HTF Anime Discussion Part VII - Page 103

ChristopherDAC · 04-21-2005, 05:42 PM

Oh, and I really think that post 3000 should be the last in this thread. 100 pages is more than long enough for a thread somebody might want to search some day! Can I get a consensus on Part VIII?

**HTF Ads**

James_Kiang · 04-21-2005, 05:49 PM

Sounds good to me Christopher. It has grown a bit larger than normal, that's for sure.

JohnAD · 04-21-2005, 06:13 PM

Christopher:

I'll second it, so the motion is passed

.

James:

Magical Project S is a pretty good show for the younger set. I think Mao-Chan is also rated for 3+. I would recommend against showing Princess Mononoke to your daughter; not just for the violence, but I think for the themes as well. I've been thinking about this myself as well. My wife and I are planning on having kids soon, and I want to make sure the little Sith Lord or Sith Lady isn't warped (yet)

.

Kong:

So how many episodes of Yukikaze were on the US release? Was it the whole OVA, or just a couple of episodes?

John.

Woo Jae · 04-21-2005, 07:09 PM

Sith-lings?

I shall tremble before them just as I would tremble in fear of you...

Still at work, and it's one of those days... anyhow, hope to see more of kiddy grade tonight

Tony-B · 04-21-2005, 07:13 PM

Quote:

Studio Bones works around the clock, including weekends for over a year to create FMA ... and one work sums it up.

What if I changed that word to "Awesome", "Fantastic", or "Wonderful" instead of "Sucks"? Hmm?

Quote:

I seem to remember that Tony liked RaXephon. I guess there's hope for Studio Bones yet

What I've seen is alright, but I haven't seen it all yet.

Quote:

Today's youth are even more vocal about their tastes and opinions.

I think I'm more blunt than vocal in expressing my opinion.

Quote:

Are you a Takahashi fan, Tony? Please note, she has done a LOT more than just InuYasha.

Can't say that I'm a fan of her. I can't stand Inuyasha, and I'm pretty sure I haven't seen anything else by her.

Quote:

You say above that [FullMetal Alchemist] "sucks". I would be interested to read your constructive criticism of this show.

Alright. Here goes. I've seen the first 4 or 5 episodes of the series, and a few odd ones here and there later on in the series on Adult Swim. The episodes I saw didn't get my attention in any way whatsoever. The fact that it did not get my attention caused me to give up watching the series and do something more valuable with my time.

I didn't like FMA for the following reasons:
1. I found it incredibly boring.
2. The series loves to use one of the most common anime cliches: "Hey look at me! I've got powers and I know how to use them!" Those kind of shows tend to get on my nerves rather quickly.
3. The "comedic" parts lack intelligence, and I really can't stand the drawing style when the characters freak out about something.
4. The pseudo-philosophical junk and hokey science that populates the series makes my inner science nerd cry.

I was interested in Alphonse and his unique characteristics, but they never really seemed to showcase those qualities. Instead they just simply focus on making him a boring sidekick with few independent thoughts and whose main purpose is to throw lame jokes off of. I wish that he would be bitter and scarcastic instead of bland and lifeless. That would have made the series far more interesting and original.

FMA is really good when it comes to overall production values. It generally looks good, the animation is smooth, and the sound is usually good.

That's pretty much what I don't like about it. Flame away.

Rob Gardiner · 04-21-2005, 07:36 PM

Thanks, Tony, for explaining the reasoning behind your opinion. No flames are necessary, right?

Right away I can tell you I agree with complaint #3 -- I don't care for the "SD" (super deformed) look either.

But I disagree with you on #1. I've only seen the first 2 discs, but episodes 3, 4, 6, and especially 7 were particulary well-written, in my opinion. I'm not sure what you're getting at with #2. I wouldn't say Edward uses his powers in a "showy" way; rather, he uses them only when necessary. And as for #4, even though I love studying science, and I appreciate the sci-fi genre, I accept that this is a fantasy series that features a science that simply does not exist in the real world. I thought that turning the pseudo-scientific principle into a pseudo-philosophical principle was one of the shows great strengths.

In any case, while I don't agree with your opinion of the show, I understand where you are coming from, and I appreciate that you elaborated on your opinion in a thoughtful way.

Just out of curiosity, what anime are you a fan of? (Besides Miyazaki, of course.)

Tony-B · 04-21-2005, 08:12 PM

I would have wrote an explanation when I first brought up that I don't like FMA. However, I did not have the time to do so. Knowing that, I just made a very blunt and concise statement.

Sure, Edward does use the powers when necessary, but how many times does that happen? I think it's quite often.

As far as my favorite animes are concerned, I would say Cowboy Bebop, Akira, and Crest Of The Stars. I like Kenshin and Trigun a lot too, but they suffer from the SD disease that is so common in anime.

Todd McF · 04-22-2005, 07:17 AM

Feel free to dislike it - I do appreciate your explanation, that's all I was looking for. Its a hugely popular show so when someone says it "sucks" its worth discussing.

Indulge me here:

One thing I've noticed about FMA is that they keep things extremely light until the sh*t hits the fan. Very much like Chrno Crusade. Edward gets the short jokes, gets deformed when he flips out, gets knocked down / taken out easily - until the sh*t hits the fan. Then he shifts modes and gets competent - and the series gets dead serious. The end of episode 2 and all of episode 3 are dead serious - especially after all the campy humour.

As far as the deformation - I can't stand it either. If you think FMA is bad be prepared for Chrno Crusade. That's another show that goes campy to ultra serious. Its a jarring transition.

If you watch the first 3 Full Metal Alchemist episodes in sequence the show will either hook you or not, and give you an opportunity to adjust to its style. Again its alot like Chrno Crusade - I hated the first episode but by episode #4 I was totally hooked, just like FMA.

Todd McF · 04-22-2005, 07:23 AM

Hey James,

Watch out for Rahxephon with your daughter. There are some pretty rough sequences in that show - death, broken bodies, lots of blood etc.

I havent introduced my 4 year old Anime yet - but I'd start with "Kiki's Delivery Service". Its an amazing movie - less scary than for the little guys than "Spirited Away".

Just my 2 cents.

Woo Jae · 04-22-2005, 08:51 AM

I'd agree, there are parts of Rahxephon that are pretty intense.

Maybe I should qualify my statement on Ghibli films in general with a (as usual) general disclaimer. Because I am too lazy to write up specific one for anime, I'd advocate that the parent watch the show BEFORE showing it to the child and decide what shows are appropriate, as different people find different things objectionable.

For the most part, most of the Ghibli films I've seen have a universal appeal that is apparent to almost all ages. That said, Mononoke-Hime (Princess Mononoke) and even Kaze no Tani no Nausicaa (Nausicaa in the Valley of the Wind) are probably a bit on the serious side, with the former being more violent. But I also feel that we should give kids credit for their own "adultness" and not shield them from things unnecessarily. Which is where most Ghibli Flicks by Miyazaki really excel - they combine incredible animation with imagination and a very well scripted and plotted story. The only studio similar to this in US is PIXAR's works, whose head John Lassetter (sp?) has said he was inspired by Ghibli to create such films. Where the violence is not gratuitous and an important part of the story (and the story itself- by definition - be worthy viewing material) I feel it's OK to expose a child to some violence.

This is of course a very personal decision, and as a single person, I can't and don't presume to dictate that is how others should handle this issue.

Now on to more "regular" posts - I watched Kiddy grade #3-5, and the show did seriously shape up into an interesting blend of action, politics and fun. Hope to finish it tonight.

Todd McF · 04-22-2005, 09:00 AM

Good point - its absolutely a personal decision. I just wanted go give him the heads up where that series heads.

Speaking of rough material - saw Kite Uncut last night. Mezzo Forte was a better flick but the gunplay in Kite was simply awesome. I loved it. Its kind of the reverse of Mezzo Forte - the violence in Kite is over the top compared to Mezzo while the sex in Mezzo was over the top compared to Kite.

Anyway, I thought Kite was great but there is a sequence at the very end that should have been executed with more dramatic effect. That was my only gripe.

Woo Jae · 04-22-2005, 09:15 AM

Hopefully my last word on this topic ^_^;

Some other things to note is that at some point, our kids will be exposed to violence and curse words and sex and everything else - much as we were. As a parent you really can't seal off the child in a vacuum of a world where there are only happy things around. The best anyone can do is to be open, honest, and supportive of the child as well as lead by example. But how to raise a child is a very tough thing to do in any day and age - especially when both parents have to work to make money to support a family.

Anyhow, that said - I am hoping to order a few things from DDD today to finish off a few series, and start new ones.