn for the worse, so overall, I'd probably pick TIME TUNNEL as the better of the two - just because it didn't have the chance to get "too silly".
My fascination with THE TIME TUNNEL comes from its premise, the idea of time travel, and the physical appearance of that fantastic set. The actual execution of the show left some things to be desired.
Quote:
I'd attribute TT's higher rankings to three things:
1) It's recently been on Encore and therefore has a leg up on Voyage when it comes to recognizability with the younger set. Even if this represents only a small percentage of increased sales, it's something that has to be factored in. |
I can't imagine that the Encore Action Channel gets that many people watching it. The universe of subscribers that even get the channel has to be painfully small - and the number of THOSE people who actually watched or recorded TIME TUNNEL has to be considerably smaller than that. (I work in radio and know a bit about ratings and reaching audiences.)
Quote:
| 2) As much as I hate to say it (because it reflects poorly on today's tv viewers), I do believe the black & white versus color argument has some validity. It's crazy, but true none the less. |
I'd bet the house on that. But the weird thing there is: Have you ever had occasion to watch popular music videos, and nitice how many of them are deliberately filmed in black & white?
Quote:
| 3) With newbies/youngsters controlling the dollar spending so much, it only makes sense that they'd be more attracted to a show about "time travel" than "sailing the 7 seas." That's just a function of the age in which we live. Kids desire more fantasy and science fiction than they do straight drama/action. And even though VTTBOTS gives us the best of both worlds, the younger generation doesn't know this and will naturally gravitate toward the show that has the "cooler" concept (if you get my meaning). |
I'd tend to agree with that. The whole Cold War scenario is somewhat dated, though if you transpose the VOYAGE foreign despots with today's terrorists, some of those stories could be considered valid. Time travel is nearly always valid since history remains constant and the future is unknown.
Quote:
| I've been thoroughly enjoying both sets this week, but have to admit that after about 3 episodes of TT I got bored. It seems to me the show immediately fell into a very predictable pattern. Voyage, on the other hand, has been a joy to watch and has much more variety. |
Funny, I've had just the opposite experience. Watching my fave, THE TIME TUNNEL was a supreme joy while I've found myself dozing off during some of the slower moments aboard the Seaview. But the good thing about DVDs is, you just go back and play them again.
But the bottom line is, I realize how THE TIME TUNNEL has been frowned upon over the years, so it's a happy surprise to see it: a) respected enough to get a great DVD treatment, and b) apparently selling well in the process.
Harry "fill in a witty line here" N.