RYAN----Interesting post. I agree that the 5.1 tracks really aren't needed. Last year I went through the 8 Paramount discs within a couple days and IMO, none of them need any work when it comes to the V/A. Part 4 has one horrid looking scene (the shower scene) yet it's weird because THE PROWLER (directed by the same guy) has one bad looking scene and it takes place in the shower.
As I said earlier, extras mean nothing to me so I'm happy with what I've got. However, I will buy whatever is released. I'm going to be buying the extras because I'm a die-hard fan. Had I been a lesser fan I'd certainly skip these upgrades. As for being uncut, I've still got my doubts. "Some" footage has been found but this could just lead to more controversy. For years (decades really) there have been rumors about what was cut and what wasn't. Since this hasn't actually been seen, we're going on mainly rumors so if we get uncut versions, the edits could be as small as what we saw in part 1. I've seen part 7 uncut and there is a major difference there so that would be a big change. The DVD of part 5 and I think 3 feature a few extra seconds so it'll be interesting to see how much more is out there.
I'm currently holding onto my current discs because I'm worried that these "director's cuts" might hurt the actual films. I don't mind them putting the gore back in but I really hope they don't add anything just to make it "uncut". Meaning, I hope something filmed for television isn't just thrown in for a fake uncut release (ala what people buy on Ebay). My favorite of the series is part 6 and rumor has it that this was filmed in different versions. I personally love the rather non-violent version out there now and personally, I'd hate to see this thing as some bloodbath because it could take away the film as I know it.
I think another thing to keep in mind is that it might not be possible for uncut releases. This is what I meant earlier when I said fans would never be happy. I think the bottom line is that Paramount is trying to restore these but in the end, it might not be possible and I hope fans understand this. The effort could be there and the final results might not be what we wanted but there isn't anything else to be done. The cut footage in OFFICER is lost so we should probably expect "some" stuff to be lost here.
So, for F13, I will rebuy these for the extras, which will be commentaries, interviews and perhaps deleted scenes. I'll do this because I love the series. I own the NIGHTMARE set and this is something I'd never rebuy. I'll watch the movies but don't need extras for any of them. With F13, I'll take some extras but if it doesn't happen I still have the movies to watch at least.
As I said earlier, extras mean nothing to me so I'm happy with what I've got. However, I will buy whatever is released. I'm going to be buying the extras because I'm a die-hard fan. Had I been a lesser fan I'd certainly skip these upgrades. As for being uncut, I've still got my doubts. "Some" footage has been found but this could just lead to more controversy. For years (decades really) there have been rumors about what was cut and what wasn't. Since this hasn't actually been seen, we're going on mainly rumors so if we get uncut versions, the edits could be as small as what we saw in part 1. I've seen part 7 uncut and there is a major difference there so that would be a big change. The DVD of part 5 and I think 3 feature a few extra seconds so it'll be interesting to see how much more is out there.
I'm currently holding onto my current discs because I'm worried that these "director's cuts" might hurt the actual films. I don't mind them putting the gore back in but I really hope they don't add anything just to make it "uncut". Meaning, I hope something filmed for television isn't just thrown in for a fake uncut release (ala what people buy on Ebay). My favorite of the series is part 6 and rumor has it that this was filmed in different versions. I personally love the rather non-violent version out there now and personally, I'd hate to see this thing as some bloodbath because it could take away the film as I know it.
I think another thing to keep in mind is that it might not be possible for uncut releases. This is what I meant earlier when I said fans would never be happy. I think the bottom line is that Paramount is trying to restore these but in the end, it might not be possible and I hope fans understand this. The effort could be there and the final results might not be what we wanted but there isn't anything else to be done. The cut footage in OFFICER is lost so we should probably expect "some" stuff to be lost here.
So, for F13, I will rebuy these for the extras, which will be commentaries, interviews and perhaps deleted scenes. I'll do this because I love the series. I own the NIGHTMARE set and this is something I'd never rebuy. I'll watch the movies but don't need extras for any of them. With F13, I'll take some extras but if it doesn't happen I still have the movies to watch at least.




