I think I can see a pattern here of why bad covers are just bad. Not using the theatrical poster art is one. Not using the original font or color scheme of the initial marketing campaign is another. Alot of these studios don't get it. If a movie is succesful and is popular don't try to reinvent it with some rushed new look for the product, because 99% it looks like garbage and is unappealing to everyone.
Now I say the Panic Room SE works though. The font and 2 color scheme grab your attention from all the visually busy covers that might be on the shelf around it. This also worked for a lot of laserdisc box sets. Seven, The Game, T2, Robocop. All you needed was the movie logo and some themed texture around it. Laserdiscs sure were classy back then:

Bad reimagined DVD cover art:


