Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: The Signature Collection Blu-ray Review

Highly Recommended 4.5 Stars
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937)
Released: 04 Feb 1938
Rated: APPROVED
Runtime: 83 min
Director: William Cottrell, David Hand, Wilfred Jackson, Larry Morey, Perce Pearce, Ben Sharpsteen
Genre: Animation, Family, Fantasy
Cast: Roy Atwell, Stuart Buchanan, Adriana Caselotti, Hall Johnson Choir
Writer(s): Jacob Grimm (fairy tales), Wilhelm Grimm (fairy tales), Ted Sears (story), Richard Creedon (story), Otto Englander (story), Dick Rickard (story), Earl Hurd (story), Merrill De Maris (story), Dorothy Ann Blank (story), Webb Smith (story)
Plot: Snow White, pursued by a jealous queen, hides with the Dwarfs, but the queen learns of this and prepares to feed her a poison apple.
IMDB rating: 7.7
MetaScore: N/A

Disc Information
Studio: Disney
Distributed By: N/A
Video Resolution: 1080P/AVC
Aspect Ratio: 1.33:1
Audio: English 1.0 DD (Mono), English 7.1 DTS-HDMA, Spanish 5.1 DD, French 5.1 DD
Subtitles: English SDH, Spanish, French
Rating: G
Run Time: 1 Hr. 23 Min.
Package Includes: Blu-ray, DVD, Digital Copy
Case Type: Keep case in a slip cover
Disc Type: BD50 (dual layer)
Region: ABC
Release Date: 02/02/2016
MSRP: $36.99

The Production: 5/5

Jealous to the point of madness over anyone’s beauty outshining her own, the wicked Queen (Lucille LaVerne) is dismayed to learn from her Magic Mirror (Moroni Olsen) that her stepdaughter Snow White (Adriana Caselotti) has grown into a more ravishing beauty than she. Sent into the woods to be killed by the Queen’s huntsman (Stuart Buchanan), Show White is allowed to escape deep into the forest where she is led by her forest friends to the cottage of the seven dwarfs: Doc (Roy Atwell), Grumpy (Pinto Colvig), Happy (Otis Harlan), Sneezy (Billy Gilbert), Bashful (Scotty Mattraw), Sleepy (Pinto Colvig), and the mute Dopey. The Magic Mirror, however, knows all and informs the Queen that there is still alive a beauty that outshines her own. The queen then decides to take matters into her own hands and takes drastic measures to eliminate Snow White once and for all.

To modern viewers who are spoiled by the animation of such late Disney classics as Beauty and the Beast or The Lion King not to mention the animation fare of the Golden Age such as Bambi and Peter Pan, Snow White might seem to be a bit lacking in the “wow” department, yet it would be almost impossible to find a more expertly or evocatively drawn sequence than the horrific dash through the forest when Show White is released by the huntsman and is running for her life. With every tree limb a gnarly hand trying to grab and hold her and with the trees filled with all manner of demonic presences, it’s little wonder she eventually collapses into a sea of traumatized tears. And yet, the horrors of the scene give way to the film’s most lilting tune “With a Smile and a Song” where Disney’s animation geniuses have imbued every forest creature with such adorable personalities (without giving them the ability to speak) that they chase away the princess’ fears (and our own) and restore a sense of joy and wonder to the proceedings. Of course, the entire Frank Churchill-Paul Smith-Leigh Harline song score is so filled with gems it’s rather amazing to realize that not a single one of them was nominated for the Best Song Oscar (the original score was nominated) even though six of them made it onto the Hit Parade.

The script for the film is credited to no fewer than eight hands: Ted Sears, Otto Englander, Earl Hurd, Dorothy Ann Blank, Richard Credon, Dick Rickard, Merrill De Maris, and Webb Smith, so it’s impossible to know who did what. What’s generally terrific, however, is that the film’s deft mix of comedy with the melodramatic evil of the Queen and her unstoppable mission to destroy her rival is astutely handled marking something of a touchstone for all of Disney’s future animated efforts. The best cartoon features in the studio’s vaults all manage this astute handling of comedic and dramatic elements without either side predominating.

As for the voice casting, it’s superb. True, Adriana Caselotti’s tremulous soprano dates her singing clearly to the 1930s when young soprano vocalists such as Deanna Durbin were so popular, but its sweetness and naiveté are unmistakably right for the part of Snow White. As her polar opposite, Lucille LaVerne finds all of the cruelty and malignant power as the mad Queen and her crone counterpart. Famous for his long take sneezes, Billy Gilbert was picture perfect casting as Sneezy, and all of the other voice actors for the dwarfs etch wonderful characters with a limited number of spoken lines. Harry Stockwell’s Prince gets the least development (even the huntsman is a stronger character) by the animators, but he certainly handles the Prince’s “One Song” with appropriate ardor.

Video: 4.5/5

3D Rating: NA

The film’s 1.33:1 theatrical aspect ratio is faithfully delivered in this 1080p transfer using the AVC codec. The transfer gives every appearance as being the same one used in the 2009 Blu-ray release right down to the main titles and the opening storybook pages being windowboxed (the remainder of the feature is not). The color palette is an adroit mixture of pastels and primary colors which the Blu-ray has no trouble handling. Banding which can sometimes creep into animation transfers is nowhere to be seen. Sharpness is the variable in this transfer with about 90% of it looking majestically sharp while otherwise there are occasional frames or the edges of frames which are softer and less distinct, and in typical Disney home video fashion, the image seems to have been digitally smoothed. The image is certainly free from any dirt or debris. The transfer has been divided into 27 chapters.

Audio: 4/5

The DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 remixed soundtrack is clear and clean and is free from age-related artifacts such as hiss or crackle. The main title music and some other musical passages do channel the music to the seven sound channels (the LFE channel is barely used), but most amazing is that the film’s most exciting sequence, the chase of the crone by the dwarfs while rain, wind, thunder, and lightning pummel the soundtrack, seems to revert to the original mono nature of the audio since the surround channels are mostly silent here. For purists, a remastered Dolby Digital 1.0 soundtrack is also provided and sounds authentic and without age-related problems.

Special Features: 4.5/5

Audio Commentary: Disney scholar John Canemaker hosts and is supplemented with vintage comments from Walt Disney and the Disney staff which makes for a fantastic history behind the making of the film.

In Walt’s Words (4:22, HD): transcribed from an audio interview in 1956, Walt Disney comments on the making of the film. Some of these comments are included in the above commentary.

Iconography (7:16, HD): current staff artists reminisce about their first experiences with Snow White and then produce iconic sculptures using their own various media abilities.

@DisneyAnimation: Designing Disney’s First Princess (5:16, HD): today’s animators look at various influences from the 1930s which influenced the look of Snow White.

The Fairest Facts of Them All (4:37, HD): Disney Channel star Sofia Carson relates seven little known facts about the iconic film.

Snow White in Seventy Seconds (1:12, HD): a young rapper relates the story of the film.

Alternate Sequence: The Prince Meets Snow White (3:39, HD): recreation of a crew story session of how the Prince and Snow White might meet for the first time.

The Making of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (33:15, HD): Disney historians such as Neal Gabler and John Canemaker along with many vintage interviews with Walt Disney and various animators tell the story of the four and half years leading up to the film’s premiere in December 1937.

Bringing Snow White to Life (11:35, HD): Andeas Dija and other Disney animators discuss the key artists assigned to the individual characters.

Hyperion Studios (30:36, HD): the interactive tour through Disney’s original animation studio has been shortened into a thirty-minute featurette offering the information contained in the 2009 Blu-ray tour but without any user interaction. The vignettes discuss work done onSnow White in various phases of the facility including the Story Room, the Music Room, Layout, Art Department, Animation Department, Live Art Reference, The Sweat Box, Ink & Paint, and Camera Department.

Decoding an Exposure Sheet (11:35, HD): a rather technical look at the record sheet kept on each sequence of the movie detailing times and movement of frames so each department would know exactly what was expected of them and what had already been done.

Snow White Returns (8:44, HD): a reconstruction of a possible animated sequel short using the two deleted musical numbers from the film along with some new bridging material.

Story Meeting/Dwarfs (5:51, HD): a recreation of a story session between Walt and his story men concerning dwarf behavior at a key moment.

Story Meeting/Huntsman (3:55, HD): a recreation of a story session between Walt and his story men concerning the huntsman’s behavior before his attack on Snow White.

Deleted Sequence/Soup (4:07, HD): the pencil sketches for the deleted soup-eating sequence.

Deleted Sequence/Bed (6:28, HD): the pencil sketches and stills for the deleted bed-making sequence.

Voice Talent (6:20, SD): a short about the various actors who voice the major characters in the film.

Promo Trailers (HD): Zootopia, The Good Dinosaur.

DVD/Digital Copy: disc and code sheet enclosed in the case.

Overall: 4.5/5

Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs is a landmark in the history of cinema, and while it may not be most people’s favorite Disney animated feature, it certainly set the tone and texture for all of the greatest ones which were to be created in the next few decades. There are some new bonus features with this release while most of the games and some other bonus material has been dropped from the 2009 Blu-ray release. For those who don’t have the film in any version, this is highly recommended. Others will have to weigh for themselves if the new bonus content is reason enough to buy it again.

Published by

Matt Hough

administrator

34 Comments

  1. Pinocchio is probably the greatest animation miracle of all time and the artistry will never be surpassed.  Also, an excellent script and absolutely thrilling and entertaining film.

  2. Hello all—I could have sworn that I saw something about there being a newly discovered and restored Oswald short included with this new release.Did I imagine that?Regards,matt

  3. It's my favorite Disney Animated Movie.  One extra not included that should have been is the 1938-04-24 episode of the Jack Benny radio program that includes the parody Snow White and the Seven Gangsters (https://archive.org/details/JackBenny1  currently number 55 on the list).  This is one of the best bits from the show ever and it was done with Walt Disney in attendance.  Best part: Andy Devine as The Prince.

  4. My copy of the new Blu-ray arrived today. I plan to watch it this weekend and compare the audio commentary to the one on the previous Blu-ray to see if there are any difference I can suss out. I will post an update within the next two weeks, as my weekends have a habit of getting away from me. 🙂

  5. A shame that the Oswald short isn't actually included on the disc; it's inclusion would have actually gotten me to rebuy Snow White even though I already own the previous Diamond edition Blu. Not a fan of these digital only extras.

  6. Same here, too.  Snow White is an essential, but it would take an earthshaking MAJOR development for me to purchase another release.  I still enjoy gazing at the deluxe laserdisc box..and that first Platinum DVD set has sentimental value, so it stays.  Those and the 2009 Blu-ray are it, man.  No more.

  7. [QUOTE=Charles Smith]

    Same here, too.  Snow White is an essential, but it would take an earthshaking MAJOR development for me to purchase another release.  I still enjoy gazing at the deluxe laserdisc box..and that first Platinum DVD set has sentimental value, so it stays.  Those and the 2009 Blu-ray are it, man.  No more.

    [/QUOTE]The formats get better and Disney's efforts get worse. If they didn't know they needed home video, I'm sure they'd bail on physical media altogether.

  8. [QUOTE=Ken_McAlinden]

    Thanks, Matt! Just FYI, the 2009 release included the mono soundtrack as well. It was selectable from the audio options menu as "Restored Original Soundtrack".

    [/QUOTE]

    Thanks for the information, Ken. I'll go back in and revise the review.

  9. [QUOTE=warnerbro]

    I guess Disney thinks they'll entice us to repurchase this set with the addition of:

      Snow White in Seventy Seconds (1:12, HD): a young rapper relates the story of the film.

    [/QUOTE]

    Yeah, right.

  10. I have the same conundrum with this I had with the Sleeping Beauty Blu-ray.  Nothing about it surpasses the previous release in way I value other than the fact that it is available digitally as well as on disc.  If I buy the digital copy by itself, I feel like I am now a data point saying that digital copies are preferable to physical releases.

    With Sleeping Beauty, I waited until the Blu-ray plus digital copy release went on sale for the same price as the digital copy by itself.  I'll probably do the same in this case.

  11. My question is how different is this new Walt Disney-John Canemaker audio commentary compared to the Walt Disney-Roy Disney track from the other release. I love vintage Walt and that's the only potential selling point for me here.

  12. [QUOTE=Josh Steinberg]

    My question is how different is this new Walt Disney-John Canemaker audio commentary compared to the Walt Disney-Roy Disney track from the other release. I love vintage Walt and that's the only potential selling point for me here.

    [/QUOTE]

    You mean the audio commentary from the first Blu-ray or from some earlier release on laser or DVD? As far as I know, the Blu-ray commentaries are the same. I will admit, however, I didn't play the commentary from the 2009 Blu-ray when I was doing the A/B comparison for the video quality. I just assumed it was the same. There was no mention in the press materials that it was new to this release.

  13. [QUOTE=Ken_McAlinden]

    I have the same conundrum with this I had with the Sleeping Beauty Blu-ray.  Nothing about it surpasses the previous release in way I value other than the fact that it is available digitally as well as on disc.  If I buy the digital copy by itself, I feel like I am now a data point saying that digital copies are preferable to physical releases.

    [/QUOTE]

    I know Vudu has a way of adding a digital copy for a discount if you already own a previous disc. I don't know if that applies to Disney movies, though, since they maintain control over all of their films via the Disney Digital Anywhere service. The only digital copies I own are ones that came along with the physical discs when I purchased them, so I haven't ever used the "upgrade" service. I'm with you on trying not to encourage streaming over physical media.

  14. Disney is advertising this release as "First Time on Digital HD" so I guess that's what this new release is *really* all about.

    In any event, I never purchased the 2009 BD release (still had my Platinum DVD with the "Disney through the Ages" special feature up on the shelf, and was still lamenting the end of HD-DVD at the time);  so I just ordered this.

    Thanks for the review!

  15. Never got the original either as I didn't have blu ray at that time (the only home video format I was late to adopt, early adopter with all other formats). Really looking forward to this and hope my favorite Pinocchio will be next for a reissue.

  16. [QUOTE=Randy Korstick]

    Never got the original either as I didn't have blu ray at that time (the only home video format I was late to adopt, early adopter with all other formats). Really looking forward to this and hope my favorite Pinocchio will be next for a reissue.

    [/QUOTE]

    Pinocchio is my favorite, too.

  17. [QUOTE="warnerbro, post: 4345052, member: 367311"]Pinocchio is probably the greatest animation miracle of all time and the artistry will never be surpassed.  Also, an excellent script and absolutely thrilling and entertaining film.[/QUOTE]

    And that fantastic song score, too. No wonder both the score and the "When You Wish Upon a Star" song won Oscars.

  18. [QUOTE="warnerbro, post: 4341987, member: 367311"]I guess Disney thinks they'll entice us to repurchase this set with the addition of:

      Snow White in Seventy Seconds (1:12, HD): a young rapper relates the story of the film.[/QUOTE]

    That may end up as Most Useless BD Extra of 2016 – what a waste of space!

    It's so bad they don't even tell us the name of the kid – maybe they wanted to protect her from future embarrassment! 😀

  19. Brad here.  First since I do not yet own a copy of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1938), I am debating on whether I should get this new Blu release or go back and try to obtain the 2009 Blu? I should get it to help complete my Disney Blu collection and we do get our friends Matt & Amy who in addition to two handsome sons, have a beautiful 4 year old daughter all of whom visit us regularly and would love to see Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs on the 70.

    Furthermore, should I also consider the previous Platinum DVD release to get extras that might not have made it to the Blu release (as Disney is notorious for)?

    Oh and some news along a different but related tack (prickly and controversial as it is), it has been reported on Wiki that Warner Bros possibly is looking to do a valid release of the "Censored Eleven" animated shorts from Merrie Melodies; foremost of which is the Bob Clampett short  Coal Black and the Sebben Dwarves.  According to the Censored Eleven Wiki page, all restoration and transfer work has been completed as of Jan 2016 but no official release announcement.

    I don't intend to start any discussion here on this related topic and any such dialogue should be referred to the appropriate HTF thread (or one started if none exists) so I won't say anything further on that topic here.

  20. [QUOTE="Josh Steinberg, post: 4342736, member: 304502"]My question is how different is this new Walt Disney-John Canemaker audio commentary compared to the Walt Disney-Roy Disney track from the other release. I love vintage Walt and that's the only potential selling point for me here.[/QUOTE]

    This morning I listened to the commentary from the first Blu-ray released and then a few hours later the one from the new Blu-ray. I cannot discern any differences.

    I will say I prefer the menus on the original Blu-ray, which is a bit truer to the film. The new menu feels like it is playing up the prestige of the film rather than the fun and joy of it.

  21. [QUOTE="Mark Walker, post: 4346773, member: 269416"]This morning I listened to the commentary from the first Blu-ray released and then a few hours later the one from the new Blu-ray. I cannot discern any differences.[/QUOTE]

    Thanks Mark!  I guess the initial press release that trumped a new commentary was in error.

  22. This release was made for people like me. I missed out on the 2009 release and now I have a 3 1/2 year old Disney princess fiend. I checked online for the 2009 release before this was announced and it would have cost me over $100 2nd hand. I am willing to forego any supplements for the chance to have Disney open up their precious vault and release it again so we can purchase it at a reasonable price.

  23. [QUOTE="dana martin, post: 4347956, member: 307828"]so Oswald is not on the physical disc, damn, looks like this is a pass then[/QUOTE]

    Seriously? All the hype about it and it's not even on the disc! Go figure. Is there any way to just get the short?

Leave a Reply