Quote:
as far as the "second season sucks" sentiments
here are two typical plotlines for the second season:
36. Testimony of a Traitor
*snip*
35. The Hand of Goral
*snip*
and here are two typical plotlines for the first season:
21. Space Rockers
*snip*
13. Cruise Ship to the Stars
*snip*
i'll probably still pick up the first season, but most of the episodes were simple minded and cheesy as hell. |
You can just as easily prove that the first season is "better" if you pick different typical examples. For instance:
First season
"Flight of the War Witch" - Buck journeys through a space warp into another universe, where he discovers that the peaceful planet Pendar is being threatened by the sinister war witch Zarina. The Pendarans enlist the aid of Buck and Princess Ardala, who had followed Buck through the space warp, and an unsteady alliance between the humans and Draconians is formed as Buck leads a combined fleet against Zarina's battlecruiser.
Second season
"The Golden Man" - The Searcher rescues a gold-skinned boy from an escape capsule in an asteroid field. When the ship collides with one of the asteroids, the boy assures the crew of the Searcher that, with the help of his companion, who is on a nearby planet, he can dislodge the ship from the asteroid. But when Buck and Hawk go to the planet to get the companion, they find that he is being held captive by a man who wants to use the boy's powers for his own greedy purposes.
My point is that
both seasons had a pretty good amount of good
and bad storylines. There's a lot of bad in "The Golden Man" and the one with the Dwarves, for instance. The reason it's easier to cite more first season examples is that the season was twice as long.
Also, one problem is that you mention the merits of second season
plotlines. True, several of the storylines sound good (a great many of them are stolen from other series, like the Bringers of Wonder episode of
Space: 1999). The problem is that many of these storylines are let down in the actual execution, by a tight budget, high school-level acting and some casting mistakes.
As a kid, I have to be honest: I preferred the second season, but after seeing the episodes again as an adult, I find the first season vastly more entertaining: yes, most of the episodes
are cheesy, but they're played with an almost knowing sense of fun, sort of like the audience is "in" on the joke. It's good, campy fun. I don't think one could really say the same about the second season: they tried to do straight drama, but unfortunately, didn't have the resources necessary to pull it off.