Re: Film Noir - LIST
I was going to suggest that
we here try to develop a criteria. Something along the lines of...
To be calssified a
Film Noir it must have 6 of the following 10 (I'm making these numbers up):
1) Anti-hero protagonist
2) Shot in black and white (not exclusive) with murky, shadowy grays.
3) Ex-convict or recent ex-convict characters.
4) Flash-back (remembered) narratives.
5) Occasional obtuse camera angles.
6) Plot derived from the hard-boiled pulp fiction novels.
7) American crime drama or an attempted representation of such.
8) One or more Femme fatales - “an irresistibly attractive women... especially ones that lead men into danger or disaster”.
9) Plot devices of amnesia, shared guilt, pathos, or classic nemesis.
10) Enviornment of the downtrodden, lower classes, or economically depressed.
This is just a sample which I'm sure can be greatly improved upon. I'd love to hear suggestions for other attributes and the numbering system. We could value each with points and to be a Noir it must obtain X points... again just thinking out loud.
NOTE: I am sure there are some very astute film fans that can name some non-noir films that have 6 of the 10 above. That is not what my post is about - it is not a contest.
Anyone have any ideas? We could at least develop a rough guideline this way.
BTW, I just rewatched Ulmer's
Detour last night. Might be my favorite Film Noir.
Best,
Gary