Haven't opened this thread in months since the "not enough films seen to date" Nazis deleted my original post last spring. Now the rules seem to be "no rules." Whatever...

Anyway, since Dana is using data from this thread for his analysis in the throw-down thread, I'll re-post my list (and hope it stays this time):
Last update: 07/05/2004
Criterion used: Oscar Eligibility
No. of films seen so far: 46
The top ten (so far):
1. City of God
2. Whale Rider
3. Thirteen
4. Lost in Translation
5. Mystic River
6. 21 Grams
7. Seabiscuit
8. In America
9. Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
10. The Fog of War
The best of the rest:
11. Bend It Like Beckham
12. Finding Nemo
13. Girl With a Pearl Earring
14. Cold Mountain
15. House of Sand and Fog
16. Monster
17. American Splendor
18. Swimming Pool
19. Matchstick Men
20. Dirty Pretty Things
21. Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
22. The Last Samurai
23. Something's Gotta Give
24. Love Actually
25. The Cooler
26. Owning Mahowny
27. Bad Santa
28. Calendar Girls
29. Pieces of April
30. Raising Victor Vargas
31. The Matrix Reloaded
32. Phone Booth
33. Intolerable Cruelty
34. Better Luck Tomorrow
35. The Italian Job
36. Freaky Friday
37. Elephant
38. Normal
39. Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl
40. XX/XY
41. The Matrix Revolutions
42. The Haunted Mansion
43. The Hulk
44. Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas
45. May
46. Legally Blonde 2
Rob