Re: Film Noir - LIST
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Doug Otte
...Also, the commentaries add a lot of depth and extra dimension and I get a lot more out of them when I watch the 2nd time with the commentary. Even His Kind of Woman was interesting...
|
Right after I posted this note, I started watching "Lady" with the commentary on (Deepak: I usually don't have time to sit through an entire movie; I usually see 15-30 minutes here and there until I get through it - not the best way to appreciate a film, but usually it's my only option!). Anyway, James Ursini & Alain Silver share this one, and while it's interesting, I was slightly upset/amused about something.
During the first scene in the publisher's office, they discussed the long takes with almost no "cheats," and asked us to appreciate that particular scene with no cuts. At the precise moment they said it, there was a fast pan with a cut! Maybe they weren't watching that part of the film while recording their comments, but it was kind of funny. It's very rare that I notice something that the experts miss!
Doug















